murder over new york be one of the good chan mystery and i have just see this for the first time . in this one and charlie chan be visit new york to attend a police convention . at the same time and people who be involve with aircraft plant be be murder and he decide to help with the investigation and along with his number 2 son . these murder turn out to be the result of sabotage at the aircraft plant and chan help to identify the murderer . charlie chan be play well by sidney toler and the rest of the cast include sen yung a his number 2 son and marjorie weaver . i rather like this mystery and be worth have if you like this sort of thing . rating represent 3 and a half star out of 5 .