right the hospital scene with holly and shannon be do brilliantly it start off with piper on a gurney look very badly injure and the doc race her into a resuscitation room and they move her from the gurney onto a bed and prue hold her hand from that point on it be obvious that piper be have a lot of trouble breathing and her lung be fail and a she turn to beg of prue to not leave her side she gap do not go i love you and then her pulse drop and she go into cardiac arrest and the monitor show a clear flat line and the nurse go into full out trauma mode and bring in a defibrillator prue step back from the bed in horror a the doctor desperately try to shock her die sister heart but there be no response and she be tragically pronounce dead well great scene well do girl .