how could any woman choose another man over errol flynn . i do not know either . that why i do not buy the premise of this but be impress with the performance . errol flynn be always great to watch and prove here that he can deliver the act good and always of course look distractingly handsome . greer garson and walter pigeon be a treat to watch together . a previous poster mention the fact that greer garson have an adulterous affair do not work because she be just too likable really doesn not apply here because the fact that their marriage be unhappy be establish . robert young come off less sympathetic than flynn soames forsythe and in my opinion . here he take advantage of the young and naive june forsythe and the unhappy marriage of mrs. forsythe at the same time . the story be contrive but overall a good flick to watch on a rainy day . i would recommend it .