i understand the draw and appeal to such a different type of movie and i be a huge admirer of movie with little dialog but all the same this one absolutely terrible . i have be to the scottish highland and find the lack of scottish accent in the character disappoint . this plot be strong enough in theory but the cheap set and lack of a single realistic character keep this film from get off the ground . i feel the use of silence to create atmosphere only work when you have actor who can exude some sort of presence without speaking and these actor certainly cant . if you want a silent movie that capture that presence try ( le dernier combat ) . there have be very few movie that i couldn not even manage to finish and this be one of them . absolute dribble .