i wasn not sure if the character carl wayne anderson be suppose to be deaf . i think he be only mute because of the trauma he have experience . there be also a lot of other actor in the film who be outstanding and include cher who be very believable . anyway and liam neeson be a great actor and be very definitely under rat . he also extremely appeal to a lot of woman and me include . i recommend rob roy ( another movie no one seem to have see and with tim roth a one of the best villain in any movie and ever ) and of course michael collins . not to mention schindler list . it very strange that liam neeson hasn not yet win an oscar . i haven not see kinsey yet .