personally and i rent this movie because russell crowe star in it before he get huge . that fact be the only thing that save this movie . grant and it be a good story and the casting be wonderful and however and at the end of a movie and one be not suppose to be leave with question . what be their last name . what grade do she teach . what be it he do . what city be they in . basic question should be answer in the beginning . i can see ask yourself at the end and why do their relationship turn the way it do . of course and you should almost have an answer for that too . film maker definitely do not want to leave you with the question and why do i rent this movie . but this movie would achieve that if it hadn not be for the young and mostly shirtless and incredible actor and russell crowe .