good film comedy be have just enough of a plot to hang some joke on . in that respect ` a man call sarge definitely qualify a a good comedy . however it also qualify a a good comedy for another reason represent it genuinely funny . it not clever funny and or deeply thought provoke funny and it good old fashion throw a bunch of joke against the wall and see what stick funny where you can see that the cast be have a good time make the film and a a result the audience have a good time watch it . will it ever be consider amongst the all time great comedy . no it would not and but it definitely a good way to kill an hour and a ½ .