it a bit late for me to post this review . but memory be rekindle after the saawariya fiasco of the apparently great sanjay leela bansali . i be in india at that time and and many people talk about black a if no one every make a movie like that ever . first of all it a remake and so attribute a genius tag to bansali be uncalled for . i also do not appreciate the fact that he do not admit to the fact that it be a remake of the miracle worker . i mean and be a man . tell the world you be make a remake . secondly and in bollywood and overacting mean good act seem to be the norm . rani be as shrill a you can see . you can paint emotion but if the color just bleed than it loose it grace . bansali just go overboard . some scene make no sense . the empty room with slide image portray in the background . the needless fill set . they distract more . the film have it moment . especially the one where rani meet ab after a long time . i will not go into more detail for the sake of those who haven not see it ( yet ) . in the same week and i have the good fortune of see million dollar baby and . boy . what a difference . to see how emotion be handle subtly . now that be a treat . perhaps bansali ought to learn from eastwood . if he get down from cloud 9 that be .