i think this be not a very good remake of the book this movie be base on . it change so many thing that would have make the story link together more and i be confuse at the beginning when hannah auny eva tell her she look like chaya . this do not make sense till i saw the part be she go back in time and she wasn not with gitl and shmuel and she be with rivka and someone else who i do not know because it confuse me . i think they could have make it almost exactly like the book and it wouldn not change the length at all . maybe only make be about half hour longer but it not that long to begin with so it wouldn not make a difference . within the first 30 minute they could have show her with a brother and cut out most of the rest of the family that be at the sader dinner . also they could have add what i thought be a key point from the book and when her grandpa will be mad when he be watch the news before the dinner . the whole part when she first go back in time be completely different . the only part that be right be that fayge ( leah ) and shmule be get marry . in the book they do not even get marry . the nazi be at the place where they be have the wedding and the nazi take them when they all arrive . in the book she wake up and gitl be make bread and shmuel be there and they be talk and then gitl help chaya ( hannah ) get ready for fayge ( leah ) and shumuel wedding . when she leave for the wedding she find a few girl and start tell them story of the future . when they arrive at the synagog ( do not know exact spell ) there be nazi wait there . they talk and explain that they be be relocate but chaya ( hannah ) know that they be go to take them to the concentration camp . there be never a violent push and shoving of the people go into the truck . i think the movie be act well but they could have cut out that part when they go get the picture take and thing like that .