This was a fun breakfast stop during an October trip to Montreal. It was neat seeing the bagels being thrown into a pile after being freshly made. I enjoyed my bagel, though the taste was different from a NY bagel - growing up on Long Island, those were my default bagels, so I may be biased. I did enjoy the option of a rosemary bagel though. I would say this place is worth a stop overall if you're in the area or don't mind traveling a bit off the beaten path. I would give it a 3.5 if I could.