i have see a negative review on this movie and i have to say that i be very tired of people pick apart movie to show how smart they think they be . this be a tragic and beautifully film movie that remind me so much of the sweet hereafter . i believe that some people have a hard time watch others go through tragedy and grief and be uncomfortable express themselves . this movie draw a lump to my throat the size of a golf ball and make me hug my son extra hard at bedtime . michelle williams give another outstanding performance and ewan macgregor be and a always and a complete pleasure to watch on screen . this film will come out on dvd this year and i would urge anyone with a heart to embrace it .