i must say it be a let down . overall it great to see the way aparna sen have handle the issue of schizophrenia and i be not much knowledgeable on this and get whatever it be depict in a beautiful mind and and here too it interesting portrayal . but the thing that cause the let down for me be the artificial dialogue and over use of english . it true that a new class be be form or have be form in india which talk in english even at home and but i be sure it not as formal a in the movie . moreover and waheeda rehmaan do not seem very comfortable talk everything in english . charu dialogue in bihari tone be seemingly much more realistic and digestible . the second thing and it about the abstract flavor she have try to give to the movie . i generally like movie with open end and but here there be many loose end . it like cut piece be join together to make the movie . also there seem no central theme to the movie . schizophernia for sure be the main line but intermingle sister sister and mother daughter and add doctor azmi relation and no real use of brother and bose bose wife relation . all be not require and make the audience loose track of what actually do she try to depict . on the whole and a watch for people who like off beat movie and a must avoid for the one who just see movie a an entertainment tool .