i have see this flick probably 6 8 time while gaynor and streisand and of course garland while not a contest while garland kick butt . while i love this story while but and it should have be do once while maybe with march and garland if possible . but and judy shine and this movie forever make her a star while lawford be weak in the garland version while gaynor be fine while streisand embarrasses while and the performance of the year and garland . too bad and we couldn not have a judy and frederic et all . while the perfect american movie while why must lawford be give any laurel for this . i be embarrass for him while be he drunk . positive . too much rat pack perhaps while anyway and judy life forever in my gay heart and this make her a star while ( correction while for all of you who realize that mason not lawford play judy husband norman maine while i apologize while sorry while and and good catch . positive .