'The DFB has lost touch with the fans'
The DFB has introduced plenty of things to upset the fans: varying kickoff times, VAR and China's U20s playing in the country's fourth tier. Fan researcher Harald Lange told DW that the fans have every right to be angry.
DW: Professor Lange, has the German football association (DFB) lost touch with the fans? Harald Lange: This has been true for some time now. This is because fans are not usually the center of attention for the league and club executives. They are perceived as paying customers, as consumers, rather than as passionate, proud fans who contribute to football's culture. Is the DFB actually after a different target audience than the supporters that one usually sees on the terraces? They have a very different view of the fans on the terraces. The DFB tends to perceive them as a disruptive factor, when they protest, when they cross the line, or because they just don't fit into their aesthetics. The belief is that when the fans that create the atmosphere stop attending games, others will replace them. But this won't work in the future. Two weeks ago, there was a meeting between DFB President Reinhard Grindel and representatives of Ultras and other fan groups. The DFB later stated that an open and frank discussion had taken place, but there was no comment from the fan groups. Is this a symptom of the problem? The fans are very distrusting. On the one hand, Mr. Grindel has made concessions and seems to have reached out to fans by doing things like suspending collective punishments. However, the fans don't know how to take this. They don't know whether the DFB has done this simply to curb the criticism of it that was seen in the stadiums in the first few games, or whether it is genuinely interested in building an idea of fan culture that is shared by supporters. The list of complaints against the DFB is long. For one thing, the fans complain about the changing game times and increasing prices. Isn't it understandable for the fans to be skeptical? Of course it is. The underlying question is: What is so special about our fan culture? And above all, who does football belong to? Everybody involved is claiming ownership. The fact of the matter is that without the fans, football as we know it wouldn't exist. You wouldn't be able to earn a single euro anymore, because without the fans you would not be able to attract advertizing. The DFB doesn't take this fact seriously. They think they can compensate by attracting spectators who are into events; people who would go to football one day, handball the next and to the opera the day after that. You've been able to observe this at national team games for the past several years. The atmosphere is staged, as DFB workers attempt to whip-up enthusiasm. However, whenever a match is close, the supporters of the German national team will always be out-sung by the fans of their opponents. That's because what's behind the national team's "fan club" is a highly commercialized aparatus that decides who gets into the stadium and how. This has nothing to do with fan culture. Let's talk more about the commercial side of things. The fans are also upset about the introduction of friendlies between Regionalliga Südwest sides and China's under-20 team. A meeting between the DFB and the fans was canceled because, according to the fans, the DFB refused to allow journalists to be present. Does this not demonstrate that the differences between the two sides are nearly impossible to overcome? The gap is so great because their basic positions are so far apart and there's no real attempt to mediate. Instead, they isolate themselves from each other. Journalism would be a great vehicle to find out: What is the fan thinking? How did fan culture develop into what it is today? Why is it different here from those in Spain, Italy or England? The DFB's general line is pretty well known, but a fundamental understanding does not exist. That's why there are these turf wars, both sides dig their heels in instead of opening up to each other. Another bone of contention in recent weeks has been the implementation of VAR (video assistant referees). The way decisions are being made is utterly opaque for the fans. Is this causing further alienation between the fans and the DFB? I think the system has failed so far,making football more complicated and opaque. You can't say that the fans are being played-off against the executives, but it certainly does not serve to highlight football at its core. Technology is pumped in from outside and then it takes a couple of minutes to find out: Was it a foul or not? Was it a goal or not? That is a killer for the atmosphere in a sport that lives on spontaneity. So even wrong decisions contribute to the atmposphere and the emotions. This is being reduced to some extent. Do you think football as we know it is in the process of dying? (Laughs) That's too extreme. But what you can say is that for years, football has been undergoing some very rapid changes. Depending on your position, you can see this as a good or bad thing. From the point of view of an economist, I would say football has turned into a wonderful business, and many people make a lot of money out of it. On the other hand, if you look at it from the perspective of the real fans who have deep ties to their club through tradition, their city or their region, they have lost a great deal, as others earn a lot of money using the object of their identity, their emotions and their commitment. They feel massively betrayed. That is the breeding ground for protests, but also for conflicts. Professor Harald Lange is the head of sports science at the University of Würzburg. He is an avid football fan and he established Germany's first institute for fan culture in 2012.
DFB
German_Football_Association Humid_continental_climate New_Zealand_DF_class_locomotive_(1979) Distributed_feedback_laser Continental_climate DFB Continental_Mediterranean_climate
DFB
German_Football_Association Humid_continental_climate New_Zealand_DF_class_locomotive_(1979) Distributed_feedback_laser Continental_climate DFB Continental_Mediterranean_climate
VAR
Var_(department) Variety_(botany) Variable_star_designation Var_(river) Autodromo_Riccardo_Paletti FK_Vardar NK_Varaždin_(1931–2015) Varese_Calcio Video_assistant_referee Vár Varzim_S.C. Value_at_risk RK_Vardar Vector_autoregression Value-added_reseller Jibou
China
China China_national_football_team Republic_of_China_(1912–1949) China_women's_national_football_team Qing_dynasty Chinese_Basketball_Association A1_Team_China Cinema_of_China China_men's_national_basketball_team History_of_China China_national_badminton_team Recognition_of_same-sex_unions_in_China Taiwan Chinese_Football_Association Porcelain China_national_baseball_team
U20
England_national_under-20_football_team Argentina_national_under-20_football_team Canada_men's_national_under-20_soccer_team United_States_men's_national_under-20_soccer_team France_national_under-20_football_team Italy_national_under-20_football_team Junior_ice_hockey Australia_national_under-20_soccer_team Germany_national_under-20_football_team Serbia_national_under-20_football_team J20_SuperElit Denmark_national_under-19_football_team Croatia_national_under-20_football_team Chile_national_under-20_football_team Pune_F.C._Academy England_national_under-20_rugby_union_team
researcher
Harald Lange
German_submarine_U-505
DW
Drum_Workshop Deutsche_Welle DW-TV Defender_(association_football) Dreamworld_(Australian_theme_park) Data_warehouse Delhi_Wizards D.W._Read DW Discworld
DW
Drum_Workshop Deutsche_Welle DW-TV Defender_(association_football) Dreamworld_(Australian_theme_park) Data_warehouse Delhi_Wizards D.W._Read DW Discworld
Professor
Lange
Lange_(musician) David_Lange The_Angel_(1982_film) Lange_(ski_boots) Lang'e_language Lange_Aviation Lange,_Estonia Johan_Lange Lange_(surname) Langé Rudolf_Lange Lange,_Western_Australia Jakob_Emanuel_Lange Friedrich_Albert_Lange Rune_Lange Anne_Françoise_Elisabeth_Lange
German football association
German_Football_Association
DFB
German_Football_Association Humid_continental_climate New_Zealand_DF_class_locomotive_(1979) Distributed_feedback_laser Continental_climate DFB Continental_Mediterranean_climate
Harald Lange
German_submarine_U-505
DFB
German_Football_Association Humid_continental_climate New_Zealand_DF_class_locomotive_(1979) Distributed_feedback_laser Continental_climate DFB Continental_Mediterranean_climate
DFB
German_Football_Association Humid_continental_climate New_Zealand_DF_class_locomotive_(1979) Distributed_feedback_laser Continental_climate DFB Continental_Mediterranean_climate
DFB
German_Football_Association Humid_continental_climate New_Zealand_DF_class_locomotive_(1979) Distributed_feedback_laser Continental_climate DFB Continental_Mediterranean_climate
President
Reinhard Grindel
Reinhard_Grindel
Ultras
Ultras Ultra-royalist Ultra-prominent_peak Ultra_(Malaysia) Ultras_(comics) Juventus_F.C._ultras Insurgency_in_Jammu_and_Kashmir Ultra Extremism Ultra_(British_band) Ultra-Tories
DFB
German_Football_Association Humid_continental_climate New_Zealand_DF_class_locomotive_(1979) Distributed_feedback_laser Continental_climate DFB Continental_Mediterranean_climate
Grindel
Grindel,_Switzerland
DFB
German_Football_Association Humid_continental_climate New_Zealand_DF_class_locomotive_(1979) Distributed_feedback_laser Continental_climate DFB Continental_Mediterranean_climate
DFB
German_Football_Association Humid_continental_climate New_Zealand_DF_class_locomotive_(1979) Distributed_feedback_laser Continental_climate DFB Continental_Mediterranean_climate
DFB
German_Football_Association Humid_continental_climate New_Zealand_DF_class_locomotive_(1979) Distributed_feedback_laser Continental_climate DFB Continental_Mediterranean_climate
DFB
German_Football_Association Humid_continental_climate New_Zealand_DF_class_locomotive_(1979) Distributed_feedback_laser Continental_climate DFB Continental_Mediterranean_climate
German
Regionalliga Südwest
Regionalliga_Südwest Regionalliga_Südwest_(1963–1974) Frauen-Regionalliga 2016–17_Regionalliga
China
China China_national_football_team Republic_of_China_(1912–1949) China_women's_national_football_team Qing_dynasty Chinese_Basketball_Association A1_Team_China Cinema_of_China China_men's_national_basketball_team History_of_China China_national_badminton_team Recognition_of_same-sex_unions_in_China Taiwan Chinese_Football_Association Porcelain China_national_baseball_team
under-20 team
France_national_under-20_football_team Portugal_national_under-20_football_team Spain_national_under-20_football_team Colombia_national_under-20_football_team Canada_men's_national_under-20_soccer_team Argentina_national_under-20_football_team Italy_national_under-20_football_team South_Korea_national_under-20_football_team Ghana_national_under-20_football_team Campionato_Nazionale_Dante_Berretti Cameroon_national_under-20_football_team Norway_national_under-19_football_team Serbia_national_under-20_football_team United_States_men's_national_under-20_soccer_team Canada_women's_national_under-20_soccer_team Spain_national_under-20_basketball_team
DFB
German_Football_Association Humid_continental_climate New_Zealand_DF_class_locomotive_(1979) Distributed_feedback_laser Continental_climate DFB Continental_Mediterranean_climate
DFB
German_Football_Association Humid_continental_climate New_Zealand_DF_class_locomotive_(1979) Distributed_feedback_laser Continental_climate DFB Continental_Mediterranean_climate
Spain
Spain Spain_national_football_team Royal_Spanish_Football_Federation Liga_ACB Spanish_Empire Spain_men's_national_basketball_team Spain_national_rugby_union_team Restoration_(Spain) Habsburg_Spain Francoist_Spain Royal_Spanish_Cycling_Federation Spain_women's_national_football_team Same-sex_marriage_in_Spain Spain_national_under-21_football_team Spanish_poetry Spain_national_beach_soccer_team
Italy
Italy Italy_national_football_team Italy_national_rugby_union_team Kingdom_of_Italy Italian_Football_Federation Italy_national_rugby_league_team Italian_Campaign_(World_War_II) Italy_women's_national_football_team Lega_Basket_Serie_A Italian_Rugby_Federation A1_Team_Italy ISU_Junior_Grand_Prix_in_Italy Italy_national_basketball_team Kingdom_of_Italy_(Holy_Roman_Empire) Italy_national_under-21_football_team Cinema_of_Italy
England
England England_national_football_team England_cricket_team England_national_rugby_union_team England_national_rugby_league_team Kingdom_of_England Rugby_Football_Union England_women's_national_football_team The_Football_Association England_women's_cricket_team Football_in_England England_women's_national_rugby_union_team Great_Britain_national_speedway_team England_national_under-21_football_team England_national_under-20_rugby_union_team England_men's_national_hockey_team
DFB
German_Football_Association Humid_continental_climate New_Zealand_DF_class_locomotive_(1979) Distributed_feedback_laser Continental_climate DFB Continental_Mediterranean_climate
VAR
Var_(department) Variety_(botany) Variable_star_designation Var_(river) Autodromo_Riccardo_Paletti FK_Vardar NK_Varaždin_(1931–2015) Varese_Calcio Video_assistant_referee Vár Varzim_S.C. Value_at_risk RK_Vardar Vector_autoregression Value-added_reseller Jibou
video assistant referees
Video_assistant_referee
DFB
German_Football_Association Humid_continental_climate New_Zealand_DF_class_locomotive_(1979) Distributed_feedback_laser Continental_climate DFB Continental_Mediterranean_climate
Professor
Harald Lange
German_submarine_U-505
University of Würzburg
University_of_Würzburg
Germany
Germany Germany_national_football_team Nazi_Germany German_Empire Germany_women's_national_football_team Weimar_Republic German_Football_Association ISU_Junior_Grand_Prix_in_Germany GfK_Entertainment_Charts Germany_national_youth_football_team A1_Team_Germany Germany_national_rugby_union_team Kingdom_of_Germany German_literature Germany_men's_national_ice_hockey_team Same-sex_marriage_in_Germany
2012
under-20 team
China_national_under-20_football_team
iptc::15000000 sport::20001065 topic::sport type::entity type::organization type::sport_team
German football association
German_Football_Association
iptc::15000000 slot::keyword sport::20001065 topic::sport type::entity type::organization type::sport_org
Reinhard Grindel
Reinhard_Grindel
gender::male iptc::15000000 slot::keyword topic::sport type::entity type::person type::sport_head
video assistant referees
Video_assistant_referee
slot::keyword type::concept type::entity type::misc
Harald Lange
gender::male iptc::05000000 slot::keyword topic::education type::entity type::person type::teacher
University of Würzburg
University_of_Würzburg
iptc::05000000 slot::keyword topic::education type::education_org type::entity type::organization
China
China
topic::none type::entity type::gpe type::gpe0 type::location
researcher
topic::none type::role type::value
DW
Deutsche_Welle
topic::media type::entity type::media type::organization
Professor
topic::none type::role type::value
President
topic::none type::role type::value
Ultras
Ultras
iptc::15000000 sport::20001065 topic::sport type::entity type::organization type::sport_org
German
topic::none type::gpe0-x type::other
Regionalliga Südwest
Regionalliga_Südwest
iptc::15000000 sport::20001065 sport_event::20001118 topic::sport type::competition type::entity type::event type::sport_competition
Spain
Spain
topic::none type::entity type::gpe type::gpe0 type::location
Italy
Italy
topic::none type::entity type::gpe type::gpe0 type::location
England
United_Kingdom
topic::none type::entity type::gpe type::gpe0 type::location
Germany
Germany
slot::in topic::none type::entity type::gpe type::gpe0 type::location
2012
topic::none type::time type::value