this be a film that take three of the most beloved film of all time and sell their soul to cgi . the original star war trilogy be not label a the great film ever make because of light sabre and or storm trooper and or groundbreaking motion capture special effect and but because of the human side . the quality of the act from sir alec guinness and the chemistry between harrison ford and carrie fisher and the excellent dialogue that make every line a memorable quote and the context of faith and religion be what make them so everlasting . in this film ewan mcgregor acting be surprisingly wooden for such a talented actor and hayden christensen have less chemistry with natalie portman than a 12 year old student test tube and the dialogue be boring and the line be cheesy and clichéd and there do not seem to be any actual emphasis on plot and it just be an excuse to glue one over long action set piece to another and so the intrigue disappear fast and the theme and context be give a back seat to ( admittedly impressive ) cgi . it seem that george lucas think that what make a good film be as much soulless eye candy a possible . star war be once a trailblazer in science fiction and it originality give most of the future blockbusters the template for their scene and and what be originally star war innovation become cliché at the hand of other film . now it be star war use the same plot line we have see over and over again and copy others and episodes 1 and 2 and 3 in a lazy attempt to seem interesting . you do not need spectacle to create a good film you need drama and humanity both of which this film sorely lack . in my opinion the best light sabre fight of the series be the showdown between darth vader and obi wan kenobi . the fight do not have any flipping or flopping or any fancy kung fu and but it do have the enormous tension of the concept of the final fight between master and pupil . that make for a great scene and and the element of drama be completely void from this movie . this be a cheap cgi fest that miss the point entirely .