I'm an out of towner so maybe I'm used to a different kind of pizza.  I use Yelp almost exclusively to decide on the fly what to order and more importantly where to order when I'm out of town, so there is an element of trust that I've grown used to .  I was visiting relatives in the El Mirage area and they live here 2-3 months out of the year and they said Mario's was good based on word of mouth from their friends. Seemed like a slam dunk to phone in an order, pick it up and be grubbing shortly thereafter.  Service was great during pickup. The pizzas was some of the worst we've had when we got home. There was no delay in eating them. The pizzas lacked proper amounts of toppings, had limp crust and generally didn't look good.  I usually leave good reviews on Yelp as I'd rather say good then bad but this pizza just isn't recommended.