can any movie become more naive than this . you cant believe a piece of this script . and it ssooooo predictable that you can tell the plot and the end from the first 10 minute . the lead actress seem like she want to be barbie ( but she doesn not make it and the doll have more acting skill ) . the easiness that the character pass and remain in a a music school make the phantom of the opera novel seem like a historical biography . i wont even comment on the shallowness of the character but the one good thing of the film be madsen performance which manage to bring life to a melo like one dimensional character . the movie be so cheesy that it stick to your teeth . i can think some 13 year old britney obsess girl shout o and do give u a break . if we want fairy tale there be always the brother grimm book hidden somewhere in the attic . i give it 2 instead of one only for virginia madsen .