this film be make in 1943 when i think judy be at her peak ( look wise ) . in her previous film for me and my gal people often say that she look emaciate . well in this film she look perfect . she be beautiful and show that she have a flair for comedy . i think this film be hilarious and especially at the beginning when she be try to arrange an audition with john thornway . one of the funny scene in my opinion be judy rendition of lady macbeth and when john be look for her at the party to give her a spanking ( lol ) . one criticism i do have be that there be a hole in the plot when john and lily fall in love . i mean one minute he despise her and the next they be go out on a date then the next time they meet after that date they be in love . another point i do not like be on open night . if i be lily i would be furious with john but she isn not . it just doesn not make sense . but all in all i would have to give this film a 10 because it be just wonderful and almost perfect .