this movie isn not bad and but i wasn not impressed either . the usual flashback way of tell the story be slightly change here represent one character tell u what happen and the second one confirm the situation and but put them in different context and give them different meaning and and some crucial moment be tell completely opposite . a the movie continue it become a bit boring and there be no real change and plot be straight and clear and predictable represent whole movie be build on only one question represent whose version be a true one . and and unfortunately and the final answer isn not surprising . this movie be an average and watchable and very forgettable story when you have nothing wiser to do . zal be disappointing ( so promise actress in her early movie like testament or amelia and i hop she will become something like mare winningham and but this movie maybe do not give her enough opportunity ) and perry be well in flashback scene and quite inconceivable when deal with her wife death and be a suspect for her murder and greene have too small part and i wonder how low can she fall and while benzali be the only reason one could enjoy in this movie . if it be write by raymond chandler it could be a masterpiece and and hitchcock have make some great movie with even bad script . but and there be only one chandler and only one hitch so sometimes we have to be satisfy with movie like this .