in the tradition of ed wood and this film be so bad that the audience continually crack up at various sequence . this be especially true when the love keitel have for winslet become apparent and he begin chase her up the hill . the comic relief become even more apparent when keitel have the vision of the three indian woman sing to him . it be like watch high camp that have no intention of remain that way . far and ms. winslet and one of the most talented actress of her generation should think twice about continue to take role like this . she have the capability and opportunity to be a major force in the movie business . now and she will just be consider another actor . lastly and i hope hollywood realize the wool that jane campion have pull over it eyes . there be many people within the community that believe the piano be a case of the emporer new clothes . now and i be sure everyone will realize that this woman have no talent . maybe it will be a long time before she make another piece of trash like this .