that for you decide . i be go to list a few thing and you can make up your own mind and which will decide if you wan na watch this movie or not . let start with the actor and because they really give their best . they be great and the chemistry between eric bana and rachel mcadams be really good . even if it almost unbelievable and that they would love each other that much and they sell it . but that also one of the downfall . there be not that much drama and there be not that much friction . while that might be nice for the character and you wonder how smoothly thing go . then at other time you get problem and that shouldn not be there . in other word and the movie be inconsistent . plot hole and a very crazy story detail ( the first time eric banas character and rachel mcadams character meet be . well wrong . just wrong . i can not say more and without reveal anything and but in normal term it a no no . ) add up to an overall weird experience . add to that the occasional and normal time travel paradox and some major plot hole and you have a movie that get you through it romantic magic or a movie that will leave completely cold .