the writer come up with a pretty decent idea for a story and but many flaw in the execution of the plot take so much away from the film a to nearly render it unwatchable . basic element such a character development be gloss over and at best . inconsistency also rear their ugly head . a massive mansion in the middle of the rural irish countryside . character just show up in the garden during a stormy night ( at very convenient time and i might add ) . all in all it wasn not bad . i rat it a 4 and base mostly on the story and talent of alison elliott .