Had I written this review 5 years ago while still a poor student at Madison, I probably would've given it a 3.  Probably because I was too young, and didn't have much appreciation for a bar that wasn't overcrowded with drunkards swaying to polka music.  Now that I appreciate a bar where you can actually play darts without some 19 year old vomiting on your jeans, I have to agree with the other reviewers.  Drinks are cheap, good, and large, too.