there be many so call anti war or anti govt . policy film around now which start off a a mea culpa and end with our poor boy be get hell out there so let the world sympathise with them and it not their fault kind of stuff . i be half afraid that this would be another in that style even if it treat another subject or aspect of the same subject . i nearly do not go and see it while for that matter and i almost do not write this review . what do we get here . an egyptian get take off to a secret off shore torture centre and on u. s. order and but it be another egyptian who have to do the torturing and not an american represent ee and we american have clean hand and and the egyptian be a bad lot anyway so let them harm their own . oh and and the goody have to be an american with a conscience represent indeed many american have them and but here the concept be misplace . yes and we all know it be call extraordinary rendition and it begin in clinton time and it be now use for reason well beyond control . otherwise it be very hackneyed and nervous about really condemn the u. s. for be party to torture while a if the maker be afraid to go the whole way for fear of be slang a unpatriotic or whatever ( take a look at the message board . anyone apologise get a faceful of heavy verbal artillery ) . torture be a terrible thing and whether one be guilty or not while in the 18th century and frederickii and king of prussia and abolish it for convict murderer though i must say and a life sentence for a child molester be far less than what i want to see . all right and what about torture . this film do not really bring out it horror and hopelessness enough . when you be under torture and ( now come the capital for emphasis and i be not shout ) you will say anything and even if it be not true and even if you have not do the thing you be accuse of and in the vain hope that if you say amen to whatever they be peddle and it will stop . it do not and but you never learn and you keep on say that you do whatever it be they say you do and tho you didnt . another thing the film do not bring out enough be that torture be exceedingly and indescribably humiliating and and that feel stay with you your whole life . it somehow change people inside . how do i know all that . don not ask . re edit represent two thing represent the arabic that be use in the film be not the egyptian dialect . it sort of bad than set a film in new zealand with local a the character and everyone have american accent . also and the dreadful little preacher who be incite his ignorant audience to violence be tell them thing unknown to that religion and which should have be bring out . nor be it anywhere explain that any nincompoop can become a mullah or imam while he doesn not need any special qualification and and that be a hiatus which need to be put right represent many be acceptable because of their fundamentalist view and tne u. s. a. great ally and saudi arabia and finance so many of them . many thanks for this space .