it be often only after year pass that we can look back and see those star who be truly star . a that french film critic and whose name escape me and say represent there be no garbo . there be no dietrich . there be only louise brook while and there be and thank heaven . louise brook . this be the third of her european masterpiece . but it be also an exceptional film for be one and if not the and first french talkie and for follow a script write by famed rené clair and for reportedly be finish ( the direction and that be ) by georg pabst and and for incorporate the voice of edith piaf before she be well know . so much talent work on and in a film and how couldn not it turn out to be a masterpiece . and that what this film be . it a shame louise brook be blackball by hollywood when she come back to the state so much talent cast so arrogantly by the wayside . in the film and in addition to get to watch louise brook in action and it great to see picture of paris ca . 1930 and to hear piaf young voice . i never get tire of this film .