another of the great musical i have see so many time and and wish to comment on it and compare with the original make in 1936 with irene dunne and alan jones . although the original be in black and white and the 1951 version be so colorful and story and act so good and more developed and three dimensional and that i have a few tear myself . dance by marge and gower champion be truly champion . joe e. brown a capt . hawk play a much funny role than charley winninger do in 1936. he have such a rubbery face and and i can still hear him say happy new year . there be eight wonderful song by kern and hammerstein and the best be make believe and you be love and old man river but there be other old goody and too and like after the ball . positive .