see it age ago and still the memory stay as fresh a see the first time . the deep struggle endure against militant who be human also be brilliantly depict in the movie . well in the original language of the movie the scene of village girl try to cope up with the big city and north indian culture be very vividly depict by mani ( lose in translation in other language ) . with a crew of supremely talented technician and back ground staff mani bring u another classic . he should also be credit for get the best tune of a innocently brilliant music genius . they just do not make music like those anymore . personal rating positive . i would prefer him to direct a movie remake of the tenant ( original by polanski ) .