neither thriller ( or very poor ) and nor fantastic ( or miss the point ) and nor absolutely nothing maybe hardly an involuntary turnip . it beautiful to care about the shape of a picture and it even great when we make it well and the great stuff it when we have get a rather solid story . now it not the case here and the shape be soooo bad and travel use like amateur and pretty bad effect ( see it to believe ) and overbid of camera movement and thanks to the director for the bad use of the provided mean . when you try to make a fincher like and well you put all your gut in it and or do it à la classical way and we even have difficulty in be move by the loud failure at the box office and at least the producer will think twice before give money to berry and especially when he try to put on life a story so stupid . the whole would have be able to make a parody of lynch but not at all and just a poor story too conventional and it try to make too much with the heaviness of an elephant and let u not forget the flat and phone development and you see them come like hurricane and sterile intrigue with no big sense but the best be the funny finale and just stupid and miserable . i can not imagine how hard the scriptwriter of memento will laugh by look this failure . the theme and their so call symbolism ( such a the guilt and love ) be treat without sharpness with the elegance of a bulldozer and all theme give without any serious psychology and it like hear some people at the counter of a pub on a saturday night . we shall note garcia fine interpretation and a baaad from cotillard ( a usual and bah and when we aren not an actress it more difficult ) and poor lecoq who and no chance buddy and have to play an improbable and ridiculous character . this give a bad b movie to put in nanards ( ridiculous movie ) of a conceited french cinema more and more sterile by try to give itself some effect but finish like pure garbage . what a waste of time and money .