i be extremely excite for this movie . my expectation be under control because i read the book first sooo i expect difference . what i do not expect be how great the difference be . start off by the character physical appearance . like channing tantums lack of tattoo n amanda seyfried not be a brunette lol but i let that go . the character development be not there at all . you do not have time to love amanda seyfried character and you couldn not feel for her or for john when they first separate . i think the two week be rush and i hat that she leave first then him . it take the emotional separation away . and why do they change tim from the book . why do they make him a dad instead of a brother and why do they make him sooo old look and the movie lack that intense moment when they find out what happen at the end ( didnt want to spoil it lol but for those who watch it u know what i mean ) and whhhyyyy ooooo wwhyyyy do they change the end . in the book it be heartbreaking and emotional and it emphasize on channing tatum character decision whhyyy do they twist it . it just make it look like a rushed end . it be terrible . thats what disappoint me the most . the end of the book should have be exactly the same negative .