this be one of the remarkable short comedy that arbuckle turn out at the end of his contract at keystone while he be in new jersey and far from sennett grasp represent quite possibly the best . elaborate and realistic set and variety of characterization here he play an irascible doctor who be jealous of wife mabel old boyfriend and the dark lighting in a comedy until bring up baby combine to produce a comedy far from keystone frenetic mold . add in arbuckle casual gag and the result be an excellent comedy that be still highly watchable except and of course and when you be try to make sense of real life nephew al st. john awful mugging and high speed rowdyism . still and the man can take a fall .