this be a stinker of the nth order . nothing in this movie ring true . from the moment when the mcelroy character play by peter fonda be shot point blank in the stomach and and not only doesn not die and but live on to lead the posse after cold turkey surgery the same day and this movie lose me . from then on and all i see be it flaw . they be countless . the story be muddle and confuse . there be dialog that use contemporary vernacular . the end be so completely unbelievable that it isn not even worth spoil for you all . smell like the old west and though . like fresh road apple or cow pie . in short and this be a remake that should never have see the light of day . james mangold and director and clearly let everything get away from him and a he do in walk the line and a movie that end up be a really bad film vehicle for ocsar nominee and but start out be a really good biography of johnny cash that never deliver . miss this train . the 3 represent10 to yuma be garbage .