i watch this episode a lot of time because i do not get how prue die . this be what happen . prue and piper and and phoebe try and save their innocent and a doctor and because shax want to kill him . phoebe go upstairs to look in the book of shadow while prue and piper be protect their innocent . shax appear while phoebe be still upstairs and so shax throw an energy ball at the doctor but prue push him out of the way and prue get hit in the chest with it and smash against the wall and same with piper . so phoebe come downstairs and say the spell and since it be only phoebe who say it and not the power of three shax only get wound . phoebe call leo to heal piper and prue . so leo heals them . phoebe go into the underworld to find cole and meanwhile prue and piper be look for shax in the street . piper and prue see shax and piper use her power to blow up shax and meanwhile a new reporter get it all on tape . so it all over the new about the three powerful halliwell sister and meanwhile phoebe doesn not know anything because she be still in the underworld . there repoters and people all over the halliwell house . then a maniac come in the house and say can i be part of your coven . and prue say no this be our house get out of here . and prue use her power to throw her out . a the maniac come out of the house cry say there mean witch . the maniac get so mad that she shoot piper right through the stomach . prue get in her car and tray to go to the hospital but people would not let her through and so prue use her power to move people out of the way and make people wan na kill her more . they get to the hospital but piper do not make it . meanwhile phoebe be in the underworld . phoebe find out that they have be expose and so phoebe asks cole to ask the source if he can reverse time . the source say he will only reverse time if phoebe promise to stay here in the underworld and so cole tell phoebe what the source tell him . phoebe say what would make him think i would make a deal like that . and then cole say and so you can save one of your sister life . leo go to the hospital to find out the piper really be dead so he tell phoebe that it true . then phoebe agrees to stay only if cole will go back to warn piper and prue about the exposer and death of piper . back at the hospital swat be about the shoot prue and but the second before they do time be rewound back when they be at the manor with the doctor but this time phoebe wasn not there to call leo to heal prue and piper and so the doctor get throw in the wall too . the doctor die and so do prue . but this be what i do not get and if piper be throw against the wall too how come only prue die . why do they not show leo come and heal piper and leo try to heal prue . if you know the answer please e mail me at angelpuss924 @ yahoo . com p . i miss prue but i like paige too and i be glad the show continue .