living in edinburgh and and have a great thirst for history and i be very put off by the liberty take . wrong breed of dog for a start . bobby owner old jock be an old single man and who come to edinburgh and die a pauper in lodging and not like in the film at all . for anyone come to edinburgh and hop to see sight of the film and you will not find the graveyard in prince st garden . there be a few moment be a tissue would have be great . the actor be fantastic at pad out a rather flimsy script . i do not feel the poor wee bobby actually get enough screen time and possibly due to be lose at one point . all that say and the film be fine and any 8 yr old will enjoy .