Manchester United are out of the Champions League after a 1-0 home defeat to Atletico Madrid saw them beaten 2-1 on aggregate
Renan Lodi's first-half header was enough to take Diego Simeone's side into the quarter-finals as Ralf Rangnick's team endured a frustrating evening at Old Trafford
Anthony Elanga had appeared to be fouled in the build-up to the goal but United lacked the spark at the other end that was required to break down a resolute Atletico
Already out of the FA Cup, the defeat means that United's slim hopes of ending their long trophy drought this season are at an end, with goalkeeper David de Gea later admitting: "There are too many years without any trophies
"Manchester United were the more enterprising team for much of the first half as they tried to press Atletico with some success, rushing the Spanish side to the delight of the crowd
Raphael Varane's tackle on Joao Felix was cheered, Fred's flicks and tricks brought roars, while Cristiano Ronaldo was winning tackles by the touchline, dribbling down the wing
There were moments, hints that Atletico might fold
 Elanga spurned a wonderful chance from close range
 Bruno Fernandes wanted a penalty
 Nothing was given
The Atletico forwards had only long balls to work with for much of the opening 45 minutes but when they did play, it was United's frailty that was systematically exposed
The warning came just before the goal, Marcos Llorente narrowly offside when setting up Joao Felix to score
 The Atletico wing-backs had too much space
 It proved costly
Elanga appeared to have been fouled at the other end but Atletico were soon through United, Joao Felix's backheel finding Antoine Griezmann whose cross was headed in by Lodi
De Gea, who had earlier pulled off an extraordinary save to keep out Rodrigo De Paul's speculative shot, could do nothing
 Diogo Dalot could not say the same
A response was needed
 Elanga drove wide, Fred dragged another past the other post to Ronaldo's disgust, before Jadon Sancho volleyed the ball into the Stretford End
Rangnick made a triple substitution midway through the second half
 Fernandes was withdrawn
 But the formation stayed the same until Edinson Cavani came on for Fred
Jan Oblak did save well from Varane but the final substitution only capped a miserable night - captain Harry Maguire jeered off as he was replaced by Juan Mata
"I think we played a good first half," said Rangnick
 "All those things we planned to do we did
 The only thing we did not do was convert that energy into scoring the first goal ourselves
 One thing we cannot do against Atletico is concede the first goal
"Rangnick was frustrated that the officials did not award the foul on Elanga in the build-up to the game's only goal
 "I did not think we should have been 1-0 down," he said
 "For me that was a foul on Elanga
 That was the only really dangerous moment, apart from the offside goal that they scored," he said on 
The Man Utd interim manager felt the officials allowed Atletico to get away with antics which disrupted the flow of the game
 "The second half, I don't know if the game was played for more than two minutes without someone down on the floor
 There were some curious decisions, I don't know if they were decisive
"He added on : "We had one or two good moments where we should have scored
 Conceding that counter-attacking goal before half time didn't make life any easier for us
"In the second half it was difficult - it was always interrupted with somebody lying on the floor
 [The ref] fell for those time-wasting antics and four minutes extra time was a joke
""There are too many years without any trophies, even without fighting for trophies," De Gea said
"So I think we need to be clear we want to achieve good things, fight for trophies, we don't just want to play for the top four and be there, get out of the Champions League in the quarter-finals
 Something like this
"We need much more from everyone because this club is too big for where we are now"So we need much more from everyone because this club is too big for where we are now
 We are far from the fighting places for the Premier League, for the Champions League, so we need much more from everyone
""It was very stable," said Simeone of his own team's performance
"They caused us some issues down the sides, they started to cause us problems, then we changed things
 Griezmann worked hard down the right and that enabled us to be better positioned
"But it was not just this
 We managed to hit them on the counter and that confirmed that the solutions were going to be there
 I think the team really knew what they needed to do today
"In the second half, we controlled the game and that made us more comfortable
 We knew the opponent likes to play on the counter-attack so we decided to deny them the spaces
"There was little realistic chance of Manchester United pulling off something extraordinary in this Champions League
 The Premier League table reveals the gulf between them and their domestic rivals even before the best clubs from continental Europe are considered
However, this was still a dismal evening for United because it was so predictable
 Punished on the counter-attack after being exposed in the wide areas, what followed was grim: United trying to find a way through Atletico Madrid's defensive block
 Ideas lacking
Rangnick said afterwards that the one thing not to do against Atletico is concede first
 That is what they did
 Simeone understood the one thing that his team had to do
 "We knew the opponent likes to play on the counter-attack," he said
 Sit back
 Let United have it
What followed was turgid
 United passed it to one side and then to the other
 Crosses came in
 Fodder for these centre-backs
 An increasingly desperate Ronaldo tried to knock it past a defender and run round him
 Maybe 10 years ago
The fans at Old Trafford were vocal in the support at the start, seeing their side press their opponents, there was a real sense of occasion and signs that the team were up for the challenge