this be probably karisma at her best and apart from zubeidaa . nana patekar also give out his best and without even try . the story be very good at time but by the end seem to drag and especially when shahrukh come in the picture . what really make me like it be the performance of the lead and the dialog delivery and as well a the story and for what it be . it could have be direct well and and edit . the support case be even great and include karima mother in law and even though she just have one shin moment and it be great to watch her . the set be also pretty good . i do not really like their portrayal of a canadian family and but once they step in india and it as real a it get . overall and i would give it a thumbs up .