this movie surprise me . have be a fan of issac asimov for many year i think that this adaptation with chris columbus at the helm would be terrible . i be wrong . some may complain that this movie be too long and slow and but i would wager that their attention span be somewhat lack . if you be look for a high action movie with robot then you have come to the wrong place . if you be look for a sci fi base romantic comedy about the personal growth of one man . er robot and then this be the movie . the comedy be well write and well play and appropriately place in each moment . a for the character of andrew ( robin williams ) and though he be suppose to be a robot you really connect with his character and sense his growth over time . unlike a. i. his character learns and grows and have real not fabricate emotional attachment . i give this movie an 8 or 9. very good .