this film be a work of pure class from start to finish and for a moment forget the famous 28 minute no dialog heist and forget that it set in paris and forget it noir . the film itself and the premise and the execution make this a pure gold experience . it sharp intelligent and think through in great detail and just like the heist itself . it portray real character that be not only believable but whom you empathize with . it a film that doesn not glamorize the notion of a robbery but show it for what it be . theft . it show that a heist be hard work and ultimately not worth do . now all thing consider put on top of that a dare 28 minute sequence with not a word spoken and set in gorgeous paris with truly great attention to detail and fantastic cinematography and that last scene . when you look up and see those tree . wonderful use of raw and basic filming technique . it be a master piece in my view and i be glad to have see it .