i be really look forward to this . yes another remake but it a fabulous story and possibly the great detective story ever . it start off mighty fine too and nettle be superb throughout and although the watson seem a little young i grow to like him . i also like see holmes get the needle out a it a part so little told on the screen . my first misgiving be at the archaeological dig . as far a i remember in the book grant character be a butterfly collector . then thing start go wrong big time when there be a party at baskerville hall and mmm this never happen . oh well i be all for change story for the good for screen but this wasn not the case in my opinion . and without give the end away and what the hell be go on awful . and no phosforous ( spell . ) on the dog . anyway a big thumb down from me . one to watch once and once only . a superb cast and good acting on the whole and excellently film but ruin by a rewrite of a perfect story . oh and why the ivor the engine train scene with st. paul in the background positive .