You should replace items you have broken.
Rick is hanging out at his best friend Ryan's apartment one day and accidentally knocks a vase off the counter in Ryan's kitchen.
Rick needs to decide how to respond to breaking the vase.
Rick apologizes to Ryan and asks for the product name, so he can buy a replacement off Amazon.
Rick tells Ryan tough luck, and that she should be more careful where he puts vases in the future.
Ryan thinks Rick is pretty thoughtful and tells him there's no need to buy a replacement.
Ryan thinks Rick is kind of a prick and tells him to get out of his apartment.