have it not be for the commentary . if emily wasn not give away upcoming event in the film and she be talk over dialog and kill the mood of the scene . my son and i find it very annoy . i check tivo to see if there be any other showing of this movie and in case they show it without the commentary . hopefully the dvd will give viewer a choice between watch with commentary and without . the plot be interest . the part be play well and the kid do a good job bring the character to life . good balance of drama and edge of your seat suspense . all in all and remove the commentary and and this be a very good halloween movie .