Can 'Sophie turned toward the teddy bear, lifted his paw, and exclaimed,  She wants a lollipop to hold in her hand! ' be viewed as neither a logical extension nor a contradiction of 'The teddy bear was holding a lollipop so Sophie asked for one too.'
Sophie turned toward the teddy bear, lifted his paw, and exclaimed,  She wants a lollipop to hold in her hand! ###The teddy bear was holding a lollipop so Sophie asked for one too.