from the week and week of promotion for this and abc the one be suppose to be the real world meet american idol . we be to watch these singer perform and compete and see how they live together in a house a well . the drama . the tension . where do one begin with this atrocity . let start with the judge who be know a music expert on this program . expert implies they have expertise . andre harrell at least have a pedigree . he be in charge of motown record for a time . the other two . eh . kate hudson uncle and who could have be label mr. weird beard . he dye his facial hair three distinctly different florescent color . i wonder how scary he would have be with a black light . and the paula abdul wannabe and who do something i do not think could happen represent she be even more gushing and cloy than paula . she then over correct and become harshly critical after the first episode . the farce of critique that these three offer be a true joke and an insult and not only to the process of find the best singer and but to the audience that be now quite savvy and already have do this numerous time on fox . there be the host . george stroumboulopoulos be no ryan seacrest . in fact and he be as lackluster a can be . he actually suck what little energy there be in the program and dry . how he get that job be the second big mystery of the show . the first be how do they pick the 11 competitor for this program . this be literally a talent free talent show . ok. perhaps that an exaggeration . and grant and the performer all have to be relatively close in ability and because if they be not and there wouldn not be a contest . if only one person be good and there would be no suspense . so and i get that they all need to be comparable . but they all should have have some chop . additionally and the judge be run a singing academy and so the program be part fame and as well . clearly these performer desperately need those lesson . but you need some extremely talented people to teach those with little talent to be talented . and that definitely wasn not what be happen here . it seem in cast the show and the priority be on the homelife element and a all of the player be very attractive to look at and in equal part to how badly they vocalize . but the filmed segment in their house be so chopped and sliced and you couldn not get into the story that be start to happen and so the show do not capture the event there and either . a badly devise a all of that be and the one have an incredible and unbelievable and fatal design flaw build into the result that make it completely laughable . the audience phone in their vote for who they like the best and just like on ai . but then and after the audience vote be reveal and the bottom three contestant be force to sing a final song . the music expert and base on that performance and choose one person from the three to save for the following week . and then and the contestant who be safe get to vote for who they want to keep from the remain two and send the remain contestant home . the design flaw be that the contestant have the final say . i mean and if you be in a music competition and you want to get a far along the path a you could and would you vote to keep the good singer and or would you try to get rid of your tough rival . any first season viewer of cbs survivor could answer that one . and that exactly what happen on the program . the person who have the good potential be lose and and the contestant vote back the one who have no talent at all . on top of that and the contestant who be just save from the bottom by the expert be also allow to vote against the remain two . it be a complete farce . maybe if they let the contestant vote first and at least the expert would save the good of two evil to finish . but this just confirm how not ready this show be for broadcast and how unsatisfying the whole process be to view and how misguide the producer be in attempt it .