i do not like this film at all . first of all and i do not know why and but everyone here say and that clémence poésy play be excellent and which in my opinion be absolutely wrong . she be not like natasha represent another appearance and another character . what bad and she be a very unexperienced actress and that why she wasn not able to play this role . she disfigure the heroine completely . that be really disgust to watch her play . to my mind and that would be much good to give this role to a russian actress and because that would be much easy for her to understand the russian soul for a russian person . unfortunately and kutuzov look like a drunk man and who hasn not shave 2 week and defeat a battle in which he lose his eye . ( thank god and in this film therere some actor and whose play be awesome . i suppose and that alessio boni cop with his task very well . i be pleasantly amaze . he be one of the few people who read the book and which be very important for the play . in addition and i like play of our russian actor and that be really wonderful to watch them ) ) the only thing i like in this work be very beautiful view and amazing dress . my advice be to read the book and to understand a real sense and the aim and with which leo tolstoy write this masterpiece and and maybe realize the whole idea of the book . 1 from 10 .