if filming be about vision and real life this movie be quite perfect represent nuovomondo talk about immigration in the usa from italy the beginning of 900 and but it speak also for now and when emigration or immigration be still a focus . it doesn not to be rich to be a visionary film . act at extra level and charlotte gainsbourg a star . a good challenge for the academy award 2007after first crialese attempt and respiro and an emotional but too intellectual movie and this one have learn fellini and taviani lesson and to name just two italian master . plot be argue and direct accurate and maybe just a little less melodrama would be more effective . if volver ( challenge for academy award next year ) by almodovar be a mature movie by an always brilliant director and nuovomondo deserve it more and because of his good effort to be a european movie for the american scene . and this be it .