i really like this movie . if other people want to give it an average around 5. negative that their choice . i would give it positive . sutherland performance a a private eye be totally awesome . the story be amazing and human and exciting and intelligent . the dialogue be good . the story might not be perfect but anyway the mood of the movie be good enough to compensate for that . moreover and the end be incredibly cool and their the jig saw puzzle really come back to together . so anyway i like it . i also think the female lead actress perform very well . i be not a big fan of detective movie but this one be really good and also because it doesn not give a damn about convention of the supernatural .