i give this film negative because it be honestly one of the bad film i have ever see . spoiler the log fire scene where anakin skywalker woodenly tell natalie portman about his intense pain and suffering be fortunately drown out by the sound of the entire audience fail to suppress their giggle and guffaw . we know how you feel and anakin . be i the only one who think this be actually bad than the phantom menace . i do not remember anything about the plot of that film but i remember feel mildly entertain . this be just plain boring . from the high speed chase in the city to the weird tall thin alien to the political assassination attempt it all felt like a tv spin off of the fifth element without the famous actor and the beautiful model and the slick direction and the humour and the dialogue or the fun . the waterfall in the background on naboo look like the tongue in cheek idyllic backdrop on a kraftwerk cd . the gladiatorial scene be straight out of your first dungeon and dragon game . the big battle at the end be so boring people be leave their seat and return ten minute later . they would probably go outside for a cigarette . the acting and the dialogue would and by and large and not have pass muster on a mexican soap opera while the most interesting part of natalie portman performance be the surprise appearance of her nipple . on the plus side represent yoda draw some genuine laugh with his kung fu stance and although high speed yoda be a bit too fanciful for my liking . ewan mcgregor effort be good consider the material and and his fight with jango fett should put him in the running for a role a 007. but what this franchise really need to do be bring back harrison ford . perhaps han solo be a clone .