Russian Bomb Claims Questionable, Expert Says
The Russian military said Tuesday, Sept. 11, that it successfully tested a vacuum bomb it described as the world's most powerful conventional weapon. It's a claim arms expert Sascha Lange said is disputable.
Sascha Lange, an expert in the analysis of arms development at the German Institute for International and Security Affairs, said a Russian video showing a massive explosion is not solid evidence that the country has developed the "father of all bombs." DW-WORLD.DE: The Russians announced they detonated a new vacuum bomb, saying it was the world's most powerful conventional weapon. What do you doubt about their claims? Sascha Lange: I doubt that everything took place the way the Russians claim. The pictures that were shown on state television do not clearly show what is claimed. For example, a Tupolev 160 "Blackjack," a strategic bomber, is shown opening its bomb hatch in the pictures, but you do not see the weapon fall out of the plane. A cut is made and then a body falls out of a different plane. You can recognize this because there is a different weapons bay and the bomb releases differently than it would from a "Blackjack bomber." Are there additional inconsistencies? Yes. You can see the weapon in free fall and you can see an explosion. But as big as the explosion in the pictures is, you cannot tell if it was caused by the bomb that has fallen. This large explosion could also have been carried out on the ground and not have resulted from the dropped bomb. When you examine the explosion, you see it happens on a completely level plain. Then pictures are shown with buildings and vehicles that are supposed to have been destroyed by the bomb. But they are not at visible before the explosion. There are several points where all the pictures don't entirely fit together and the claims are not at all supported by these pictures. The bomb is also not shown dropping from the "Blackjack bomber's" weapons bay. The pictures imply what is claimed in the Russian media, but they don't show it at all. You are referring to the video shown on Russian state television? Yes, exactly. They were also shown in the news media here [in Germany] with the headline "Russia has new bombs." The arms technology is not fundamentally new. The exact terminology for it is a thermobaric weapon. The Americans used them in Vietnam War as well as in the last Gulf War. The concept was even considered by the Germans in World War II. The Russians have now simply issued a news report saying, "We have the biggest bomb." I think it is mainly driven by domestic, political concerns -- for the Russian population to see that Putin is the strongest and now we also have the strongest bomb. Can you say whether Russia is actually in a position to build a bomb that has four times the power of the MOAB, the Americans' strongest known conventional weapon? Fundamentally the Russians could do it. They've constructed other munitions with these warheads, such as their artillery rockets. But I would not assume that the weapon shown has four times the explosive force of the American MOAB. It doesn't match up. For optical reasons? Right. The size is not big enough. The MOAB is a large bomb with a mass of 10 tons -- that's really something completely different. The dropping that was shown on Russian television reminded me much more of an older American thermobaric weapon, the "Daisy Cutter." Russia claimed that it developed this weapon for the fight against terrorism. Is the bomb suitable for that? That is just as far-fetched as the claim that the Americans want to use nuclear weapons in the hunt for terrorists. The weapon is not suited for the fight against terrorism. It's just the opposite: in operations like in Afghanistan and Iraq, militaries are using the smallest munitions possible. The trend is going in a very different direction toward the smallest possible munitions with smaller explosive radii rather than to large bombs with as much explosive force as possible. Then how would the Russians' weapon be used? Psychologically, first of all. The Americans used this type of weapon in Vietnam to make clearings for helicopters in the jungle. In Iraq, they were used to detonate minefields. In Afghanistan, these bombs have been used extremely seldom, as far as I know. There, and also in Iraq, they would more likely be used for psychological warfare. They produce an incredible explosion, even if it is a conventional weapon. But from a military point of view, it's a very rarely used weapon. Where does Russia's military stand in international comparison? Not where it would like to see itself. The Russian armed forces suffered heavily at the end of the Cold War. Planes and tanks are gradually beginning to be built again, but they cannot replace what has aged away. The level of training has severely dropped over the past 15 years. There is a gradual upward trend now, but it is starting from a very low level. The Russians have a very long way to go before their armed forces really are taken seriously.
Russian
Russian
Tuesday, Sept. 11
arms expert
Sascha Lange
Sascha Lange
German Institute for International and Security Affairs
German_Institute_for_International_and_Security_Affairs
Russian
DW-WORLD.DE
Russians
Sascha Lange
Russians
Tupolev 160 "Blackjack,"
Blackjack
Blackjack Blackjack_(American_band) BlackJack_(film_series) Blackjack_(1998_film) Blackjack_(weapon) Blackjack_(1990_film) Blackjack_(Donald_Byrd_album) Blackjack_(Atari_2600_video_game) Blackjack_(Blackjack_album) Blackjack_(1978_film) Blackjack,_Cherokee_County,_Texas Baton_(law_enforcement) Quercus_marilandica Black_Jack_(manga) Blackjack_(Transformers) Tupolev_Tu-160
Blackjack
Blackjack Blackjack_(American_band) BlackJack_(film_series) Blackjack_(1998_film) Blackjack_(weapon) Blackjack_(1990_film) Blackjack_(Donald_Byrd_album) Blackjack_(Atari_2600_video_game) Blackjack_(Blackjack_album) Blackjack_(1978_film) Blackjack,_Cherokee_County,_Texas Baton_(law_enforcement) Quercus_marilandica Black_Jack_(manga) Blackjack_(Transformers) Tupolev_Tu-160
Russian
Russian
Germany
Germany Germany_national_football_team Nazi_Germany German_Empire Germany_women's_national_football_team Weimar_Republic German_Football_Association ISU_Junior_Grand_Prix_in_Germany GfK_Entertainment_Charts Germany_national_youth_football_team A1_Team_Germany Germany_national_rugby_union_team Kingdom_of_Germany German_literature Germany_men's_national_ice_hockey_team Same-sex_marriage_in_Germany
Russia
Russia Russian_Empire Russia_national_football_team Russia_men's_national_ice_hockey_team Russia_men's_national_junior_ice_hockey_team Tsardom_of_Russia Russia_national_rugby_union_team Russian_Soviet_Federative_Socialist_Republic Russian_Football_Union Russia_women's_national_football_team Russia_national_basketball_team Russia_national_rugby_league_team Russia_Fed_Cup_team Russia_national_cerebral_palsy_football_team Russia_national_handball_team Russia_Davis_Cup_team
Americans
Vietnam War
Vietnam_War Military_history_of_Australia_during_the_Vietnam_War Opposition_to_United_States_involvement_in_the_Vietnam_War Canada_and_the_Vietnam_War New_Zealand_in_the_Vietnam_War Vietnam Lists_of_protests_against_the_Vietnam_War United_States_news_media_and_the_Vietnam_War Vietnam_War_in_film Joint_warfare_in_South_Vietnam,_1963–69 Lawrence_Joel Indochina_Wars First_Indochina_War Vietnam_War_casualties Vietnam_veteran 1947–50_in_the_Vietnam_War
Gulf War
Gulf_War Iraq_War Australian_contribution_to_the_1991_Gulf_War 2003_invasion_of_Iraq Operation_Granby Coalition_of_the_Gulf_War
Germans
World War II
World_War_II Eastern_Front_(World_War_II) World_War_II_in_Yugoslavia Pacific_War Second_Sino-Japanese_War Military_history_of_Gibraltar_during_World_War_II Military_history_of_Australia_during_World_War_II Romania_in_World_War_II European_theatre_of_World_War_II Military_history_of_the_Philippines_during_World_War_II Hungary_in_World_War_II Military_history_of_Canada_during_World_War_II Invasion_of_Poland Military_history_of_Greece_during_World_War_II Netherlands_in_World_War_II Slovene_Lands_in_World_War_II
Russians
Russian
Putin
Vladimir_Putin Puin_(brand) Putin_(surname)
Russia
Russia Russian_Empire Russia_national_football_team Russia_men's_national_ice_hockey_team Russia_men's_national_junior_ice_hockey_team Tsardom_of_Russia Russia_national_rugby_union_team Russian_Soviet_Federative_Socialist_Republic Russian_Football_Union Russia_women's_national_football_team Russia_national_basketball_team Russia_national_rugby_league_team Russia_Fed_Cup_team Russia_national_cerebral_palsy_football_team Russia_national_handball_team Russia_Davis_Cup_team
MOAB
Moab Moab,_Utah GBU-43/B_MOAB Moab_Cluster_Suite Canyonlands_Field Moab_(disambiguation)
Americans
Russians
American
MOAB
Moab Moab,_Utah GBU-43/B_MOAB Moab_Cluster_Suite Canyonlands_Field Moab_(disambiguation)
MOAB
Moab Moab,_Utah GBU-43/B_MOAB Moab_Cluster_Suite Canyonlands_Field Moab_(disambiguation)
Russian
American
Daisy Cutter
BLU-82 Daisy_cutter_(fuse)
Russia
Russia Russian_Empire Russia_national_football_team Russia_men's_national_ice_hockey_team Russia_men's_national_junior_ice_hockey_team Tsardom_of_Russia Russia_national_rugby_union_team Russian_Soviet_Federative_Socialist_Republic Russian_Football_Union Russia_women's_national_football_team Russia_national_basketball_team Russia_national_rugby_league_team Russia_Fed_Cup_team Russia_national_cerebral_palsy_football_team Russia_national_handball_team Russia_Davis_Cup_team
Americans
Afghanistan
Afghanistan War_in_Afghanistan_(2001–present) Afghanistan_national_cricket_team Afghanistan_national_football_team Kingdom_of_Afghanistan Democratic_Republic_of_Afghanistan Emirate_of_Afghanistan Soviet–Afghan_War Islamic_Emirate_of_Afghanistan Operation_Enduring_Freedom Flag_of_Afghanistan International_Security_Assistance_Force Military_history_of_Australia_during_the_War_in_Afghanistan Afghanistan_national_under-19_cricket_team Afghanistan_Football_Federation Islamic_State_of_Afghanistan
Iraq
Iraq Iraq_national_football_team Iraq_War Ba'athist_Iraq Kingdom_of_Iraq 2003_invasion_of_Iraq Iraq_Football_Association Mandatory_Iraq Iraq_national_under-23_football_team Iraqi_Republic_(1958–68) History_of_the_Jews_in_Iraq Anglo-Iraqi_War Flag_of_Iraq Iraq_national_under-20_football_team Australian_contribution_to_the_2003_invasion_of_Iraq Elections_in_Iraq
Russians
Americans
Vietnam
Vietnam Vietnam_War Vietnam_national_football_team Vietnam_Football_Federation Vietnam_at_the_2005_Southeast_Asian_Games List_of_non-marine_molluscs_of_Vietnam Vietnamese_cuisine Vietnam_(miniseries) Vietnam_women's_national_football_team Volleyball_Federation_of_Vietnam South_Vietnam Football_in_Vietnam Vietnam_women's_national_volleyball_team Vietnam_national_under-23_football_team Vietnam_national_under-20_football_team VietNam_(band)
Iraq
Iraq Iraq_national_football_team Iraq_War Ba'athist_Iraq Kingdom_of_Iraq 2003_invasion_of_Iraq Iraq_Football_Association Mandatory_Iraq Iraq_national_under-23_football_team Iraqi_Republic_(1958–68) History_of_the_Jews_in_Iraq Anglo-Iraqi_War Flag_of_Iraq Iraq_national_under-20_football_team Australian_contribution_to_the_2003_invasion_of_Iraq Elections_in_Iraq
Afghanistan
Afghanistan War_in_Afghanistan_(2001–present) Afghanistan_national_cricket_team Afghanistan_national_football_team Kingdom_of_Afghanistan Democratic_Republic_of_Afghanistan Emirate_of_Afghanistan Soviet–Afghan_War Islamic_Emirate_of_Afghanistan Operation_Enduring_Freedom Flag_of_Afghanistan International_Security_Assistance_Force Military_history_of_Australia_during_the_War_in_Afghanistan Afghanistan_national_under-19_cricket_team Afghanistan_Football_Federation Islamic_State_of_Afghanistan
Iraq
Iraq Iraq_national_football_team Iraq_War Ba'athist_Iraq Kingdom_of_Iraq 2003_invasion_of_Iraq Iraq_Football_Association Mandatory_Iraq Iraq_national_under-23_football_team Iraqi_Republic_(1958–68) History_of_the_Jews_in_Iraq Anglo-Iraqi_War Flag_of_Iraq Iraq_national_under-20_football_team Australian_contribution_to_the_2003_invasion_of_Iraq Elections_in_Iraq
Russia
Russia Russian_Empire Russia_national_football_team Russia_men's_national_ice_hockey_team Russia_men's_national_junior_ice_hockey_team Tsardom_of_Russia Russia_national_rugby_union_team Russian_Soviet_Federative_Socialist_Republic Russian_Football_Union Russia_women's_national_football_team Russia_national_basketball_team Russia_national_rugby_league_team Russia_Fed_Cup_team Russia_national_cerebral_palsy_football_team Russia_national_handball_team Russia_Davis_Cup_team
Russian
Cold War
Cold_War Cold_War_(2012_film) Cold_war_(general_term) Cold_War_(Doctor_Who) Cold_War_(ice_hockey) Cold_War_(2018_film) Cold_War_(video_game) Cold_War_(TV_series) Cold_War_(song) Cold_War_(1953–1962) Cold_War_(1985–1991) Cold_War_(1947–1953) Cold_War_(band) Cold_War_(1962–1979) Cold_War_II Cold_War_(1979–1985)
Russians
Tupolev 160 "Blackjack,"
Tupolev_Tu-160
iptc::16000000 topic::conflict type::entity type::military_equipment type::misc
Sascha Lange
gender::male meta::todo slot::expert slot::keyword topic::none type::entity type::person
Russia
Russia
slot::in slot::keyword topic::none type::entity type::gpe type::gpe0 type::location
Russian
topic::none type::gpe0-x type::other
Tuesday, Sept. 11
topic::none type::money type::value
arms expert
topic::none type::role type::value
German Institute for International and Security Affairs
German_Institute_for_International_and_Security_Affairs
iptc::11000000 topic::politics type::entity type::organization type::policy_institute
DW-WORLD.DE
topic::media type::entity type::media type::organization
Russians
topic::none type::gpe0-x type::other
Germany
Germany
topic::none type::entity type::gpe type::gpe0 type::location
Americans
topic::none type::gpe0-x type::other
Vietnam War
Vietnam_War
iptc::16000000 topic::conflict type::entity type::event type::war
Gulf War
Gulf_War
iptc::16000000 topic::conflict type::entity type::event type::war
Germans
topic::none type::gpe0-x type::other
World War II
World_War_II
iptc::16000000 topic::conflict type::entity type::event type::war
Putin
Vladimir_Putin
gender::male iptc::11000000 topic::politics type::entity type::head_of_state type::person type::politician
MOAB
GBU-43/B_MOAB
iptc::16000000 topic::conflict type::entity type::military_equipment type::misc
American
topic::none type::gpe0-x type::other
Daisy Cutter
BLU-82
iptc::16000000 topic::conflict type::entity type::military_equipment type::misc
Afghanistan
Afghanistan
topic::none type::entity type::gpe type::gpe0 type::location
Iraq
Iraq
topic::none type::entity type::gpe type::gpe0 type::location
Vietnam
Vietnam
topic::none type::entity type::gpe type::gpe0 type::location
Cold War
Cold_War
iptc::16000000 topic::conflict type::entity type::event type::war
United_States