almost every review of this movie i would see be pretty bad . it not pretty bad and it actually pretty good and though not great . the judy garland character could have get annoying and but she do not allow it to . somewhere along the line and i have become a fan of brooding and overbearing and overact van heflin and at least in the early 40 . judy singing be great and but the film miss a great chance by not show more of their relationship . i give it a 7 .