How 'closed communities' provide a breeding ground for radical Islam
Dr. Elham Manea spent four years studying sharia councils in Britain. Talking to DW in the aftermath of the Manchester attack, she reveals how parallel societies give rise to radicalization and how to prevent it.
DW: The main suspect in the Manchester bombing was born in Britain, as were the 2005 7/7 attackers and the man who crashed his car into pedestrians on Westminster Bridge. In the course of your research into Muslim communities in England and sharia councils, to what degree have you witnessed parallel societies with their own set of rules and behavior? Elham Manea: I prefer to use the word "closed community" as an expression which refers to ghettoized groups, organizing themselves along ethnic and/or religious lines. And in some European societies, specifically in Britain, they create separate cultural and social entities. They function with different cultural norms than those prevalent in British society. And talking specifically about Britain, they have parallel legal structures. Did I observe the existence of these closed communities? Yes, of course. It is a really big problem there. Read: Will Manchester change after the attack? How large are these communities? It depends. Quite often you see them like clusters in certain cities. The problem has more to do with the fact that in places like Birmingham or Bradford, you see certain areas where more than 40 percent of the population are of the Islamic faith. There is nothing wrong with having groups from different backgrounds or a certain faith. The problem is the clustering of certain ethnic groups with certain religious backgrounds in certain areas can lead to social problems - specifically with the spread of certain fundamentalist interpretations of Islam within these communities. How important is it for the more radicalized ones to stay separate from main society because they don't want to have anything to do with the "infidels"? I agree you have this pattern of behavior. I have to insist, nevertheless, that we ascertain that there are closed communities of other faiths in Britain, for instance the Hindus. And they also have their social problems, like gender issues and forced marriages. However, when we talk specifically about closed Islamic communities, we see the added factor of radicalization. Read: 'Heaven will wait': on the religious radicalization of young women There are systematic structures that make sure that the youth are separated from their outside environment ideologically. In Quran schools that follow the Deobandi strand of Islam and in their mosques, they tell children not to emulate the unbelievers, not to behave like them, not to love them, not to associate with them. How are you supposed to live within that society? So we can pour as much money as we want into combating violent extremism, but at the same time we seem to ignore that the nonviolent forms of Islamization are even more important. Because those who are willing to blow themselves up are at the last stage of a radicalization process. And we don't seem to want to look at what is happening before, because it would push us to raise serious questions about the type of integration, structures or policies that we have - or the lack of them. A lot of politicians do not have the courage to look at the public interest. In Britain - in other countries as well, but I am talking right now specifically about Britain - if we don't act in a way that tackles the roots of the problems, Britain will continue to be on high-alert when it comes to terrorism. And it is not coming from outside. It is coming from within. Read: Madrid to Manchester - a timeline of terror in Europe So what would be an appropriate answer? What should the politicians do in the public interest? They should insist on certain kinds of policy measures. I just mentioned Quran schools for instance. From my perspective, any self-respecting politician should insist that Quran schools be supervised by a state authority like any kindergarten. You would not allow a kindergarten that teaches hate speech. But the moment we say this about a Quran school, everybody will say this is a no-go zone. It is about time that we see which types of lessons are being taught at Quran schools, ending this ghettoization, making sure that we have some kind of infrastructure of nonviolent Islamists. These we have to really put under the microscope! What are they doing? What kind of schools are they are supporting? What kind of activities are they doing with young people? I mean, there are many questions that we have to raise. Is it fair to say that those closed societies provide a fertile ground for the type of radicalization that leads to people blowing themselves up? Yes! But I would not say that every closed community leads to radicalization. As I said, you have closed communities of other faiths. However, closed communities of the Islamic faith are more likely to experience high rates of radicalization. There was a study published this year in Britain that showed that high numbers of fighters joining Islamic State came from ghettoized communities. You even have the statistics to prove it. In these ghettoized communities, you still have very strong control by religious leaders who do not exactly set an example when it comes to tolerance. In fact, they speak of separation and very often of hatred. And they exercise control over the closed communities. That control makes it possible to spread the ideology to disillusioned youths. Dr. Elham Manea's latest book was published in 2016 under the title "Women and Sharia Law" and was based on four years of study of sharia councils in many Muslim communities in Great Britain. Dr. Manea works as a lecturer at the Institute for Political Science at the University of Zurich. The interview was conducted by Matthias von Hein.
Islam
Islam Islam_in_the_Philippines Islam_in_Australia Islam_in_Indonesia Islam_in_Ethiopia Sunni_Islam Islam_in_Albania Islam_in_Malaysia Islam_in_the_Republic_of_Macedonia Islam_in_Lebanon Islam_in_India Islam_in_China Islam_in_Sri_Lanka Islam_in_the_United_Kingdom Islam_in_the_United_States Islam_in_Norway
Dr.
Elham Manea
Elham_Manea
Britain
United_Kingdom Great_Britain United_Kingdom_of_Great_Britain_and_Ireland Roman_Britain Kingdom_of_Great_Britain British_Empire Sub-Roman_Britain Prehistoric_Britain British_GAA Britain_in_the_Middle_Ages British_Iron_Age List_of_British_films_of_1959 Early_modern_Britain List_of_British_films_of_1958 Britain_(place_name) England
DW
Drum_Workshop Deutsche_Welle DW-TV Defender_(association_football) Dreamworld_(Australian_theme_park) Data_warehouse Delhi_Wizards D.W._Read DW Discworld
Manchester
Manchester Manchester,_New_Hampshire Manchester_Rugby_Club Manchester,_Connecticut Manchester_Airport University_of_Manchester Old_Trafford_Cricket_Ground Manchester,_Tennessee Manchester,_Vermont Manchester_Piccadilly_station Manchester,_Richmond,_Virginia Manchester_Parish Manchester,_New_York Manchester_(UK_Parliament_constituency) Manchester,_Kentucky Manchester_Velodrome
DW
Drum_Workshop Deutsche_Welle DW-TV Defender_(association_football) Dreamworld_(Australian_theme_park) Data_warehouse Delhi_Wizards D.W._Read DW Discworld
Manchester
Manchester Manchester,_New_Hampshire Manchester_Rugby_Club Manchester,_Connecticut Manchester_Airport University_of_Manchester Old_Trafford_Cricket_Ground Manchester,_Tennessee Manchester,_Vermont Manchester_Piccadilly_station Manchester,_Richmond,_Virginia Manchester_Parish Manchester,_New_York Manchester_(UK_Parliament_constituency) Manchester,_Kentucky Manchester_Velodrome
Britain
United_Kingdom Great_Britain United_Kingdom_of_Great_Britain_and_Ireland Roman_Britain Kingdom_of_Great_Britain British_Empire Sub-Roman_Britain Prehistoric_Britain British_GAA Britain_in_the_Middle_Ages British_Iron_Age List_of_British_films_of_1959 Early_modern_Britain List_of_British_films_of_1958 Britain_(place_name) England
2005
Westminster Bridge
Westminster_Bridge Westminster_tube_station 2017_Westminster_attack Composed_upon_Westminster_Bridge,_September_3,_1802
Muslim
England
England England_national_football_team England_cricket_team England_national_rugby_union_team England_national_rugby_league_team Kingdom_of_England Rugby_Football_Union England_women's_national_football_team The_Football_Association England_women's_cricket_team Football_in_England England_women's_national_rugby_union_team Great_Britain_national_speedway_team England_national_under-21_football_team England_national_under-20_rugby_union_team England_men's_national_hockey_team
Elham Manea
Elham_Manea
European
Britain
United_Kingdom Great_Britain United_Kingdom_of_Great_Britain_and_Ireland Roman_Britain Kingdom_of_Great_Britain British_Empire Sub-Roman_Britain Prehistoric_Britain British_GAA Britain_in_the_Middle_Ages British_Iron_Age List_of_British_films_of_1959 Early_modern_Britain List_of_British_films_of_1958 Britain_(place_name) England
British
Britain
United_Kingdom Great_Britain United_Kingdom_of_Great_Britain_and_Ireland Roman_Britain Kingdom_of_Great_Britain British_Empire Sub-Roman_Britain Prehistoric_Britain British_GAA Britain_in_the_Middle_Ages British_Iron_Age List_of_British_films_of_1959 Early_modern_Britain List_of_British_films_of_1958 Britain_(place_name) England
Manchester
Manchester Manchester,_New_Hampshire Manchester_Rugby_Club Manchester,_Connecticut Manchester_Airport University_of_Manchester Old_Trafford_Cricket_Ground Manchester,_Tennessee Manchester,_Vermont Manchester_Piccadilly_station Manchester,_Richmond,_Virginia Manchester_Parish Manchester,_New_York Manchester_(UK_Parliament_constituency) Manchester,_Kentucky Manchester_Velodrome
Birmingham
Birmingham Birmingham,_Alabama Birmingham_City_F.C. Arena_Birmingham University_of_Birmingham Birmingham_Airport Birmingham,_Michigan Birmingham_Classic_(tennis) Edgbaston_Cricket_Ground Birmingham_New_Street_railway_station British_Grand_Prix_(athletics) Birmingham_(UK_Parliament_constituency) Roman_Catholic_Archdiocese_of_Birmingham Alexander_Stadium Birmingham_City_Council ATP_Birmingham
Bradford
Bradford Bradford_Bulls Bradford_County,_Pennsylvania City_of_Bradford Bradford,_Pennsylvania Bradford_County,_Florida Bradford,_Ontario Bradford_(Park_Avenue)_A.F.C. National_Register_of_Historic_Places_listings_in_Bradford_County,_Florida Chad_Bradford Bradford,_New_Hampshire Bradford,_Massachusetts Bradford,_Manchester Bradford_(UK_Parliament_constituency) Bradford_City_A.F.C. Bradford,_Vermont
Islamic
Islam Islamic_architecture Islamism Islamic_calendar Islamic_art Sharia Islamic_state Islamic_culture Islamic_studies Islamic_mythology Islamic_banking_and_finance Caliphate Islamic_music Islamic_philosophy History_of_Islam Islamic_Golden_Age
Islam
Islam Islam_in_the_Philippines Islam_in_Australia Islam_in_Indonesia Islam_in_Ethiopia Sunni_Islam Islam_in_Albania Islam_in_Malaysia Islam_in_the_Republic_of_Macedonia Islam_in_Lebanon Islam_in_India Islam_in_China Islam_in_Sri_Lanka Islam_in_the_United_Kingdom Islam_in_the_United_States Islam_in_Norway
Britain
United_Kingdom Great_Britain United_Kingdom_of_Great_Britain_and_Ireland Roman_Britain Kingdom_of_Great_Britain British_Empire Sub-Roman_Britain Prehistoric_Britain British_GAA Britain_in_the_Middle_Ages British_Iron_Age List_of_British_films_of_1959 Early_modern_Britain List_of_British_films_of_1958 Britain_(place_name) England
Hindus
Islamic
Islam Islamic_architecture Islamism Islamic_calendar Islamic_art Sharia Islamic_state Islamic_culture Islamic_studies Islamic_mythology Islamic_banking_and_finance Caliphate Islamic_music Islamic_philosophy History_of_Islam Islamic_Golden_Age
Quran
Quran The_Holy_Qur'an:_Text,_Translation_and_Commentary IRIB_Quran Quran_and_miracles Criticism_of_the_Quran Blood_Quran Noble_Quran_(Hilali-Khan) Al-Baqara An-Nisa,_34 Alexander_the_Great_in_the_Quran Mary_in_Islam Violence_in_the_Quran Women_in_the_Quran Islamic_mythology
Deobandi
Deobandi Deoband
Islam
Islam Islam_in_the_Philippines Islam_in_Australia Islam_in_Indonesia Islam_in_Ethiopia Sunni_Islam Islam_in_Albania Islam_in_Malaysia Islam_in_the_Republic_of_Macedonia Islam_in_Lebanon Islam_in_India Islam_in_China Islam_in_Sri_Lanka Islam_in_the_United_Kingdom Islam_in_the_United_States Islam_in_Norway
Islamization
Islamization Muhammad_Zia-ul-Haq's_Islamization Islam Islamization_of_Iran Islam_in_Central_Asia Islamization_of_the_Sudan_region Spread_of_Islam_in_Indonesia Islam_in_Mauritania Islam_in_Palestine Islamic_architecture Islam_in_the_Philippines
Britain
United_Kingdom Great_Britain United_Kingdom_of_Great_Britain_and_Ireland Roman_Britain Kingdom_of_Great_Britain British_Empire Sub-Roman_Britain Prehistoric_Britain British_GAA Britain_in_the_Middle_Ages British_Iron_Age List_of_British_films_of_1959 Early_modern_Britain List_of_British_films_of_1958 Britain_(place_name) England
Britain
United_Kingdom Great_Britain United_Kingdom_of_Great_Britain_and_Ireland Roman_Britain Kingdom_of_Great_Britain British_Empire Sub-Roman_Britain Prehistoric_Britain British_GAA Britain_in_the_Middle_Ages British_Iron_Age List_of_British_films_of_1959 Early_modern_Britain List_of_British_films_of_1958 Britain_(place_name) England
Britain
United_Kingdom Great_Britain United_Kingdom_of_Great_Britain_and_Ireland Roman_Britain Kingdom_of_Great_Britain British_Empire Sub-Roman_Britain Prehistoric_Britain British_GAA Britain_in_the_Middle_Ages British_Iron_Age List_of_British_films_of_1959 Early_modern_Britain List_of_British_films_of_1958 Britain_(place_name) England
Madrid
Madrid Community_of_Madrid Madrid_Open_(tennis) Madrid_(Congress_of_Deputies_constituency) Madrid_Tennis_Grand_Prix Adolfo_Suárez_Madrid–Barajas_Airport Madrid,_Cundinamarca Madrid,_New_York WTA_Madrid_Open_(tennis) 2015_Mutua_Madrid_Open Real_Madrid_C.F. 2016_Mutua_Madrid_Open Madrid,_Iowa 2013_Mutua_Madrid_Open 2018_Mutua_Madrid_Open 2011_Mutua_Madrid_Open
Manchester
Manchester Manchester,_New_Hampshire Manchester_Rugby_Club Manchester,_Connecticut Manchester_Airport University_of_Manchester Old_Trafford_Cricket_Ground Manchester,_Tennessee Manchester,_Vermont Manchester_Piccadilly_station Manchester,_Richmond,_Virginia Manchester_Parish Manchester,_New_York Manchester_(UK_Parliament_constituency) Manchester,_Kentucky Manchester_Velodrome
Europe
Europe UEFA Europe_(band) UEFA_competitions European_Athletic_Association European_theatre_of_World_War_II European_Union Europe_(dinghy) European_Cricket_Council UEFA_Champions_League Senior_League_World_Series_(Europe–Africa_Region) Big_League_World_Series_(Europe–Africa_Region) Sailing_at_the_2004_Summer_Olympics_–_Europe Neolithic_Europe History_of_Europe Europe_(magazine)
Quran
Quran The_Holy_Qur'an:_Text,_Translation_and_Commentary IRIB_Quran Quran_and_miracles Criticism_of_the_Quran Blood_Quran Noble_Quran_(Hilali-Khan) Al-Baqara An-Nisa,_34 Alexander_the_Great_in_the_Quran Mary_in_Islam Violence_in_the_Quran Women_in_the_Quran Islamic_mythology
Quran
Quran The_Holy_Qur'an:_Text,_Translation_and_Commentary IRIB_Quran Quran_and_miracles Criticism_of_the_Quran Blood_Quran Noble_Quran_(Hilali-Khan) Al-Baqara An-Nisa,_34 Alexander_the_Great_in_the_Quran Mary_in_Islam Violence_in_the_Quran Women_in_the_Quran Islamic_mythology
Quran
Quran The_Holy_Qur'an:_Text,_Translation_and_Commentary IRIB_Quran Quran_and_miracles Criticism_of_the_Quran Blood_Quran Noble_Quran_(Hilali-Khan) Al-Baqara An-Nisa,_34 Alexander_the_Great_in_the_Quran Mary_in_Islam Violence_in_the_Quran Women_in_the_Quran Islamic_mythology
Quran
Quran The_Holy_Qur'an:_Text,_Translation_and_Commentary IRIB_Quran Quran_and_miracles Criticism_of_the_Quran Blood_Quran Noble_Quran_(Hilali-Khan) Al-Baqara An-Nisa,_34 Alexander_the_Great_in_the_Quran Mary_in_Islam Violence_in_the_Quran Women_in_the_Quran Islamic_mythology
Islamists
Islamic
Islam Islamic_architecture Islamism Islamic_calendar Islamic_art Sharia Islamic_state Islamic_culture Islamic_studies Islamic_mythology Islamic_banking_and_finance Caliphate Islamic_music Islamic_philosophy History_of_Islam Islamic_Golden_Age
Britain
United_Kingdom Great_Britain United_Kingdom_of_Great_Britain_and_Ireland Roman_Britain Kingdom_of_Great_Britain British_Empire Sub-Roman_Britain Prehistoric_Britain British_GAA Britain_in_the_Middle_Ages British_Iron_Age List_of_British_films_of_1959 Early_modern_Britain List_of_British_films_of_1958 Britain_(place_name) England
Islamic State
Islamic_State_of_Iraq_and_the_Levant Islamic_state Islamic_State_of_Iraq_and_the_Levant_–_Sinai_Province Islamic_State_of_Iraq_and_the_Levant_–_Khorasan_Province Islamic_republic Islamic_State_of_Iraq_and_the_Levant_in_Libya Islamic_State_of_Afghanistan Islamic_State_of_Iraq Caliphate Islamic_State_of_Iraq_and_the_Levant_–_Caucasus_Province Islamism Islamic_state_(disambiguation) Al-Shabaab_(militant_group) South_Thailand_insurgency Azawad Salman_Ramadan_Abedi
Dr.
Elham Manea
Elham_Manea
2016
title
Women and Sharia Law
Muslim
Great Britain
Great_Britain Great_Britain_national_rugby_league_team Kingdom_of_Great_Britain United_Kingdom A1_Team_Great_Britain United_Kingdom_of_Great_Britain_and_Ireland Great_Britain_Olympic_football_team List_of_non-marine_molluscs_of_Great_Britain Great_Britain_national_speedway_team Peerage_of_Great_Britain Great_Britain_at_the_Olympics Great_Britain_men's_national_field_hockey_team English_poetry Great_Britain_Davis_Cup_team Great_Britain_at_the_2012_Summer_Olympics Great_Britain_at_the_1908_Summer_Olympics
Dr.
Manea
Manea,_Cambridgeshire Manea_railway_station Manele MANEA Manea_River Nicolae_Manea
Institute for Political Science
University of Zurich
University_of_Zurich
Matthias von Hein
Great Britain
United_Kingdom
slot::in slot::keyword topic::none type::entity type::gpe type::gpe0 type::location
Islamization
Islam
iptc::12000000 slot::keyword topic::none topic::religion type::entity type::misc type::other type::religion type::religion-x
Elham Manea
Elham_Manea
gender::female iptc::01000000 iptc::05000000 iptc::20000013 slot::interviewee slot::keyword topic::culture topic::education type::artist type::entity type::person type::teacher type::writer
Manchester
Manchester
slot::in slot::keyword topic::none type::entity type::gpe type::gpe2 type::location
Dr.
topic::none type::role type::value
DW
Deutsche_Welle
topic::media type::entity type::media type::organization
2005
topic::none type::time type::value
Westminster Bridge
Westminster_Bridge
topic::none type::entity type::location type::street
Muslim
iptc::12000000 topic::none topic::religion type::other type::religion-x
European
topic::none type::loc-x type::other
British
topic::none type::gpe0-x type::other
Birmingham
Birmingham
topic::none type::entity type::gpe type::gpe2 type::location
Bradford
Bradford
topic::none type::entity type::gpe type::gpe2 type::location
Hindus
Hinduism
iptc::12000000 topic::none topic::religion type::other type::religion-x
Quran
Quran
iptc::12000000 topic::religion type::entity type::misc type::religion_misc
Deobandi
Deobandi
iptc::12000000 topic::religion type::entity type::misc type::religion
Madrid
Madrid
topic::none type::entity type::gpe type::gpe2 type::location
Europe
Europe
topic::none type::entity type::location type::regio
Islamists
iptc::12000000 topic::none topic::religion type::other type::religion-x
Islamic State
Islamic_State_of_Iraq_and_the_Levant
iptc::16000000 topic::conflict type::armed_movement type::entity type::organization
2016
topic::none type::time type::value
title
topic::none type::role type::value
Women and Sharia Law
iptc::01000000 iptc::20000013 topic::culture type::book_title type::entity type::misc type::work_of_art
Institute for Political Science
iptc::13000000 topic::science type::entity type::organization type::research_center
University of Zurich
University_of_Zurich
iptc::05000000 topic::education type::education_org type::entity type::organization
Matthias von Hein
gender::male slot::interviewer topic::media type::entity type::journalist type::person
Islamism
Spain
Switzerland
Germany