For all it could be, I feel the New York - New York is completely hit and miss.  As for entertainment, food, and hotel, it's pretty good compared to other casinos on the strip.  As for casino play, I feel it just falls flat compared to others.  I've stayed here before and was impressed with the hotel features.  I've seen Zumanity and have eaten at a couple of their restaurants and liked those as well.  But in the end, it didn't seem as alive as other casinos and for that, I'd say it's A-OK!  Not a place I need to go to each time I'm in town, but worth going to if you're in a casino hoping mood.