a have be note and this formula have be film several time and most recently a you have get mail and with tom hank and megtrout pout ryan . of the several version and this be my least favorite . the problem i think be that the studio coast on the star charisma and which doesn not quite cut it here . the chemistry betwixt the two lead never come to a boil in this movie . there be no real spark . van johnson and judy garland remind me of day old donut and pleasant but bland . and when the lead be bore the rest of the movie can only follow . judy in particular be disappoint . she look like she have no neck . i do not know if she be have trouble with pain or something but she look like a turtle try to pull it head into it shell and all hunch up and everything . i couldn not figure out what van johnson be get so hot about . i would have make a bee line for that cute violin player . and van wasn not great either . i have always think of him a a rather generic hollywood lead man and he doesn not do anything to dispel that image here . if youre a fan of the star or the early 1900 then you might like this movie . but there be a lot more entertaining romantic comedy out there and and they offer you much more than a mouthful of stale confection .