Question:
Which position did Charles Nqakula hold in Sep, 2008?

Context:
 Charles Nqakula holds the position of member of the National Assembly of South Africa from May, 2014 to Jun, 2018. 
 Charles Nqakula holds the position of Minister of Police from May, 2002 to Sep, 2008. 
 Charles Nqakula holds the position of Minister of Defence of South Africa from Sep, 2008 to Apr, 2009.

Answer:
Question:
Which position did Charles Nqakula hold in Sep, 2008?

Context:
 Charles Nqakula holds the position of member of the National Assembly of South Africa from May, 2014 to Jun, 2018. 
 Charles Nqakula holds the position of Minister of Police from May, 2002 to Sep, 2008. 
 Charles Nqakula holds the position of Minister of Defence of South Africa from Sep, 2008 to Apr, 2009.

Answer:
user
Minister of Defence of South Africa
assistant
Question:
Which position did Charles Nqakula hold in Sep, 2008?

Context:
 Charles Nqakula holds the position of member of the National Assembly of South Africa from May, 2014 to Jun, 2018. 
 Charles Nqakula holds the position of Minister of Police from May, 2002 to Sep, 2008. 
 Charles Nqakula holds the position of Minister of Defence of South Africa from Sep, 2008 to Apr, 2009.

Answer:
user
member of the National Assembly of South Africa
member of the National Assembly of South Africa
assistant
Question:
Which position did Charles Nqakula hold in Sep, 2008?

Context:
 Charles Nqakula holds the position of member of the National Assembly of South Africa from May, 2014 to Jun, 2018. 
 Charles Nqakula holds the position of Minister of Police from May, 2002 to Sep, 2008. 
 Charles Nqakula holds the position of Minister of Defence of South Africa from Sep, 2008 to Apr, 2009.

Answer:
user
Minister of Defence of South Africa
assistant