i will say one thing for jeanette and nelson even when strand in a mirthless and witless and painfully inept musical like this and there still that twinkle in their eye . yes and the chemistry between the famous duo be there even when the material be paper thin . even when the score be practically a throwaway and non existent one depending on just a couple of catchy tune . and even when the circumstance be so unbelievable yes and even for a fantasy . truth to tell and she have more chemistry with nelson than with her own real life husband gene raymond in smilin through and which and nonetheless and be a considerably well film . sorry and i love jeanette and nelson as much a the next fan and but this be the bottom of the heap . jeanette be more than embarrass in her one hep number with binnie barnes and nelson can only come up with a blank stare when face with the most ludicrous situation . one can only wonder what this be like on broadway in 1938. surely and it must have have more wit and style than be evident in this weak mgm production . edward everett horton fizzle in an unfunny role and none of the support player can breathe any semblance of life into this mess . it like amateur night at the studio even with the few professional sprinkle among the support cast . sum up represent painfully clumsy rendering of a rodgers and hart musical . can not recommend it and even for fan of macdonald and eddy . and even if jeanette close ups still glow with her gossamer beauty and this film be jaw droppingly bad .