Question:
Which position did Ian Macdonald Horobin hold in Sep, 1952?

Context:
 Ian Macdonald Horobin holds the position of Member of the 36th Parliament of the United Kingdom from Oct, 1931 to Oct, 1935. 
 Ian Macdonald Horobin holds the position of Member of the 40th Parliament of the United Kingdom from Oct, 1951 to May, 1955. 
 Ian Macdonald Horobin holds the position of Member of the 41st Parliament of the United Kingdom from May, 1955 to Sep, 1959.

Answer:
Question:
Which position did Ian Macdonald Horobin hold in Sep, 1952?

Context:
 Ian Macdonald Horobin holds the position of Member of the 36th Parliament of the United Kingdom from Oct, 1931 to Oct, 1935. 
 Ian Macdonald Horobin holds the position of Member of the 40th Parliament of the United Kingdom from Oct, 1951 to May, 1955. 
 Ian Macdonald Horobin holds the position of Member of the 41st Parliament of the United Kingdom from May, 1955 to Sep, 1959.

Answer:
user
Member of the 40th Parliament of the United Kingdom
assistant
Question:
Which position did Ian Macdonald Horobin hold in Sep, 1952?

Context:
 Ian Macdonald Horobin holds the position of Member of the 36th Parliament of the United Kingdom from Oct, 1931 to Oct, 1935. 
 Ian Macdonald Horobin holds the position of Member of the 40th Parliament of the United Kingdom from Oct, 1951 to May, 1955. 
 Ian Macdonald Horobin holds the position of Member of the 41st Parliament of the United Kingdom from May, 1955 to Sep, 1959.

Answer:
user
Member of the 41st Parliament of the United Kingdom
Member of the 36th Parliament of the United Kingdom
assistant
Question:
Which position did Ian Macdonald Horobin hold in Sep, 1952?

Context:
 Ian Macdonald Horobin holds the position of Member of the 36th Parliament of the United Kingdom from Oct, 1931 to Oct, 1935. 
 Ian Macdonald Horobin holds the position of Member of the 40th Parliament of the United Kingdom from Oct, 1951 to May, 1955. 
 Ian Macdonald Horobin holds the position of Member of the 41st Parliament of the United Kingdom from May, 1955 to Sep, 1959.

Answer:
user
Member of the 40th Parliament of the United Kingdom
assistant