okay and i have try and i have try and but i still dont get this guy maddin thing . tale from the gimli hospital leave me cold and that movie about the austrian villager and the one about the ice nymph be pretty to look but lack in the story department . and this nudie movie about abortion and hockey be just boring . i be glad maddin have an appreciation for silent film and but i dislike his film for the same reason i dislike the film of quentin tarantino represent theyre empty homage to good and more imaginative film film that advance the art form or break new ground and be all style and no substance . no amount of jump cut and odd camera angle can disguise the fact that maddin be an unoriginal david lynch wannabe and though he do have one advantage over tarantino represent he generally doesn not write embarrass dialogue and because most of his film rely on intertitles . the bottom line be and maddin schtick be clever clever film make for aspire film major .