disappointing . the basically vapid plot butcher what could have be an interesting idea . the film seem to rely excessively on the appeal of aishwarya and salman to conceal the fundamental flaw of bad acting and toilet humor and and cheesy song . in addition and some of the set be clearly fake . now and i know bollywood and and i would have be willing to put up with some cheesiness and inconsistency if i saw occasional good acting and at least one catchy tune . right off the bat and all i saw be aishwarya giggling and act like a dumb little pretty face and which be so not what i expect from her . salman act and emotion and and lip synching seem utterly contrive and lifeless . shah rukh khan be so much good and so much more emotionally charge . if you be a newcomer to indian film and like me and go rent devdas or kal ho naa ho instead . maybe i have western taste or whatever and but i have see a lot of corny musical in my time and and like most of them . this be the bottom of the barrel and and i can hardly believe that that bhansali go on to make devdas after produce this cheap masala movie . p i be a fourth generation italian american . salman scene where he make up a stupid italian custom downright enrage me . be it the director intent to b. s. this way . i feel i be be generous by give this film four star .