Opinion: Juncker takes the bull by the horns
EU Commission president Jean-Claude Juncker regrets Luxembourg's tax-saving tricks for big business and wants to put a stop to them. That won't do much for his credibility, says Christoph Hasselbach.
Jean-Claude Juncker has gone on the offensive, but he left it very late. Juncker went into hiding for days, leaving his spokesperson to represent him, but he now admits it was a mistake not to comment on last week's accusations of tax evasion by multinational firms in his home country. He also regrets the tax advantages themselves. Now, suddenly, after the pressure continued to mount, the Commission is proposing an automatic exchange of information about these sorts of tax arrangements, and a uniform basis for assessment. In other words, the system Juncker spent more than twenty years building up in his homeland as prime minister and finance minister of Luxembourg is now to be combated at the European level. The initiative comes across as a clumsy attempt to draw a veil over Juncker's previous role. Entire country as a tax-saving scheme It clearly took the wily politician far too long to grasp the explosive potential of the affair, perhaps because it had become so normal. Using complicated financial constructs, Luxembourg has ensured that international firms have been able to save taxes that apparently amount to billions of euros. As Juncker was the country's finance minister for 20 years and prime minister of the Grand Duchy for almost as long - mostly simultaneously - he was intimately involved in the country's development into a financial center. The fact that the entire country functioned as a tax-saving scheme for rich foreigners and international companies contributed in large part to Luxembourg having by far the highest per capita income in the EU. But Luxembourg is not an isolated case. Ireland and the Netherlands have also made big tax concessions to big businesses. And all the governments knew it. Just a few days ago around 50 states, including Luxembourg, signed an agreement on the mutual exchange of information on bank customers. Such resolve is however still lacking where company taxation is concerned. Ordinary citizens make up the shortfall The Commission did initiate inspections of Ireland, the Netherlands, and Luxembourg in 2013; but these looked into questions of competition, not whether such tax deals were in themselves illegal. Yet this is precisely where the problem lies. Even Juncker now admits that just because something is legally permissible it doesn't follow that it is morally acceptable. If one EU country attracts business by offering incomparably low levels of taxation, it is living at the expense of others who can't afford to, or don't want to accept the loss of income. In the end, it is always ordinary citizens who have to make up the shortfall, with their taxes. This, and the fact that Europe has until now tolerated this ruinous competition, is the real scandal. It is grist to the mills of those who want to destroy the European idea. No wonder the French far-right leader Marine le Pen was the first to call for Juncker's resignation. She and all those of a similar political persuasion all over Europe are going to have a field day. Resignation unlikely Nonetheless, Juncker will almost certainly stay on as president of the Commission. The majority of his supporters in the Council of Europe and in the European Parliament will make sure of that. His election process was protracted and complicated; many other personnel decisions also depended on it, and party-political and geographical aspects had to be taken into account. Starting all over again now would open a huge can of worms. Besides, his resignation could well intensify the widespread public sense that the European elite are failing. In view of the current mood of rampant euroskepticism, Juncker spoke of "Europe's last chance" when he presented the new Commission. It must, then, have been clear to him what was at stake. What he clearly underestimated was the his personal role in whether the "last chance" will be seized or lost. One can only hope that this affair has shaken the EU awake, and that it really will put an end to minimal taxation for big businesses. It's a move that would be certain to win public approval.
Juncker
Juncker_Commission Jean-Claude_Juncker Juncker
EU Commission
European_Commission
president
Jean-Claude Juncker
Jean-Claude_Juncker Juncker_Commission
Luxembourg
Luxembourg Luxembourg_City Luxembourg_national_football_team Luxembourg_(Belgium) Same-sex_marriage_in_Luxembourg Luxembourg_(canton) House_of_Luxembourg Luxembourg_Football_Federation Luxembourg_national_under-21_football_team Luxembourg_District Luxembourg_railway_station Luxembourg_in_the_Eurovision_Song_Contest Luxembourg_Open Luxembourg_Fed_Cup_team Luxembourg_women's_national_football_team Luxembourg_Davis_Cup_team
Christoph Hasselbach
Jean-Claude Juncker
Jean-Claude_Juncker Juncker_Commission
Juncker
Juncker_Commission Jean-Claude_Juncker Juncker
Commission
Commissioned_officer Commission_(remuneration) Officer_(armed_forces) European_Commission Ship_commissioning Letters_patent Commission_(document) The_Commission_(mafia) Government_agency Commission_(art) City_commission_government U.S._Securities_and_Exchange_Commission Committee County_commission Contract Sicilian_Mafia_Commission
Juncker
Juncker_Commission Jean-Claude_Juncker Juncker
Luxembourg
Luxembourg Luxembourg_City Luxembourg_national_football_team Luxembourg_(Belgium) Same-sex_marriage_in_Luxembourg Luxembourg_(canton) House_of_Luxembourg Luxembourg_Football_Federation Luxembourg_national_under-21_football_team Luxembourg_District Luxembourg_railway_station Luxembourg_in_the_Eurovision_Song_Contest Luxembourg_Open Luxembourg_Fed_Cup_team Luxembourg_women's_national_football_team Luxembourg_Davis_Cup_team
European
Europe Ethnic_groups_in_Europe European_Boxing_Union UEFA European_Union European_Figure_Skating_Championships European_Aviation_Air_Charter European_Canadians List_of_European_records_in_athletics European_theatre_of_World_War_II European_Americans European_cuisine Culture_of_Europe PGA_European_Tour White_people European_New_Zealanders
Juncker
Juncker_Commission Jean-Claude_Juncker Juncker
Luxembourg
Luxembourg Luxembourg_City Luxembourg_national_football_team Luxembourg_(Belgium) Same-sex_marriage_in_Luxembourg Luxembourg_(canton) House_of_Luxembourg Luxembourg_Football_Federation Luxembourg_national_under-21_football_team Luxembourg_District Luxembourg_railway_station Luxembourg_in_the_Eurovision_Song_Contest Luxembourg_Open Luxembourg_Fed_Cup_team Luxembourg_women's_national_football_team Luxembourg_Davis_Cup_team
billions of euros
Juncker
Juncker_Commission Jean-Claude_Juncker Juncker
Grand Duchy
Grand_duchy Grand_Duchy_of_Finland Grand_Duchy_(band) Grand_Duchy_of_Lithuania Grand_Duchy_of_Baden Luxembourg List_of_monarchs_of_Luxembourg Grand_Duchy_of_Hesse Grand_Duchy_of_Oldenburg Grand_Duchy_of_Kraków Grand_Duchy_of_Tuscany Grand_Duchy_of_Moscow Grand_Duke_of_Finland Grand_Duchy_of_Luxembourg Grand_duke Grand_Duchy_of_Berg
Luxembourg
Luxembourg Luxembourg_City Luxembourg_national_football_team Luxembourg_(Belgium) Same-sex_marriage_in_Luxembourg Luxembourg_(canton) House_of_Luxembourg Luxembourg_Football_Federation Luxembourg_national_under-21_football_team Luxembourg_District Luxembourg_railway_station Luxembourg_in_the_Eurovision_Song_Contest Luxembourg_Open Luxembourg_Fed_Cup_team Luxembourg_women's_national_football_team Luxembourg_Davis_Cup_team
EU
European_Union Europe List_of_European_records_in_swimming Eu,_Seine-Maritime E.U._(TV_series) European_Hot_100_Singles .eu European_Top_100_Albums Europium International_Federation_of_the_Phonographic_Industry United_Left_(Galicia) Experience_Unlimited United_Left_of_the_Balearic_Islands Esquerra_de_Menorca United_Extremadura Citizenship_of_the_European_Union
Luxembourg
Luxembourg Luxembourg_City Luxembourg_national_football_team Luxembourg_(Belgium) Same-sex_marriage_in_Luxembourg Luxembourg_(canton) House_of_Luxembourg Luxembourg_Football_Federation Luxembourg_national_under-21_football_team Luxembourg_District Luxembourg_railway_station Luxembourg_in_the_Eurovision_Song_Contest Luxembourg_Open Luxembourg_Fed_Cup_team Luxembourg_women's_national_football_team Luxembourg_Davis_Cup_team
Ireland
Ireland Republic_of_Ireland Ireland_national_rugby_union_team Ireland_cricket_team Ireland_national_football_team_(1882–1950) Irish_Rugby_Football_Union Republic_of_Ireland_national_football_team Ireland_men's_national_rugby_league_team Kingdom_of_Ireland Ireland_international_rules_football_team A1_Team_Ireland Ireland_women's_cricket_team Peerage_of_Ireland Same-sex_marriage_in_the_Republic_of_Ireland List_of_non-marine_molluscs_of_Ireland Irish_poetry
Netherlands
Netherlands Netherlands_national_football_team Netherlands_national_cricket_team Royal_Dutch_Football_Association Netherlands_women's_national_football_team A1_Team_Netherlands Netherlands_women's_national_cricket_team Same-sex_marriage_in_the_Netherlands Netherlands_national_under-21_football_team Kingdom_of_the_Netherlands Netherlands_national_baseball_team List_of_non-marine_molluscs_of_the_Netherlands Dutch_Top_40 Netherlands_national_cerebral_palsy_football_team ISU_Junior_Grand_Prix_in_the_Netherlands Dutch_Republic
Luxembourg
Luxembourg Luxembourg_City Luxembourg_national_football_team Luxembourg_(Belgium) Same-sex_marriage_in_Luxembourg Luxembourg_(canton) House_of_Luxembourg Luxembourg_Football_Federation Luxembourg_national_under-21_football_team Luxembourg_District Luxembourg_railway_station Luxembourg_in_the_Eurovision_Song_Contest Luxembourg_Open Luxembourg_Fed_Cup_team Luxembourg_women's_national_football_team Luxembourg_Davis_Cup_team
Commission
Commissioned_officer Commission_(remuneration) Officer_(armed_forces) European_Commission Ship_commissioning Letters_patent Commission_(document) The_Commission_(mafia) Government_agency Commission_(art) City_commission_government U.S._Securities_and_Exchange_Commission Committee County_commission Contract Sicilian_Mafia_Commission
Netherlands
Netherlands Netherlands_national_football_team Netherlands_national_cricket_team Royal_Dutch_Football_Association Netherlands_women's_national_football_team A1_Team_Netherlands Netherlands_women's_national_cricket_team Same-sex_marriage_in_the_Netherlands Netherlands_national_under-21_football_team Kingdom_of_the_Netherlands Netherlands_national_baseball_team List_of_non-marine_molluscs_of_the_Netherlands Dutch_Top_40 Netherlands_national_cerebral_palsy_football_team ISU_Junior_Grand_Prix_in_the_Netherlands Dutch_Republic
Luxembourg
Luxembourg Luxembourg_City Luxembourg_national_football_team Luxembourg_(Belgium) Same-sex_marriage_in_Luxembourg Luxembourg_(canton) House_of_Luxembourg Luxembourg_Football_Federation Luxembourg_national_under-21_football_team Luxembourg_District Luxembourg_railway_station Luxembourg_in_the_Eurovision_Song_Contest Luxembourg_Open Luxembourg_Fed_Cup_team Luxembourg_women's_national_football_team Luxembourg_Davis_Cup_team
2013
Juncker
Juncker_Commission Jean-Claude_Juncker Juncker
EU
European_Union Europe List_of_European_records_in_swimming Eu,_Seine-Maritime E.U._(TV_series) European_Hot_100_Singles .eu European_Top_100_Albums Europium International_Federation_of_the_Phonographic_Industry United_Left_(Galicia) Experience_Unlimited United_Left_of_the_Balearic_Islands Esquerra_de_Menorca United_Extremadura Citizenship_of_the_European_Union
Europe
Europe UEFA Europe_(band) UEFA_competitions European_Athletic_Association European_theatre_of_World_War_II European_Union Europe_(dinghy) European_Cricket_Council UEFA_Champions_League Senior_League_World_Series_(Europe–Africa_Region) Big_League_World_Series_(Europe–Africa_Region) Sailing_at_the_2004_Summer_Olympics_–_Europe Neolithic_Europe History_of_Europe Europe_(magazine)
European
Europe Ethnic_groups_in_Europe European_Boxing_Union UEFA European_Union European_Figure_Skating_Championships European_Aviation_Air_Charter European_Canadians List_of_European_records_in_athletics European_theatre_of_World_War_II European_Americans European_cuisine Culture_of_Europe PGA_European_Tour White_people European_New_Zealanders
French
far-right leader
Marine le Pen
Marine_Le_Pen
Juncker
Juncker_Commission Jean-Claude_Juncker Juncker
Europe
Europe UEFA Europe_(band) UEFA_competitions European_Athletic_Association European_theatre_of_World_War_II European_Union Europe_(dinghy) European_Cricket_Council UEFA_Champions_League Senior_League_World_Series_(Europe–Africa_Region) Big_League_World_Series_(Europe–Africa_Region) Sailing_at_the_2004_Summer_Olympics_–_Europe Neolithic_Europe History_of_Europe Europe_(magazine)
Juncker
Juncker_Commission Jean-Claude_Juncker Juncker
Commission
Commissioned_officer Commission_(remuneration) Officer_(armed_forces) European_Commission Ship_commissioning Letters_patent Commission_(document) The_Commission_(mafia) Government_agency Commission_(art) City_commission_government U.S._Securities_and_Exchange_Commission Committee County_commission Contract Sicilian_Mafia_Commission
Council of Europe
Council_of_Europe Parliamentary_Assembly_of_the_Council_of_Europe List_of_Presidents_of_the_Parliamentary_Assembly_of_the_Council_of_Europe Congress_of_the_Council_of_Europe Flag_of_Europe
European Parliament
European_Parliament European_Parliament_election,_2009_(United_Kingdom) Member_of_the_European_Parliament Espace_Léopold Seat_of_the_European_Parliament_in_Strasbourg European_Parliament_election,_1994_(Spain) Elections_to_the_European_Parliament European_Parliament_election,_1987_(Spain) European_Parliament_election,_2014_(United_Kingdom) European_Parliament_election,_2014_(Poland) London_(European_Parliament_constituency) European_Parliament_election,_2014_(Spain) European_Parliament_election,_2009_(Spain) European_Parliament_election,_2004_(Spain) European_Parliament_election,_1989_(Spain) List_of_members_of_the_European_Parliament_for_Greece,_2014–19
European
Europe Ethnic_groups_in_Europe European_Boxing_Union UEFA European_Union European_Figure_Skating_Championships European_Aviation_Air_Charter European_Canadians List_of_European_records_in_athletics European_theatre_of_World_War_II European_Americans European_cuisine Culture_of_Europe PGA_European_Tour White_people European_New_Zealanders
Juncker
Juncker_Commission Jean-Claude_Juncker Juncker
Europe
Europe UEFA Europe_(band) UEFA_competitions European_Athletic_Association European_theatre_of_World_War_II European_Union Europe_(dinghy) European_Cricket_Council UEFA_Champions_League Senior_League_World_Series_(Europe–Africa_Region) Big_League_World_Series_(Europe–Africa_Region) Sailing_at_the_2004_Summer_Olympics_–_Europe Neolithic_Europe History_of_Europe Europe_(magazine)
Commission
Commissioned_officer Commission_(remuneration) Officer_(armed_forces) European_Commission Ship_commissioning Letters_patent Commission_(document) The_Commission_(mafia) Government_agency Commission_(art) City_commission_government U.S._Securities_and_Exchange_Commission Committee County_commission Contract Sicilian_Mafia_Commission
EU
European_Union Europe List_of_European_records_in_swimming Eu,_Seine-Maritime E.U._(TV_series) European_Hot_100_Singles .eu European_Top_100_Albums Europium International_Federation_of_the_Phonographic_Industry United_Left_(Galicia) Experience_Unlimited United_Left_of_the_Balearic_Islands Esquerra_de_Menorca United_Extremadura Citizenship_of_the_European_Union
Grand Duchy
Luxembourg
slot::keyword topic::none type::entity type::gpe type::gpe0 type::location
European
European_Union
iptc::11000000 slot::in slot::keyword topic::none topic::politics type::entity type::igo type::loc-x type::organization type::other type::so
EU Commission
European_Commission
iptc::11000000 slot::keyword topic::politics type::entity type::igo type::organization
Jean-Claude Juncker
Jean-Claude_Juncker
gender::male iptc::11000000 slot::keyword topic::politics type::entity type::minister type::person type::politician
Council of Europe
Council_of_Europe
iptc::11000000 slot::keyword topic::politics type::entity type::igo type::organization
president
topic::none type::role type::value
Christoph Hasselbach
gender::male meta::todo topic::none type::entity type::person
billions of euros
topic::none type::money type::value
Ireland
Ireland
topic::none type::entity type::gpe type::gpe0 type::location
Netherlands
Netherlands
topic::none type::entity type::gpe type::gpe0 type::location
2013
topic::none type::time type::value
French
topic::none type::gpe0-x type::other
far-right leader
topic::none type::role type::value
Marine le Pen
Marine_Le_Pen
gender::female iptc::11000000 topic::politics type::entity type::person type::politician
European Parliament
European_Parliament
iptc::11000000 topic::politics type::entity type::igo type::organization
France