In the context of 'Rosy, too, had seen the tune as Muskrat, Muskat , and Muscat .  I asked him what he thought the original title was.', does 'Rosy had seen the tune with several names.' serve as a direct counterargument?
Rosy, too, had seen the tune as Muskrat, Muskat , and Muscat .  I asked him what he thought the original title was.###Rosy had seen the tune with several names.