Fish cakes are good. Lobster roll was good. Great fancy bloody mary. Oysters are not any better than other places in Madison which isn't saying much. What I mean by this is that both times I tried the oysters here they were small, deflated and had at least 1-2 per dozen that were frankly unpleasant to eat. I love oyster shots but the oyster in the one I got did not taste fresh. Menu has nice variety. The bar and dining room are loud. I wish they would have considered acoustics on the re-design. When the place is crowded conversation is nearly impossible.\nI would never choose to go to this place over Osteria Popavero next door which always has outstanding seafood.