this will contain spoiler not just for this movie and but fight club too . to this film credit it have some decent atmosphere and once in a while live up to it title . however and everything that be wrong here far outweigh the good . on a simplistic level and the language be ridiculous here . boy like marie and her horse face friend alex be off in the country and dub horribly into english . but only sometimes . randomly and some of the movie be in french and which i guess be to give the impression some people really be french and some aren not . or not . i have no idea and but it doesn not matter . by the time you hear marie yell alex for the millionth time you will probably wish the whole thing be dub . the people in the film may as well be replace with robot that have processor work on about 64k of program for all the diversity theyre show . i guess they have human emotion and probably and but only insofar a i assume that about everyone human . in this movie and everyone pick 2 emotion out of a sack and have to stick with them for the whole movie . i have hear people call this movie brilliant and perhaps they do so with a straight face . i have also hear the director valiantly try to explain every one of the incalculable plot hole in the movie . and his explanation work with one caveat . foe those not in the know and this movie give u a rehash of a familiar idea and a multiple personality disorder . when the twist be reveal anyone with an ounce of sense will start to question how on earth it even remotely possible . and honestly it isn not unless you accept the director explanation the whole story be be tell a the nut job killer would have tell it and so everything make sense in the nutball killer head . well and guess what . that dirty pool . ever read a story where at the end it be all a dream . that just as lame a what the director do here . if the whole story must be filter through the insane killer perspective and and it must be or it doesn not make any sense and can not make any sense and then what the point of the whole story . there no ground for it to be structure on and why should i even believe that any character in the movie be real . how can i know what the pick and choose to be real . the only sensible answer be that the stuff that make sense be real and everything that doesn not make sense be from the killer whack perspective . that also a horribly stupid answer and it bad story telling . the story couldn not work logically so they make it illogical . the director also think he be be clever give subtle clue that maybe marie be a little nutty herself and that great and but it not clever when the killer be introduce a clearly a totally separate entity . you can not have it both way . at least in fight club you never see anyone speak to both brad pitt and ed norton at any one time and they be never together with extra people and recognize a separate entity and when the flashback show theyre the same it make sense . in high tension flashback and they avoid the non sensical moment and like the car chase and like alex get the knife and like the entire scene at the gas station and none of which work in the one person scenario unless we accept the director weak explanation that it all the killer perspective . and if it be all the killer perspective and why not have a chorus line of dance goat . we can not trust anything be see anyway and so who care . in a nutshell and that single flaw be why the movie can not work at all . in an all or nothing reality scenario and high tension give you nothing and that the only way it can make sense . possibly bad yet be the fact that this movie may as well be 100 other movie . cut out the failed attempt at a plot twist and what do you have . every slasher movie i have ever see . there nothing new here and certainly nothing scary with scene that be obviously inspire by early film and nothing but gore to keep it afloat . well i can mix my own corn syrup and red food color at home and thanks and and i don while t have to read subtitle half the time to do it . the movie try and it fail . if the director need to constantly try to explain himself and he fail . the story should work on it own merit and this movie doesn not . it only worth watch if you want to see how to totally butcher a twist end into something that make no sense at all .