i want to like this and really . but robin williams character be just too unlikeable and completely over the top . sometimes this work for character but it just doesn not work here . ( i be not religious and but i felt uncomfortable with the reverend frank character antic . what with the heal the bloody nose business and rule and such . i know this be a movie and thus not a real depiction of any reverend and but still . it be very discern to watch . ) i absolutely adore mandy moore and john krasinski and and robin williams but this i do not know who to blame script . director . be just horrid . i couldn not finish watch this movie . and what be with the choir boy . very very creepy to make a mini me of an already unlikeable character . i just think it a shame because i feel all the actor could do so much good work . two star go to mandy and john because they do an okay job in this movie . but everything else just drop flat . too over the top .