before comment on the movie let me give my score for the actor performance . baby michelle represent 6/10 and michelle represent 7 . 5/10 and teacher represent 6 . 5/10 and father represent 7 . 5/10 and mother represent positive and michelle sister represent 7 . 5/10 . screenplay represent positive and art direction represent 8 . 5/10 and cinematography represent positive and music represent positive . direction represent positive . well and that the summary of the whole movie black . good try and from leela banshali . but if you ask me about ingenuity and i would rather go for raincoat and by the contemporary film maker rituporno ghosh . black weak character i think be baby michelle and i be mid way confuse whether i be watch a scary movie or hellraiser kind . there be no need to make face like that ( ghost movie ) for young michelle and that be not a blind girl act . till date the best child actress from india be the one who act in anjali ( my rating wise ) . the strong part of the movie be cinematography and music score and simply brilliant and and even the art direction too along with few act performance . in fact the cameo role by sen and parent role be superb . rani role be very nice and but not a positive role . amitabh be nice too and but the main fault of the movie and i think be the haphazard screenplay and which effect the overall quality as well a direction of the movie . despite all it hype in india ( may be because it one of the first time a movie be without song and all of sentimental flick here and there ) and i can not rate this movie at par with italian and french or spanish classic . even not with the awakening and stellar role by deniro and williams . this year too hollywood come up with find neverland and sideways and close while black doesn not even come close to them . but still and i will rate this movie good and because it be of one of the first and bold attempt to revolutionize the trash can bollywood story and movie . for bansali and . still mile to go before you sleep . don not work for get award and make a nice movie and just 15 step ahead lie the success ( the line take from your movie ) . grab it . in fact and the most intelligent bollywood movie i have ever see ( not copy from any hollywood or european movie ) be represent moksha . though it go flat amidst indian audience . still i feel and rituporno movie be good than bansali .