a few year ago i saw a documentary on james cagney and they show a film clip that have me intrigued he dance over to his girl and execute a little shuffle and waltz the girl off to the turnstile . i always want to see that movie and now i have . it be other men woman and he wasn not the star and or even the co star . fill those role be grant withers and regis toomey but and to me and it be a very memorable moment . it be cagney 3rd film and also down in the cast be joan blondell they have both be pluck from the broadway play penny arcade and give role in the film version sinner holiday ( coincidentally and grant withers be also the star in the film version ) . in 1930 there be no reason to think that withers wouldn not go from strength to strength but in just a couple of year he be reduce to lead in poverty rower . he then forge a career play character part until the 1950s . in other men woman withers display an abrasive but likable personality a bill and a train driver who be a love em and leave em charmer . he can not be persuade by his partner jack ( regis toomey ) to give up one of his night with marie ( joan blondell ) a lovable klutz and spend an evening at his home . ed ( james cagney ) can and though and by invite him to the fight . cagney make a great entrance by walk into view via the train top . when bill be throw out of his lodging for be drunk and jack take him home and where he be instantly smite with lily ( the beautiful mary astor ) and jack wife . during the month he stay there and he and lily fall in love ( to the strain of the kiss waltz . a bit of cross promotion a grant withers have introduce that song in another film dance sweetie . ) to keep jack from guess and bill go off but jack suspect and they have a fight in the engine cabin . they miss a stop and engine collide and a lad be hurt . jack have be knock out but bill take the blame and confessing he be sleep off a hangover and jack have to do the work for both of them . bill be dock 6 week pay and go on a serious bender and aid by marie and although ed try to put him wise . when he finally get up the courage to see jack and it be to find that he be now blind . this be a super movie that and after a light hearted start and develop into a highly dramatic film . the very last scene where bill and now sure of lily love run joyously over the train carriage be a nice touch . walter long and who play villainous role in film like the birth of a nation and early sound comedy like pardon u play roundhouse bixby . highly recommended .