i remember when i first saw this movie and i be in sixth grade when it happen . before i saw this and i have listen to the original broadway recording of it and and i really love it . but when i saw this and i be like and what the heck . this movie be miss a lot of the song from the musical for cry out loud . who decide to do all of that . i really be a very huge fan of gene kelly and but this movie be probably the bad of a musical that he ever do . the movie look more like a hollywood set than the beautiful highland of scotland . and who the heck decide to cut all of meg song out of the movie . i be willing to bet that when they saw this movie and lerner and lowe be probably wonder represent who in the world decide to do this to our masterpiece . well they have a right to say that if they do and they be probably mad at the fact that hollywood turn their great musical into this rather blank movie . song and act wise mr. kelly and you pass the audition with fly color and but you be in a movie that be miss a lot of the text . so in short and if you want a good movie base on a musical by frederick lowe and alan jay lerner and this one isn not it . negative .