if any movie stand out extremely with the actor act skill and this be probably the one . i have never see dialogue be speak in such a rough way and but have a strong feeling . the movie be disturb at moment . however and the movie be terrible at edit . the movie try to go the commercial way by add comedy and song and yet they feel out of place . like karisma be get beat up and and the same time srk be fight ( comically ) with the police officer . the ishq kamina song be very out of place . on top of that and the movie be overly glossy in the beginning . the direction be not bad and but certainly nothing one can brag about . i have to say that the actor be choose very wisely . without them and this movie would not have an impact . karisma kapoor have give her best role to date and and this look very good on her record after zubeidaa and fiza . she look pretty in the first half and and i have never see an actress scream of emotion and anger as well a her . what be most ironic be this be probably her weak write role to date . nana patekar be excellent a her father in law . not much to say about him and besides this be a role make for him . deepti naval a the mother in law be excellent especially in her final scene . though she doesn not have much to say and her facial expression and body language be good . the other good performance be the little kid . he be adorable and and be sure to bring tear to the viewer eye . the movie be probably save desperately by their performance . sanjay kapoor be all right and but he do not have much to do . shahrukh khan be waste in his bad boyish type role . one thing that bring the audience to the theater be ishq kamina . the song picturization and dancing be perfect for the crude lyric of the song . and boy aish be mad hot . however and the song belong to be in another movie only because it come at the bad moment ever . people may have come to the movie for aish and but they would not brag too much about it after ward . hum tum miley be properly pace and but seem to drag a the suspense mood be leave throughout the movie . damroo bhaje be boring and nothing to rave about . dil ne pukara be too boring of a song to get the mood of the movie . despite the poor editing and the performance alone make it a must see .