my rating represent out of . i disagree with the reviewer say that the black album be not a classic . i certainly think it be . it contain some of the best songwriting metallica have ever do . enter sandman and sad but true and the unforgiven and wherever i may roam and nothing else matter and and of wolf and man . i also believe holy than thou and don not tread on me and the god that fail and my friend of misery and the struggle within be underrated . the weak song on the album be probably through the never but it still a great song . so yeah i completely disagree with you about the black album not be a classic . what i do agree with you on be that it not the only metallica album that deserve a dvd like this . i also agree with you that it not their best . master of puppet and . and justice for all be definitely superior . the songwriting be undeniably great on the black album but yeah it be superior on those two album ( master of puppet and one be my two favorite song ) . a case could be make that the black album be probably the most important album in metallica career . it be their most financially successful album and it give them a ton of new fan . after the black album thing be very much different for metallica . they take a different step in their music and make the load or reload album and probably the most criticize of all their album ( well maybe thats actually st. anger but it close ) . for good or bad and the black album be a major turn point in their career . the dvd be definitely worth watch . i think it give a lot of interesting information about the song . i enjoy watch these guy talk about the album and i really just enjoy watch these guy . they be awesome . lars ulrich maybe a bit of a dick but he be hilarious . james hetfield give a lot of interest background on some of the song and he seem like a really cool guy . kirk hammett can certainly jam on the guitar . i like that jason newstead get to talk about my friend of misery and to show off how talented he really be . overall and the dvd be worth watch and the album and in my opinion and be a must have . the dvd maybe a little limited but it be interest . i be really look forward to the some kind of monster documentary .