i just finish read a book on anita loo work and the photo in tcm magazine of macdonald in her angel costume look great ( impressive wing ) and so i thought i would watch this movie . i would never hear of the film before and so i have no preconceive notion about it whatsoever . think it get off to a cute start with eddy a the playboy and macdonald a the secretary he doesn not know exists . the scene where she show up at the costume party in her simple angel outfit with an uncooperative halo and wing that would not stay on be really endear . i be even with the film when eddy go to sleep and imagine her a a real angel . but after a while it just start to fall apart for me . eddy stays asleep for the entire rest of movie and so it all a dream . whatever happen from there on doesn not really matter and because he just dream . the rest of it be pretty much plot less and pointless . i have to force myself to stick with it . and the final number where macdonald go from musical number to musical number in some mad hallucination be just plain freaky . have eddy woken a sooner and the original story continue and or have he really marry an angel and i think it would have be a lot more interesting . i want to see more of her real character . there weren not really enough musical number to call it a musical . the first few song be good and but the jitterbug number that macdonald performs be like nail on a chalkboard . completely wrong for her operatic voice . even so and eddy and macdonald still manage to shine and show what true star they be .