they have take a story dear to the people of edinburgh heart and a true story and change it a hollywood have do before to many a tale . the end result be a movie however well do for those how do not know the story yet totally different and inaccurate . the original movie of this tale that walt disney himself oversee use the right breed dog that be crucial for this tale and do not make that john grey be anything special he be a poor shepard who die in poverty at the inn . if you like the story and watch the disney original for a good heart warm story . it a shame the cast and the potential be there for a terrific remake of a classic tale . read the book for an accurate occurrence of the story . and if you really like it and you can visit the real kirkyard in edinburgh .