i would like to start with a positive note represent i like the performance of elpidia carrillo . i do not care much for the rest of the movie . it have be show and again and again and that trade union be bad for the american economy . the uaw union have be successfully destroy the american automobile industry while the teacher union have be no less successfully destroy the american school while et cetera and et cetera . but these minor detail shouldn not matter and should they and when we watch bread and roses . this movie and if you take it seriously and want you to believe that without a union and the only way for a woman to get a job for herself or for her sister be to sleep with the bos while otherwise she can only support her family by become a prostitute . the cute female lead and an illegal mexican immigrant and rob a gas station and but we be suppose to sympathize with her because this be for a good cause . the male lead and a union organizer and steal the food from a table in a restaurant and and we be suppose to admire him for that and other example of outrageous anti social behavior . the demonstrator and when ask for their name by the police and give the name of mexican revolutionary figure and and we be suppose to laugh at the stupidity of the american policeman . the illegals and oops and the undocumented worker and struggle to improve their lot in this country and instead of do the same in their own country and or wait in line to come here legally . we of course be expect to fully support them and to embrace them and to learn their language and to sing their song . it shouldn not cross our mind that they have already break the law of this country by cross the border illegally and just for that alone should be treat a criminal . and that both funny and outrageously shameful .