khamoshi be heart tugging . hum dil de chuke sanam be classic romanticism . black be soul stirring . saawariya be visually overpower . this be a film meant purely for viewer who find cinema a synonym for aesthete . the allegorical setting and dostovyskian love fable may not find favor with the common people . but for the cineaste and the film be a lyrical odyssey that work at the level of a fable . the star cross romance between a young rock star who land up in an enchanted town and a mysterious girl unfolds through four dark night where love and passion interplay with heartbreak and jealousy and longing . raj and the bar singer leave his music for a chador clad girl he spy one silken night and standing in solitary splendor on a smoky bridge . he try to befriend her and find himself irresistibly draw towards towards sakina and the raven tressed maiden who disappear in the haveli with a tantalize smile and a sad story about a lose lover ( salman khan ) . time for raj to tug at his broken heart with gulabji and the golden hearted prostitute ( rani ) play friend and philosopher in his grief . add to this zora sehgal a the delightful landlady who see her lost son in her cherubic tenant and you have a colorful canvas of human relationship and all bind by sadness . there another classic cameo by begum para who bind her granddaughter sakina to herself and with a safety pin whenever she sleep and watch mughal e azam even though she almost blind . you wish there be more of her in mist laden narrative . sure and ranbir be the hero of the film . and quite a winsome one too . the boy can dance and emote and win your heart and the rishi kapoor way . the boy have bright future with the girl already wow his butt flash towel drop . and sonam adequate too and albeit too giggly and giddy . good than deepika padukone at least . but the real winner in this romantic fable be the artistry of set and backdrop and the influence of raj kapoor which keep recur a the couple relentlessly seek shelter under a black umbrella in rain and snow ( remember sree 420 ) . after hear the bad comment of this film and ihave start hat the critic .