We go to NY 54 at least twice a month.  We love to buy the 18\" thin crust pizza, and since there are four of us, we have it made with different toppings on each quarter.  They are always happy to make the pizza to our order.  Also, they have a good selection of draft beers - I highly recommend giving those a try.  I did try their margarita, but it did not have enough alcohol content for my liking, although the taste was excellent.  There is also a great selection of desserts, which I always buy and take some home for later!