this kind of storytelling be unacceptable the only reason this film be anywhere above the 5 star out of 10 line be because it get george lucas behind it and and it have the word star and war in it title . that be an insult to aspire filmmaker and and many others out there who have make clearly superior film with superior story and writing and acting and but do not get the credit . this be a travesty . first thing first . the story . anakin evolution . there be none . apart from a little make up around the eye and and a little yelling and there be none . he become young and stupid and cocky anakin skywalker to darth vader in a single blow . the only thing consistent about darth vader in the original series be his intelligence and how good he be at almost everything he do and planning and fighting and you name it . the only consistent thing about anakin that be perceive in the prequel trilogy be his consistent stupidity . he even lose his body because of a bout of stupid cockiness . what part of the emperor palpatine tell him legend of the sith do not point to the emperor be a sith . unacceptable . the fight scene use too many digital double . everyone fly all over the place like teddy bear in a make believe doll house . count dooku and emperor palpatine and anakin and obi wan and almost every fighter have a rubbery digital double jumping around . in one specific fight scene and obi wan and anakin in the climactic battle and they both actually stop in the middle of parry and riposte and to twirl their saber a few time while inch apart . i realize the fight be choreograph and but that just get me shake my head in disbelief and disgust . the writing be awful . all the dialogue be of tremendously low quality . the good actor like ewan mcgregor and natalie portman do the best they could with their line and but that just wasn not enough . i can not say enough bad thing about this film . too much special effect and plot hole big than the centre of the universe and and absolutely no insight into any of the character . this be the big mistake of this film represent nothing new be offer . we know the rough picture of everything and all lucas do be colour it in . we know anakin lose his limb . we know luke and leia be brother and sister and we know luke be anakin son and we know obi wan and yoda go to exile and we know everything . nothing new be offer in this film . if that all the fan want and then that fine and lucas couldn not have go wrong . but when anakin finally become darth vader and and he ask after padme and and hears she be dead and he reach out his arm awkwardly and screams nooooooooooooooooooooo . that scene scream b movie all the way and and i be half expect darth vader to go danger will robinson and danger at any time . that be what this be . a b movie and disguise by a huge budget and a ultra loyalist fan base that will settle with anything now that the first two movie have pull their standard down to the pit of the earth .