Question:
Which position did Alexander Struthers Finlay hold in May, 1857?

Context:
 Alexander Struthers Finlay holds the position of Member of the 19th Parliament of the United Kingdom from Jul, 1865 to Feb, 1868. 
 Alexander Struthers Finlay holds the position of Member of the 18th Parliament of the United Kingdom from Apr, 1859 to Jul, 1865. 
 Alexander Struthers Finlay holds the position of Member of the 17th Parliament of the United Kingdom from Mar, 1857 to Apr, 1859.

Answer:
Question:
Which position did Alexander Struthers Finlay hold in May, 1857?

Context:
 Alexander Struthers Finlay holds the position of Member of the 19th Parliament of the United Kingdom from Jul, 1865 to Feb, 1868. 
 Alexander Struthers Finlay holds the position of Member of the 18th Parliament of the United Kingdom from Apr, 1859 to Jul, 1865. 
 Alexander Struthers Finlay holds the position of Member of the 17th Parliament of the United Kingdom from Mar, 1857 to Apr, 1859.

Answer:
user
Member of the 17th Parliament of the United Kingdom
assistant
Question:
Which position did Alexander Struthers Finlay hold in May, 1857?

Context:
 Alexander Struthers Finlay holds the position of Member of the 19th Parliament of the United Kingdom from Jul, 1865 to Feb, 1868. 
 Alexander Struthers Finlay holds the position of Member of the 18th Parliament of the United Kingdom from Apr, 1859 to Jul, 1865. 
 Alexander Struthers Finlay holds the position of Member of the 17th Parliament of the United Kingdom from Mar, 1857 to Apr, 1859.

Answer:
user
Member of the 18th Parliament of the United Kingdom
Member of the 19th Parliament of the United Kingdom
assistant
Question:
Which position did Alexander Struthers Finlay hold in May, 1857?

Context:
 Alexander Struthers Finlay holds the position of Member of the 19th Parliament of the United Kingdom from Jul, 1865 to Feb, 1868. 
 Alexander Struthers Finlay holds the position of Member of the 18th Parliament of the United Kingdom from Apr, 1859 to Jul, 1865. 
 Alexander Struthers Finlay holds the position of Member of the 17th Parliament of the United Kingdom from Mar, 1857 to Apr, 1859.

Answer:
user
Member of the 17th Parliament of the United Kingdom
assistant