after watch black and i wish i be blind and deaf so that i would never have have to endure this movie or it fantastic review . when i watch a film like black and i can say that the director be definitely talented . he manage to make a film without any song and with most dialogue in english and an unusual story line and get away with both rave review and house full theatre . or maybe and it have get away with rave review and house full theatre because it have no song and have many english dialogue and an unusual story line . maybe people be so tired of the usual good film that an unusual bad film seem extraordinarily good . despite all it unusuality and black be fill with clichés and highly predictable sentimental dialogue . the only thing move in this film be me and shift in my seat and try not to run from the theatre . rani mukherjee and who play michelle and a girl blind and deaf from birth and and amitabh bachchan and who play her teacher have be say to have deliver fantastic performance and yet i find it to be their bad performance that i know of . rani mukherjee have her head cock to one side through the whole film and yet it be only the blind who do that and to catch sound and which be out of the question with michelle . it seem critic and audience see overact a brilliant act while in some scene there be so much overacting and the movie seem bizarre and unreal . what be most unreal be the script and the dialogue . michelle join a university where the teacher be not train to deal with a student like her and and because of this and michelle graduate only ten year after she join . why . simply because her type speed on a braille typewriter be too slow for her to finish her examination within the time limit . surely a college that have manage to handle a blind and deaf student can find a different way to test her . the script do not even deal with the problem in the end . they take the easy way out represent after have fail several time and michelle and in a fit of rage and suddenly manage to type at a furious speed after ten year of not be able to do so . the location and time setting of the movie be very unclear . the whole movie take place in an english hindi speak town when charlie chaplin movie be release . they seem to be completely cut off from the rest of the world . then there the case of michelle sister . she be a normal person and who get an abnormal lack of attention from her parent because of michelle constant need . when she get frustrated with her parent and michelle for the same reason and she be portray a a sister who isn not understanding and who be completely to blame and who be a character make to take the audience fury . one should really sympathise with her and someone who from childhood get a highly inadequate amount of her parent attention . after all the other fantastic review that this movie get and mine must seem like blasphemy . well and everyone entitle to their opinion and and i be express mine . what really bother me be not how bad black be and but the fact that the indian audience considers something of such mediocrity to be fantastic . and that my opinion on everyone else opinion .