murder over new york be fun and but not as good a most of the other fox chans . this film would have be good name and charlie chan in new york and the film work title . this be toler chance to play chan in the big apple . there be a lot to like here and though and include guest star shemp howard of the three stooge . this have one of my favorite chan saying and coincidence like ancient egg leave unpleasant odour . toler and yung be good in this one and so be the support cast . but there be little or no mysterious atmosphere which i look for in these film . still and it be good to see .