Question:
Which position did Karen Gillon hold in Jul, 2008?

Context:
 Karen Gillon holds the position of Member of the 2nd Scottish Parliament from May, 2003 to Apr, 2007. 
 Karen Gillon holds the position of Member of the 3rd Scottish Parliament from May, 2007 to Mar, 2011. 
 Karen Gillon holds the position of Member of the 1st Scottish Parliament from May, 1999 to Mar, 2003.

Answer:
Question:
Which position did Karen Gillon hold in Jul, 2008?

Context:
 Karen Gillon holds the position of Member of the 2nd Scottish Parliament from May, 2003 to Apr, 2007. 
 Karen Gillon holds the position of Member of the 3rd Scottish Parliament from May, 2007 to Mar, 2011. 
 Karen Gillon holds the position of Member of the 1st Scottish Parliament from May, 1999 to Mar, 2003.

Answer:
user
Member of the 3rd Scottish Parliament
assistant
Question:
Which position did Karen Gillon hold in Jul, 2008?

Context:
 Karen Gillon holds the position of Member of the 2nd Scottish Parliament from May, 2003 to Apr, 2007. 
 Karen Gillon holds the position of Member of the 3rd Scottish Parliament from May, 2007 to Mar, 2011. 
 Karen Gillon holds the position of Member of the 1st Scottish Parliament from May, 1999 to Mar, 2003.

Answer:
user
Member of the 1st Scottish Parliament
Member of the 2nd Scottish Parliament
assistant
Question:
Which position did Karen Gillon hold in Jul, 2008?

Context:
 Karen Gillon holds the position of Member of the 2nd Scottish Parliament from May, 2003 to Apr, 2007. 
 Karen Gillon holds the position of Member of the 3rd Scottish Parliament from May, 2007 to Mar, 2011. 
 Karen Gillon holds the position of Member of the 1st Scottish Parliament from May, 1999 to Mar, 2003.

Answer:
user
Member of the 3rd Scottish Parliament
assistant