Cartwright's has redeemed itself! The hubs & I decided to give it another go after none of our usual Cave Creek/Carefree haunts held our interests that night. Unlike last time we avoided the steaks, but the hubs had fish & I had the prime rib. Everything was excellent. The service, which was never the issue in the first place, was absolutely top notch, and the waiter brought me several samples of wine when I couldn't decide which I wanted. Tip: This is a great way to get the equivalent of a free glass of wine ; )  Speaking of wine, they have wine tasting classes several times a month. We'll be adding this back into our restaurant rotation.