What the hey!??? How come I have never heard of this place before?  Went here for a date night with my boyfriend (we've been together 13 years so date night is mostly about good food- less cheesy romantic sh*t).  The burger was delicious- buttery bun. I had chili which was also wonderfully tasty.  The sweet potato fries were nice and crispy.  My whiskey coke was strong.  Decor is not fancy but who cares- food is good!  Bartender lady was super nice....not too overbearing- just whatever- I like that.  There is one pool table, some video gambling things.  Best of all- they have karaoke on Thursday nights.  I haven't checked out karaoke yet but gonna do it this Thursday.  Also, Tuesday is 25 cent wings- really yummy and cheap.  I love this place- one of my new fav places in Madison- truly local spot- if you like Caribou Tavern, you'll love Baldwin St. Grille.