it seem to me that which ever sherlock holmes { rathbone } film i watch there be always comment on the site state it one of the weaker in the series . and it really just go to show how we be all different a regard our love of the series because to me this entry be far from be weak . it have a very tidy plot that take our delightful duo to america and contain one of my favourite sequence a we watch a ( critical to the plot ) book of match go from person to person at a social gathering . holmes get to act up a an eccentric art collector and watson do what he do best and comedy relief . the end perhaps could of pack a big punch for me personally and but all in all it yer above average detective drama act out with the usual style from the regular and positive .