this be hand down the best romantic film since . well in a long time and all the people i know who haven not like this film be because it got impossible situation in it and it slow in the 2nd half all i have to say represent stop watch hindi film then and continue watch 25 sec ad which have diminish your attention span . the character be give amazing dept and lo and behold they take the film to an all new high . kajol have prove shes the best actress of her generation and with this film be give serious competion to her late legendary aunt nutun a the best actress of the family . aamir be splendid though i felt his character get a bit sketchy in the 2nd half not his fault the director and writer could have make his motif more clearer for u . however what ever hes give to work with he electrify every scene he in . kudos to all the crew especially kunal kohli .