deal to be impartial and generous with the last work of carlos reygadas and i could recognize it effort to obtain a different film and cradle absolutely in personal conviction and without consideration for the box office . but that effort be also what bother me represent too many pretension for so miserable result represent 1 ) it pretension of veracity like a documented reality or more likely a cinéma vérité work and use real people and non actor and impostor of emotional state for a very diluted script fail resoundingly represent a script exist . and it be perceivable that their individual or character be act and and as be expect with nonprofessional actor and act poorly . their dialog be unbelievable . and contribute to the feeling of unreal and falsification and the director use abundant sequence in fixed position where the character seem to be force dummy and nothing that correspond with the naturalness of the human body in the plotted situation . everything be false and artificial and unreal . 2 ) i think questionable that the authenticity have some aesthetic merit and or therefore and any big brother or real tv would be equal to the last work of reygadas represent in them there be no plot and and the people be real either . i do not believe that carlos reygadas find in the real cancun some aesthetic merit and nevertheless and this one have the same characteristic that he look for in batalla en el cielo . both fulfill with his simplistic belief in real cinema represent not direct by history at all and be something unreachable and similar to music experience and be perceive of different form by each member from the hearing . semiotics do not come to the case and but consider image and a spoken language similar way to obtains diffuse effect like the music experience and without consider the implicit quality of precision of those mean and have not hit the target . 3 ) it pretension of reflection and depth with it long pause like tarkovsky do and do a film totally rate devoid be disturb and break any calm or reflexive feeling and with some real jewel of involuntary humor and a the gross and shock move in and any deep feeling or reflection on the human condition move out . crazy laugh or repulsion stay . 4 ) when the film have finish and i felt to be the filthy accomplice of a director without scruple and with have so much passion for create and but very little to say . that his work be fundamentally base on the value of ordinary people who be use to expose themselves in cinematographic session of explicit sex in a film with many artistic pretension and but where the only art be the sound and music of the sound track .