'US and Germany can't afford chasm of trust'
The alleged NSA monitoring of Chancellor Angela Merkel's mobile could have serious consequences. The EU should make the first step in raising the bar on transparency, former Hillary Clinton adviser Ben Scott told DW.
Ben Scott is currently program director at the Berlin-based think tank Stiftung Neue Verantwortung (New Responsibility Foundation). He served as an adviser on technology and foreign policy to former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton in Barack Obama's first administration. DW: US intelligence stands accused of having spied on German Chancellor Angela Merkel's mobile. Berlin is upset and Merkel has already called US President Obama to discuss the matter. How big is the damage? Ben Scott: If it's true that the National Security Agency has tapped the phone of the German chancellor then that is a pretty serious political problem. And it indicates the misalignment between US American and European expectations on appropriate practices, on intelligence and foreign surveillance. Were you surprised at all when you heard about the allegations? Yes - pretty surprised. Tapping the phone of a world leader is something that I think is a decision you don't take lightly and has a lot of consequences if it is exposed. How will or should Germany react to this? We've already seen the initial reaction which is instant outrage and demands for explanation at every level all the way up to the top. But I think that the most important medium-term response is not just a demand to stop surveilling the chancellor's phone but a demand for an engagement government to government so that we'll have a policy solution. This incident is reflective of a larger division between the two countries' expectations and policies on surveillance. And I think it requires discussion and realignment because the US and Germany of course are long-time and very important allies. They can not afford to be separated by a big chasm of trust. What are the implications in terms of Trans-Atlantic relations? I think it speaks for the need for Trans-Atlantic engagement on these issues and a resolution about what standard practice should look like between allies when it comes to mass surveillance technologies. The irony of the (Edward) Snowden revelations is that we now know quite a bit about the NSA's practices. We don't know those facts about the German intelligence agency or the French intelligence agency. And if Europe wants to raise the bar and say this is the new standard for digital surveillance and this is appropriate and this is what's not and we demand the that United States comply, they have to be much more transparent about what they themselves do. There is no minimum standard for the protection of privacy among European states. Pretty much every country protects its own citizens at a much higher standard than they protect foreign citizens and I think one of the first steps has to be that the EU comes up with a common agreement amongst its member states. Do you think it's actually possible that EU members amongst themselves or the EU and the US can agree on a no-spy deal? I think it is. If NATO allies can organize themselves to go to war together, they can certainly decide to stop spying on one another. It's a question of political will and it's a question I think of a public debate of the costs and benefits of surveillance on your friends. What are the benefits that are so important to one side or the other that it's worth risking the political damage if exposed. And I think we should be careful to not put all the blame on Washington because it's clear from reading between the lines of all the stories that many European counties are doing very similar things - they simply don't have the capabilities the NSA does. How do you think the US will react to this? Does it register in Washington that the spying scandal is causing major damage in diplomatic ties with its allies? If hasn't registered yet, it is now. And I think that there will be a reaction of some kind. You've already seen President Obama make several statements about the reevaluation of surveillance policy, about making hard decision about what's really necessary in counter terrorism and what can be scaled back. He made some comments in his speech in the UN general assembly which I think are promising that the White House sees a need for reform and realignment with Europe. But what that looks like specifically remains to be seen. Is it even possible to roll back the clock here? Isn't it a fact that surveillance simply has become - in a way - so easy that intelligence services will always be tempted? I think that we have lots of technologies that would enable us to do things that we should not do. Whether it's digital surveillance or the use of powerful weapons. But that's why we have laws in democratic societies and I am confident that if the White House and the US congress changed the law and restricted the NSA from a practice that permits surveilling the German chancellor for example - then the NSA would stop doing that. The NSA has restrictions on what they do now and I think that these are honored or at least they attempt to honor them. Those screws could be tightened, the programs could be restricted further and the NSA would react appropriately. And I think so would European intelligence agencies. I think the general rule of thumb of any intelligence agency - at least in the West - is that if it's technically possible, legal and financially affordable, then it's happening. And if you're going to make changes, the place to change is the legal side. If you're going to make certain things illegal you have to be very clear where the lines are - otherwise no one is going to believe you. So there is the legal problem and the problem of trust. You not only have to change the laws to reset the lines to where they should be. You have to persuade people that it's real and that your oversight and accountability is meaningful.
US
United_States Billboard_200 Billboard_Hot_100 Recording_Industry_Association_of_America United_States_dollar Nielsen_SoundScan Billboard_charts Hot_Country_Songs Unincorporated_territories_of_the_United_States Billboard_(magazine) Dance_Club_Songs Federal_government_of_the_United_States American_English RIAA_Certification .us Us_(Peter_Gabriel_album)
Germany
Germany Germany_national_football_team Nazi_Germany German_Empire Germany_women's_national_football_team Weimar_Republic German_Football_Association ISU_Junior_Grand_Prix_in_Germany GfK_Entertainment_Charts Germany_national_youth_football_team A1_Team_Germany Germany_national_rugby_union_team Kingdom_of_Germany German_literature Germany_men's_national_ice_hockey_team Same-sex_marriage_in_Germany
NSA
National_Security_Agency Norton_&_Stockton_Ancients_F.C. Attack_(political_party) National_Scrabble_Association National_Security_Advisor_(United_States) FC_NSA_Sofia National_Sports_Academy_"Vasil_Levski" National_Security_Agency_(Bahrain) National_Security_Advisor_(Pakistan) NSA_warrantless_surveillance_(2001–2007) National_Sheriffs'_Association National_Salvation_Government National_Steeplechase_Association New_Schubert_Edition Sangtam_language Spiritual_Assembly
Chancellor
Angela Merkel
Angela_Merkel
EU
European_Union Europe List_of_European_records_in_swimming Eu,_Seine-Maritime E.U._(TV_series) European_Hot_100_Singles .eu European_Top_100_Albums Europium International_Federation_of_the_Phonographic_Industry United_Left_(Galicia) Experience_Unlimited United_Left_of_the_Balearic_Islands Esquerra_de_Menorca United_Extremadura Citizenship_of_the_European_Union
Hillary Clinton
Hillary_Clinton Hillary_Clinton_presidential_campaign,_2016 Hillary_Clinton_presidential_campaign,_2008 Saturday_Night_Live_parodies_of_Hillary_Clinton Hillary_Clinton's_tenure_as_Secretary_of_State Hillary_Clinton_email_controversy Political_positions_of_Hillary_Clinton
adviser
Ben Scott
Ben_Scott Ben_Scott_(policy_advisor)
DW
Drum_Workshop Deutsche_Welle DW-TV Defender_(association_football) Dreamworld_(Australian_theme_park) Data_warehouse Delhi_Wizards D.W._Read DW Discworld
Ben Scott
Ben_Scott Ben_Scott_(policy_advisor)
Berlin
Berlin Humboldt_University_of_Berlin Berlin_(band) German_Open_(WTA) Berlin,_New_Hampshire Berlin_Hauptbahnhof Olympiastadion_(Berlin) Berlin,_Connecticut Berlin_International_Film_Festival Berlin,_Maryland Berlin_(Lou_Reed_album) Berlin,_New_Jersey Berlin,_Massachusetts Berlin,_Wisconsin East_Berlin Battle_of_Berlin
think tank
Stiftung Neue Verantwortung
Stiftung_Neue_Verantwortung
New Responsibility Foundation
Secretary of State
Hillary Clinton
Hillary_Clinton Hillary_Clinton_presidential_campaign,_2016 Hillary_Clinton_presidential_campaign,_2008 Saturday_Night_Live_parodies_of_Hillary_Clinton Hillary_Clinton's_tenure_as_Secretary_of_State Hillary_Clinton_email_controversy Political_positions_of_Hillary_Clinton
Barack Obama
Barack_Obama Presidency_of_Barack_Obama Barack_Obama_presidential_campaign,_2008 Barack_Obama_in_comics Barack_Obama_presidential_campaign,_2012 List_of_federal_judges_appointed_by_Barack_Obama President_Barack_Obama_(painting) Efforts_to_impeach_Barack_Obama
DW
Drum_Workshop Deutsche_Welle DW-TV Defender_(association_football) Dreamworld_(Australian_theme_park) Data_warehouse Delhi_Wizards D.W._Read DW Discworld
US
United_States Billboard_200 Billboard_Hot_100 Recording_Industry_Association_of_America United_States_dollar Nielsen_SoundScan Billboard_charts Hot_Country_Songs Unincorporated_territories_of_the_United_States Billboard_(magazine) Dance_Club_Songs Federal_government_of_the_United_States American_English RIAA_Certification .us Us_(Peter_Gabriel_album)
German
Chancellor
Angela Merkel
Angela_Merkel
Berlin
Berlin Humboldt_University_of_Berlin Berlin_(band) German_Open_(WTA) Berlin,_New_Hampshire Berlin_Hauptbahnhof Olympiastadion_(Berlin) Berlin,_Connecticut Berlin_International_Film_Festival Berlin,_Maryland Berlin_(Lou_Reed_album) Berlin,_New_Jersey Berlin,_Massachusetts Berlin,_Wisconsin East_Berlin Battle_of_Berlin
Merkel
Angela_Merkel Merkel,_Texas Max_Merkel Merkel_(firearms_manufacturer) Alexander_Merkel Merkel_nerve_ending Flying_Merkel Pierre_Merkel Merkel_(surname) Fred_Merkel Ron_Merkel Germany
US
United_States Billboard_200 Billboard_Hot_100 Recording_Industry_Association_of_America United_States_dollar Nielsen_SoundScan Billboard_charts Hot_Country_Songs Unincorporated_territories_of_the_United_States Billboard_(magazine) Dance_Club_Songs Federal_government_of_the_United_States American_English RIAA_Certification .us Us_(Peter_Gabriel_album)
President
Obama
Barack_Obama Obama,_Fukui Presidency_of_Barack_Obama Obama,_Nagasaki Obama_Domain List_of_federal_judges_appointed_by_Barack_Obama Obama_(genus) Barack_Obama_presidential_campaign,_2008 Barack_Obama_Academy_of_International_Studies_6-12 Confirmations_of_Barack_Obama's_Cabinet
Ben Scott
Ben_Scott Ben_Scott_(policy_advisor)
National Security Agency
National_Security_Agency National_Security_Agency_(Bahrain) National_Security_Agency_(Montenegro) National_Security_Agency_(Egypt) National_Security_Agency_(Liberia) State_Security_Department National_Security_Service_(Somalia)
German
US
United_States Billboard_200 Billboard_Hot_100 Recording_Industry_Association_of_America United_States_dollar Nielsen_SoundScan Billboard_charts Hot_Country_Songs Unincorporated_territories_of_the_United_States Billboard_(magazine) Dance_Club_Songs Federal_government_of_the_United_States American_English RIAA_Certification .us Us_(Peter_Gabriel_album)
American
European
Germany
Germany Germany_national_football_team Nazi_Germany German_Empire Germany_women's_national_football_team Weimar_Republic German_Football_Association ISU_Junior_Grand_Prix_in_Germany GfK_Entertainment_Charts Germany_national_youth_football_team A1_Team_Germany Germany_national_rugby_union_team Kingdom_of_Germany German_literature Germany_men's_national_ice_hockey_team Same-sex_marriage_in_Germany
US
United_States Billboard_200 Billboard_Hot_100 Recording_Industry_Association_of_America United_States_dollar Nielsen_SoundScan Billboard_charts Hot_Country_Songs Unincorporated_territories_of_the_United_States Billboard_(magazine) Dance_Club_Songs Federal_government_of_the_United_States American_English RIAA_Certification .us Us_(Peter_Gabriel_album)
Germany
Germany Germany_national_football_team Nazi_Germany German_Empire Germany_women's_national_football_team Weimar_Republic German_Football_Association ISU_Junior_Grand_Prix_in_Germany GfK_Entertainment_Charts Germany_national_youth_football_team A1_Team_Germany Germany_national_rugby_union_team Kingdom_of_Germany German_literature Germany_men's_national_ice_hockey_team Same-sex_marriage_in_Germany
Trans-Atlantic
Trans-Atlantic
(Edward) Snowden
NSA
National_Security_Agency Norton_&_Stockton_Ancients_F.C. Attack_(political_party) National_Scrabble_Association National_Security_Advisor_(United_States) FC_NSA_Sofia National_Sports_Academy_"Vasil_Levski" National_Security_Agency_(Bahrain) National_Security_Advisor_(Pakistan) NSA_warrantless_surveillance_(2001–2007) National_Sheriffs'_Association National_Salvation_Government National_Steeplechase_Association New_Schubert_Edition Sangtam_language Spiritual_Assembly
German
French
Europe
Europe UEFA Europe_(band) UEFA_competitions European_Athletic_Association European_theatre_of_World_War_II European_Union Europe_(dinghy) European_Cricket_Council UEFA_Champions_League Senior_League_World_Series_(Europe–Africa_Region) Big_League_World_Series_(Europe–Africa_Region) Sailing_at_the_2004_Summer_Olympics_–_Europe Neolithic_Europe History_of_Europe Europe_(magazine)
United States
United_States United_States_men's_national_soccer_team United_States_men's_national_ice_hockey_team United_States_women's_national_soccer_team United_States_national_rugby_union_team American_poetry United_States_men's_national_junior_ice_hockey_team United_States_Soccer_Federation Secondary_education_in_the_United_States Recording_Industry_Association_of_America United_States_men's_national_basketball_team United_States_Davis_Cup_team United_States_national_cricket_team Cinema_of_the_United_States Education_in_the_United_States Same-sex_marriage_in_the_United_States
European
EU
European_Union Europe List_of_European_records_in_swimming Eu,_Seine-Maritime E.U._(TV_series) European_Hot_100_Singles .eu European_Top_100_Albums Europium International_Federation_of_the_Phonographic_Industry United_Left_(Galicia) Experience_Unlimited United_Left_of_the_Balearic_Islands Esquerra_de_Menorca United_Extremadura Citizenship_of_the_European_Union
EU
European_Union Europe List_of_European_records_in_swimming Eu,_Seine-Maritime E.U._(TV_series) European_Hot_100_Singles .eu European_Top_100_Albums Europium International_Federation_of_the_Phonographic_Industry United_Left_(Galicia) Experience_Unlimited United_Left_of_the_Balearic_Islands Esquerra_de_Menorca United_Extremadura Citizenship_of_the_European_Union
EU
European_Union Europe List_of_European_records_in_swimming Eu,_Seine-Maritime E.U._(TV_series) European_Hot_100_Singles .eu European_Top_100_Albums Europium International_Federation_of_the_Phonographic_Industry United_Left_(Galicia) Experience_Unlimited United_Left_of_the_Balearic_Islands Esquerra_de_Menorca United_Extremadura Citizenship_of_the_European_Union
US
United_States Billboard_200 Billboard_Hot_100 Recording_Industry_Association_of_America United_States_dollar Nielsen_SoundScan Billboard_charts Hot_Country_Songs Unincorporated_territories_of_the_United_States Billboard_(magazine) Dance_Club_Songs Federal_government_of_the_United_States American_English RIAA_Certification .us Us_(Peter_Gabriel_album)
NATO
NATO NATO_reporting_name NATO_summit Ranks_and_insignia_of_NATO_navies_enlisted NATO_(album) International_Security_Assistance_Force Ranks_and_insignia_of_NATO_armies_enlisted Nato_wood N.A.T.o._(singer) Enlargement_of_NATO .nato 2002_Prague_summit Army_officer_ranks Ukraine–NATO_relations Ranks_and_insignia_of_NATO_navies'_officers United_States_Permanent_Representative_to_NATO
Washington
Washington_(state) Washington,_D.C. Washington_Wizards Washington_Huskies_football Washington_Mystics Washington_County,_New_York University_of_Washington Washington_Huskies_men's_basketball George_Washington Washington_County,_Maine Washington_Capitals Washington_County,_Pennsylvania Washington_Huskies Washington,_Pennsylvania Washington,_Tyne_and_Wear Washington_County,_Oregon
European
NSA
National_Security_Agency Norton_&_Stockton_Ancients_F.C. Attack_(political_party) National_Scrabble_Association National_Security_Advisor_(United_States) FC_NSA_Sofia National_Sports_Academy_"Vasil_Levski" National_Security_Agency_(Bahrain) National_Security_Advisor_(Pakistan) NSA_warrantless_surveillance_(2001–2007) National_Sheriffs'_Association National_Salvation_Government National_Steeplechase_Association New_Schubert_Edition Sangtam_language Spiritual_Assembly
US
United_States Billboard_200 Billboard_Hot_100 Recording_Industry_Association_of_America United_States_dollar Nielsen_SoundScan Billboard_charts Hot_Country_Songs Unincorporated_territories_of_the_United_States Billboard_(magazine) Dance_Club_Songs Federal_government_of_the_United_States American_English RIAA_Certification .us Us_(Peter_Gabriel_album)
Washington
Washington_(state) Washington,_D.C. Washington_Wizards Washington_Huskies_football Washington_Mystics Washington_County,_New_York University_of_Washington Washington_Huskies_men's_basketball George_Washington Washington_County,_Maine Washington_Capitals Washington_County,_Pennsylvania Washington_Huskies Washington,_Pennsylvania Washington,_Tyne_and_Wear Washington_County,_Oregon
President
Obama
Barack_Obama Obama,_Fukui Presidency_of_Barack_Obama Obama,_Nagasaki Obama_Domain List_of_federal_judges_appointed_by_Barack_Obama Obama_(genus) Barack_Obama_presidential_campaign,_2008 Barack_Obama_Academy_of_International_Studies_6-12 Confirmations_of_Barack_Obama's_Cabinet
UN
United_Nations UN_(band) Un_(album) United_Nations_Command U.N._(group) Union_Nationale_(Quebec) National_Unity_(Peru) UN_(album) National_Union_(Spain) Parti_Unité_Nationale United_Nations_Interim_Administration_Mission_in_Kosovo United_Nations_System Peacekeeping United_Nations_Mission_in_Sierra_Leone Headquarters_of_the_United_Nations United_Nations_Security_Council_Resolution_1874
White House
White_House Executive_Office_of_the_President_of_the_United_States White_House_Office White_House_(Moscow) White_House,_Tennessee White_House_(film) White_House,_Virginia White_House_(plantation) White_House,_Bishkek Presidency_of_George_W._Bush Presidency_of_Barack_Obama White_House_station President_of_the_United_States White_House_Press_Secretary Whitehouse,_New_Jersey White_House,_Jamaica
Europe
Europe UEFA Europe_(band) UEFA_competitions European_Athletic_Association European_theatre_of_World_War_II European_Union Europe_(dinghy) European_Cricket_Council UEFA_Champions_League Senior_League_World_Series_(Europe–Africa_Region) Big_League_World_Series_(Europe–Africa_Region) Sailing_at_the_2004_Summer_Olympics_–_Europe Neolithic_Europe History_of_Europe Europe_(magazine)
White House
White_House Executive_Office_of_the_President_of_the_United_States White_House_Office White_House_(Moscow) White_House,_Tennessee White_House_(film) White_House,_Virginia White_House_(plantation) White_House,_Bishkek Presidency_of_George_W._Bush Presidency_of_Barack_Obama White_House_station President_of_the_United_States White_House_Press_Secretary Whitehouse,_New_Jersey White_House,_Jamaica
US
United_States Billboard_200 Billboard_Hot_100 Recording_Industry_Association_of_America United_States_dollar Nielsen_SoundScan Billboard_charts Hot_Country_Songs Unincorporated_territories_of_the_United_States Billboard_(magazine) Dance_Club_Songs Federal_government_of_the_United_States American_English RIAA_Certification .us Us_(Peter_Gabriel_album)
NSA
National_Security_Agency Norton_&_Stockton_Ancients_F.C. Attack_(political_party) National_Scrabble_Association National_Security_Advisor_(United_States) FC_NSA_Sofia National_Sports_Academy_"Vasil_Levski" National_Security_Agency_(Bahrain) National_Security_Advisor_(Pakistan) NSA_warrantless_surveillance_(2001–2007) National_Sheriffs'_Association National_Salvation_Government National_Steeplechase_Association New_Schubert_Edition Sangtam_language Spiritual_Assembly
German
NSA
National_Security_Agency Norton_&_Stockton_Ancients_F.C. Attack_(political_party) National_Scrabble_Association National_Security_Advisor_(United_States) FC_NSA_Sofia National_Sports_Academy_"Vasil_Levski" National_Security_Agency_(Bahrain) National_Security_Advisor_(Pakistan) NSA_warrantless_surveillance_(2001–2007) National_Sheriffs'_Association National_Salvation_Government National_Steeplechase_Association New_Schubert_Edition Sangtam_language Spiritual_Assembly
NSA
National_Security_Agency Norton_&_Stockton_Ancients_F.C. Attack_(political_party) National_Scrabble_Association National_Security_Advisor_(United_States) FC_NSA_Sofia National_Sports_Academy_"Vasil_Levski" National_Security_Agency_(Bahrain) National_Security_Advisor_(Pakistan) NSA_warrantless_surveillance_(2001–2007) National_Sheriffs'_Association National_Salvation_Government National_Steeplechase_Association New_Schubert_Edition Sangtam_language Spiritual_Assembly
NSA
National_Security_Agency Norton_&_Stockton_Ancients_F.C. Attack_(political_party) National_Scrabble_Association National_Security_Advisor_(United_States) FC_NSA_Sofia National_Sports_Academy_"Vasil_Levski" National_Security_Agency_(Bahrain) National_Security_Advisor_(Pakistan) NSA_warrantless_surveillance_(2001–2007) National_Sheriffs'_Association National_Salvation_Government National_Steeplechase_Association New_Schubert_Edition Sangtam_language Spiritual_Assembly
European
West
Western_United_States Western_world West Western_Conference_(WNBA) West_Africa Western_Ukraine West_Province_(Western_Australia) West_(cigarette) West_Germany American_League_West Longitude Scottish_Junior_Football_Association,_West_Region Enoch_West Senior_League_World_Series_(West_Region) Western_European_Summer_Time David_West_(basketball)
United States
United_States
topic::none type::entity type::gpe type::gpe0 type::location
Europe
European_Union
iptc::11000000 topic::politics type::entity type::igo type::organization type::so
Barack Obama
Barack_Obama
gender::male iptc::11000000 topic::politics type::entity type::head_of_state type::person type::politician
National Security Agency
National_Security_Agency
iptc::11000000 slot::keyword topic::politics type::agency type::entity type::governmental_organisation type::organization
Angela Merkel
Angela_Merkel
gender::female iptc::11000000 slot::keyword topic::politics type::entity type::head_of_gov type::person type::politician
Ben Scott
Ben_Scott_(policy_advisor)
gender::male iptc::11000000 slot::head slot::keyword topic::politics type::entity type::person type::politics_per
Hillary Clinton
Hillary_Clinton
gender::female iptc::11000000 slot::keyword topic::politics type::entity type::person type::politician type::politician_national
Trans-Atlantic
meta::todo slot::keyword
New Responsibility Foundation
Stiftung_Neue_Verantwortung
iptc::11000000 topic::politics type::entity type::organization type::policy_institute
Germany
Germany
topic::none type::entity type::gpe type::gpe0 type::location
Chancellor
topic::none type::role type::value
adviser
topic::none type::role type::value
DW
Deutsche_Welle
topic::media type::entity type::media type::organization
Berlin
Berlin
topic::none type::entity type::gpe type::gpe2 type::location
think tank
topic::none type::role type::value
Secretary of State
topic::none type::role type::value
German
topic::none type::gpe0-x type::other
President
topic::none type::role type::value
American
topic::none type::loc-x type::other
European
topic::none type::loc-x type::other
(Edward) Snowden
Edward_Snowden
gender::male iptc::11000000 topic::politics type::activist type::entity type::person
French
topic::none type::gpe0-x type::other
NATO
NATO
iptc::11000000 iptc::16000000 topic::conflict topic::politics type::entity type::igo type::military_alliance type::organization
Washington
Washington,_D.C.
topic::none type::entity type::gpe type::gpe2 type::location
UN
United_Nations
iptc::11000000 topic::politics type::entity type::igo type::organization
White House
White_House
iptc::11000000 topic::politics type::entity type::facility type::location type::politics_facility
West
Western_world
topic::none type::entity type::location type::regio
France