i stop watch lose at this episode because i think ana lucia and libby death be unnecessary and really depress . then i find out that they keep libby around just to die in the next episode . gah . i can not handle it . i like this show for the first season and but it definitely decline in the second season and i find jack and locke little religious feud to be annoy . the death of rodriguez and watros character be the final straw . i give this episode a 4/10 and for be the end to my viewing of this formerly great series create by alias legend j. j. abrams . i hope his series in the future will improve on this one .