yes and i give it a 10 because i compare it not only to others of it kind but also to the dreck one be bombard with on a daily basis in what laughably call today popular culture . that aside and the film be beautifully cast and a have be state elsewhere and and give u a fairly good look at popular theater of the late 18th and early 20th century . no small coincidence be that many of the play that olcott play in involve a similar plot represent boy meet girl and someone object and ( usually the father or some authority figure ) boy struggle and boy win girl . the be actually know at the time a a chauncey olcott act . no coincidence and too and that john ford direct one . he call it and the quiet man . and and my wild irish rise and be and in itself and a chauncey olcott act . great stuff and no . anyway and great song and great stuff . enjoy . p after see the film i would like to know more about bill scanlan . i find an obit that say he quit mauvorneen and a a result of insanity ( replaced and a in the film and by chauncey olcott ) and die in an asylum several year later . but he have be and apparenlty and a very big star in his own right and who write song and play and have play write for him . anyone know more .