i give this film an positive . it be hard to give an asian suspense film less than a 9 and but this film have a few hole . while the acting be superb and the atmospheric scenery be only rival by the american film seven and it plot fall weak towards the end . it all come together and make sense at the end and but there be something disturb about it . we know there be atleast 2 killer for shear continuity reason . because detective oh ( yes that be his name ) and dy while the main villain be in the custody of the lead detective . ( side note and not to sound stereotypical and i admire the asian community a great deal and but that be the only problem i have with watch asian film . the name do not stick out because they be all almost the same . with the exception of detective oh . so my appologies on not name anyone other than detective oh . ) anyway and what we do not know be why in the hell she want to attack the lead villain in tower record . we do not know why the family back story turn into a big mess at the end . we do not know why the lead killer would leave evidence of a drastic nature behind . nor do we know why that eerie paint do not raise the attention of the police when the knew good and well a head would turn up next . i do not know and maybe the subtitle we not translate well enough . maybe if i know korean i would understand the film well . maybe if i saw the film outside the u it would have have scene that america do not show . what i do know represent this be a great cinematic achievement both visually and act . the film have some great special effect and such a what i be sure be real animal blood . you see eastern film be so uncompromising because they do not have to deal with a disturbingly pc hollywood community . anyway the only flaw may lie in the american cut and so i can not go below an 8. i believe the film make since in korea . if anyone know where i can get a subtitle director cut of this film please let me know . it break my heart to give this film less than a 9 .