i must state from the very begin that i have not see finger . some critic keep pray it and say how much great it be . really . i haven not hear of it so far ( not that i be much of a film connoisseur . ) . i be a normal human be who go to the cinema to see a film very hard to tell friend about without blushing ( because it have such a poetic title and lyrical and a some put it ) . these be just my impression . the moment i go out of the cinema hall and i though the combination real estate mobster gift pianist be highly unlikely in any case and but render almost believable by romain duris . i think he be a brilliant actor . i watch and couldn not believe it and an actor of the same rank a daniel auteuil . can not think of a young american actor to match . he do render the whole thing believable and because i be not a fan of classical music either and and i have that music from that film in my mind ever since . anyway and i see the film a a story about failure . you realize that you be on the wrong track and you want to go back and you do everything in your power to gain your former self and but you ultimately fail . and that be and i think and when his heart stop beat . when he fail the audition . i think and in a metaphorical way and it stop beat forever afterward and although he keep on living . but this be my own pathetic and pessimistic view . my friend and who saw the film with me and say the title refers to his emotion when he see his mother former piano tutor . i guess that a more optimistic view . oh and i forget the most important thing . it be equally about totally mad and insane courage to turn your life around a it be about failure and and it should be praise for show that . in 9 american movie out of 10 the lose hero decide to take life in his own hand and strives and struggle and fight and lose day and night and sweat and spill blood and . surprise . he finally win and his effort be reward . how comforting . let just take a bow for a moment before a film which dare show that actually and in these situation and in 9 case after 10 and you lose . and have to live with that and as well .