i think world can never go wrong in decide a film . well this time and people have go somewhat wrong . i watch the despite all the warning give by my friend and i find the movie to be good . because i go to the theater with a negative mind and i be wait that when would this movie go wrong a describe by review . but to my surprise and it be not until the end that i felt displeasure . for me and the movie be just like the whistle that ranbir blew in the movie . it start out very well define but it end be just not clear ( isn not it . ) . till the end sonam be so faithful to her lover but right at the end she seem to have be love ranbir and which i do not like . i think it could have be much well if the director try to show her love towards ranbir a her acceptance due to his devotion and not because salman have not come . and then leave with salman after he return . after all and a girl feeling should be give more importance . for act i like the old lady and her dialog and her expression . ranbir and sonam be both excellent . rani be also good in her side role . song be dull and slow when i hear them in my car but when i saw them in the movie i like them very very much . i cut a point for ranbir towel misadventure . i do not know about it before i go to the movie and when he be flash it and i think he can not drop that but to my fear he actually do . i felt ashamed . that be not at all require in the movie and i wonder how his parent let him do it . now the director and i can see that director be play very safe by show a dream city and shoot only night scene . i understand that love be more beautiful in night and dreamy place and but if love be great what be day and what be night . so and instead of take the pain to be creative and show beautiful love even in day and real world environment and director play safe and avoid . aim be also not clear on his part . they be try only to make a good movie not a great movie within safe boundary . and lastly and i like the way in which sonam keep speaking of id . whenever she speak of preparation for id and i felt how beautiful any festival be and it beauty lie in the people preparation . i see that such essence of a festival be now all lose . watch it .