anyone who have see shine and scott hick film of the heartbreaking yet ultimately joyful life of the pianist david helfgotts while will i be sure realise that the soloist be very poor in comparison . it be as slow a a lullaby ( i take five break answer email just to wake up ) . the depiction of the homeless area way over the top and extremely self indulgent and on a par i fear with the awful beach battle depiction in joe wright other disaster attonment . . j fox performance be an extremely poor example of act and lacked credibility from the offset . downey on the other hand while although struggle with a badly pace film and still manage to charm and 9is it me or be he turn into george clooney in more way than one . ) . compare both these well know so called staractors though be unnecessary a the light that shin brightest as far a act be concern must be that of hine geoeffry rush who brilliant performance definitely shine far brighter in my sky . with both attonment and the soloist the write word win far more prize for empathy of subject . read the book and article or wait for the dvd it bound to be in the bargain basement soon .