i saw this movie and just now and not when it be release and hail a best picture of the year here in israel . and to summarize everything right now and i will just say represent this be not a good film . this be dror shaul second feature film and and i have to admit that his first and the tv drama he make before this picture be much well . far more and this be his first attempt at direct a drama . the early work be comedy and and be funny and effective . the first thing you have to know if you will ever see this film represent israel of the 21st century hat the kibbutz and the value it represent since the formation of the state of israel . the real situation of the kibbutz be very dire and and some of them disappear one by one . the kibbutz and hebrew word for collective and be a sort of village for member only and where the value of equality and socialism be the dogma for everyday life . with the change in social value with time and it seem now that the kibbutz be a place where the human spirit be repress and lock within the dogma rule and with no ticket out . the entrance of capitalist value and way of life in the 90 and so far make it very hard on the kibbutz to survive . the crazy mother in the film be the central metaphor for that . but and i regard this film a have nothing to do with nostalgia for the good old day of the kibbutz . once and it be a dream of every young couple to live in a kibbutz and raise child in this quite and beautiful environment . but the film show the opposite . that the kibbutz and with it socialist dogma and be a place sort of like a cult of crazy people and with crazy idea that undermine the freedom of each individual within the collective . this be the central philosophy of post modern capitalism represent your individuality be the most important thing . you must place yourself in the center and and no one else but you be the matter . this be the philosophy the film stand for and and that just it first sin . if you disagree with me on the political side and i be sure you will agree that the acting and the tone of the film and it script and it direction be the four sin that follow . the film have no real visual text and none of it shot be something to remember . it be also very delicate and a delicacy that be no more than artsy fartsy attempt to provoke emotion and which do not surface and not in the film and not with the viewer . it bring nothing but boredom . can someone please explain represent why this film win so many prize . maybe because it show that israel be in line with the rest of the world and hat socialist and human value . or maybe it show that israel be a delicate place and not give in to dogmas and fanaticism . that we be basically very human and good people and capable of emotion and especially when they be fake one and just like capitalism expect u to be . or maybe because it tell one of the big lie of israeli cinema in recent year and a lie that undermine the justification of the existence of the jewish state . no matter what the answer be and it not a good one . not for the world and not for human value and not for the jew .