much a i really like catherine zeta jones and i wonder once again and why remake a good movie . this version lack the tension and passion of mostly martha . it be a clear rip off . maxime foerste be more convincing a a hurting child who heal with love . i couldn not believe abigail breslin . martina gedeck own this role . unfortunately zeta jones should have find another one that she could own ( she have other role she do own . ) . sergio castellitto be good a a vulnerable but joyful italian . aaron eckhart seem passionless in comparison . this version be pleasant but bland . the love between mario and martha be perhaps predictable but satisfy . the therapist add an interesting bit of color that do not seem important . i like it when at the end he say he would be back but the movie be over before he return . i have mostly martha at home . every now and then i revisit it .