Visited GiGi's while on vacation in Madison, early on a Thursday afternoon.   This was my first time at a GiGi's, and I must say my first impression was of mostly empty cases with only about 3/4ths of the advertised flavors on display.  Yes, as other folks have said, the frosting to cake ratio is insane!  I asked the girl at the counter if the frostings were butter cream, she seemed a little unsure about some of the flavors, but since I dislike cream cheese frosting I wanted to know - of course I inadvertently selected a flavor with a cream cheese frosting, but I should have asked more specifically.  My niece had the Peanut Butter Cup, and I must say I loved her frosting much more than mine.  The cake itself was just okay, I'm guessing the allure of Gigi's  is the over-the-top frosting and sugar overload.  I definitely could have used a glass of milk to cut the sweetness!