I live in the States about 11/2 hr drive to Gibby's.  We have been going to Gibby's for over 10 years.  When we have a visitors or something to celebrate or just haveing a Gibby's craving we will make the short trip,  It is well worth the drive.  I have eaten at all the top steak house's in the US.. Morton's, Ruth Chris, Flemings, Capital Grill and more.  Gibby's is in a class all of its own.  The combination of old world ambiance, great service, consistently great food and out of this world desserts makes it a must go to if you are in the Montreal area.  After your very satisfying meal you can roam about Old Montreal on foot or take a ride in one of the many horse drawn carriages that you will find in the area.