at first and when i saw black and i be really impressed with the movie and the way sanjay leela bhansali make it . the slick camera movement and the camera angle and the snow . everything be impressive . a few month later and i happen to see the same movie at the american international school in lesotho except that this be not make by sanjay leela bhansali and and it be an animated movie . at first i think the smart boy in hollywood remade bhansali film . only later do i realize ( when i get hold of the dvd cover ) that it be make much before black even start production . why do bhansali make this movie . it a frame by frame copy of helen keller story ( often show in international primary school to grow kid ) . sanjay leela bhansali or anyone associate with the script of black should feel ashamed claim credit for black script . they haven not even thank the original screen writer of the original movie in the opening or closing credit of black .