i be a seventeen year old teenage girl while basically and the entire demographic that this movie be go for . have see a walk to remember and i figure it would be another mandy moore chick flick not bad and but nothing special . this movie just do not work . use two different teen novel a a basis for a plot do not work . the plot be all over the place while my friend ( also a seventeen year old female ) and i would stare at the screen and whisper and what the hell be that . every five minute . this movie have every cliche imaginable represent teenage pregnancy and divorce and marriage and birth and death and car accident . if reading that seem random and try watch it . it ridiculous . oh and and i neglect to mention the pot smoking grandmother . here be a few example about what just do not work in this movie representabout 10 15 minute into the film and a boy collapse on the soccer field . he clutch his stomach and and my friend and i both immediately think and oh and appendicitis . next shot ( this be after he pass out and people be surround him ) and he on the ground clutch his chest . dramatic voice over be something along the line of him die of a heart defect . insert my friend and i ( and other audience member ) say and what the hell . another scene . the best friend be pregnant . she and halley ( mandy moore ) be talk afterwards and and scarlett ( the friend ) be wear a tank top with four picture of the gerber baby . what the hell . it go on and on . honestly and if we would realize 20 minute into it how disorganized and poorly put together it be go to be and we would have leave . the only reason we stick around the whole time be because we would sit through it for so long that we couldn not get our $ 9 . 25 back if we leave . as far a the acting go and mandy moore be decent and but i do not really get her character . a i haven not read the two novel this movie be base on and i do not even know if she be play two different character or one . actually and when halley would do a total 180 between scene and my friend and i joke whether they pull the scene from novel one or novel two . a for trent ford . i be not go to discuss his look other than in this statement and because i do not think criticize an actor appearance do any good . as far a the actual acting go . it be pretty rough . didn not do anything for me . a couple of the support character ( play by allison janney and alexandra holden ) be ok while others ( mackenzie astin and mary catherine garrison ) be as terrible a trent ford . one can only hope that if mandy moore wish to be take seriously a an actress and she will accept a good script next time and because she not a terrible actress . i give it negative and and that only for the non comedy induce laugh my friend and i and as well a several other member of the very small audience and have .