Anger, dismay and cynicism: The Muslim world responds to the new Charlie Hebdo
The latest edition of Charlie Hebdo has sparked heated debate in the Muslim world. The main media outlets have been restrained in their response, but discussions on social media are incensed.
You won't find Muhammad anywhere in the Arab world right now. Not, that is, in caricature - the weeping prophet the satirical French magazine Charlie Hebdo portrayed on its cover one week after the deadly attacks in Paris. The prophet is weeping over the violence perpetrated in the supposed name of Islam. But readers of the major Arab papers can't see him, because not one of those papers has published the cartoon. The majority in Algeria, Egypt, and Saudi Arabia decided to confine their reporting on the new edition to the sidelines - if, that is, they covered it at all. Some newspapers published caricatures of their own today that expressed their positions on the issue. These are considerably at variance. The Tunisian paper Al Fair, for example, offered its readers a drawing of a jihadist lighting a bomb. The bomb is round and depicts a globe. The jihadist is sitting on it - the message is that Islamist terrorists are destroying the world in which they themselves live. The Algerian paper Al Joumhouria published a very different caricature: a drawing of a larger-than-life Jew holding a tiny Muslim doll under a terrified woman's nose. It's strongly reminiscent of the anti-Semitic drawings that circulated in Germany under the Nazis. One week after the attacks, which were perpetrated by men of Algerian origin, this caricature conveys the message that the true enemies of humanity are the Jews. Justified dismay The young, liberal online newspaper Al Arabi al-Jadeed in London, on the other hand, carries extensive coverage of the caricatures. Commentator Azmi Bishara writes that the lines between free speech and hate speech have been blurred - but that this line "is not so thin, and a sound mind can indeed tell the difference." He says "it is time to ask ourselves, can cartoons that insult the prophets of all religions, including the prophet of Islam, truly undermine the stature of these prophets? […] Are such events a worthy cause for millions of people to rise up and damage their future, their plans, their relations with other nations and peoples?" Angry voices Many people writing online say yes to that, with comments on Twitter expressing anger and even cynicism. One user writes that Charlie Hebdo is spitting into Muslims' faces once again. "We will avenge our leader Muhammad for you," writes another user from East Asia. People who don't entirely condemn the attacks have also been writing in to Al Jazeera. One reader asks what it means that Charlie Hebdo wants to "forgive," as indicated in the cartoon. "The attackers are dead, so it's not really a question of forgiveness anymore," she says. Another refers to the limits of freedom: "Islam is a peaceful religion. Making fun of or insulting other people's faith is not freedom of speech - that's hate speech." Others focus on the political background to the attacks. "The principal cause is the weakness of Muslim states, their corrupt, weak and traitorous ruling dynasties," writes one commentator, and adds that it is obvious what should be done about it: "They must be removed by good Muslims." The Egyptian fatwa office The Dar al-Iftaa, the Egyptian fatwa office, had already commented in advance of today's edition of Charlie Hebdo, describing it as "an unjustified provocation to the feelings of 1.5 billion Muslims around the world." As Dar al-Iftaa had it, "Charlie Hebdo's next edition will stir a new wave of hatred in the French and western (Muslim) community in general." It added that "the magazine's actions hinder Muslims' endeavors to achieve coexistence and dialog among civilizations." A week ago Dar al-Iftaa immediately issued a condemnation of the Paris attacks. Now, though, the office has criticized the new drawings. "This is considered a dangerous escalation in the face of human values, liberations, cultural diversity, tolerance and respect to human rights which are very vital to maintain societal peace," it writes: "Furthermore, it deepens the sentiments of hatred and discrimination in the hearts of Muslims and non-Muslims alike."
Muslim
Charlie Hebdo
Charlie_Hebdo Charlie_Hebdo_shooting
Charlie Hebdo
Charlie_Hebdo Charlie_Hebdo_shooting
Muslim
Muhammad
Muhammad Muhammad_in_Islam Muhammad_(name) Muhammad_of_Ghazni Shabazz_Muhammad Muhammad_ibn_Ja'far Muhammad:_The_Messenger_of_God_(film) Muhammad_ibn_Ahmad_al-Shaybani Muhammad_ibn_Marwan Muhammad_(book) Muhammad_(surah) Muhammad_II_ibn_Mahmud Muhammad_ibn_al-Qasim Muhammad_(Bavandid_ruler) Muhammad_ibn_Abu_Bakr Muhammad_of_Negeri_Sembilan
Arab
Arabs Arab_Canadians Arab_citizens_of_Israel Arab_world Arab_Americans Arab_cuisine Arab,_Alabama Palestinians Arabic Arabic_music Arab_Indonesians Arab_culture British_Arabs Arabian_horse Arab_(horse) History_of_Arabs_in_Afghanistan
French
magazine
Charlie Hebdo
Charlie_Hebdo Charlie_Hebdo_shooting
Paris
Paris Paris_Masters Paris_(mythology) University_of_Paris Paris,_Texas Paris,_Ontario Paris,_Tennessee Paris_(rapper) Open_GDF_Suez Paris_FC Paris,_Kentucky Meeting_de_Paris Stade_Roland_Garros Paris_(The_Chainsmokers_song) AccorHotels_Arena Paris,_Illinois
Islam
Islam Islam_in_the_Philippines Islam_in_Australia Islam_in_Indonesia Islam_in_Ethiopia Sunni_Islam Islam_in_Albania Islam_in_Malaysia Islam_in_the_Republic_of_Macedonia Islam_in_Lebanon Islam_in_India Islam_in_China Islam_in_Sri_Lanka Islam_in_the_United_Kingdom Islam_in_the_United_States Islam_in_Norway
Arab
Arabs Arab_Canadians Arab_citizens_of_Israel Arab_world Arab_Americans Arab_cuisine Arab,_Alabama Palestinians Arabic Arabic_music Arab_Indonesians Arab_culture British_Arabs Arabian_horse Arab_(horse) History_of_Arabs_in_Afghanistan
Algeria
Algeria Algeria_national_football_team French_Algeria Algerian_Football_Federation Algerian_War Algeria_national_handball_team Football_in_Algeria Algeria_Davis_Cup_team Algeria_women's_national_football_team Ottoman_Algeria Algeria_women's_national_handball_team Algeria_national_rugby_union_team List_of_Algerian_films Algerian_wine History_of_the_Jews_in_Algeria Algeria_national_basketball_team
Egypt
Egypt Egypt_national_football_team Ancient_Egypt Egypt_(Roman_province) Kingdom_of_Egypt Egypt_Eyalet Egypt_in_the_Middle_Ages Egyptian_Football_Association Ptolemaic_Kingdom Egypt_national_basketball_team Khedivate_of_Egypt History_of_ancient_Egypt Egypt_national_handball_team Egypt_Fed_Cup_team Egypt_women's_national_squash_team Egyptian_revolution_of_2011
Saudi Arabia
Saudi_Arabia Saudi_Arabia_national_football_team Saudi_Arabian_Football_Federation Saudi_Arabia_national_cricket_team Football_in_Saudi_Arabia Armed_forces_of_Saudi_Arabia Saudi_Arabia_national_under-23_football_team Saudi_Arabia_national_under-17_football_team Saudi_Aramco_Residential_Camp_in_Dhahran Energy_in_Saudi_Arabia Saudi_Professional_League Saudi_Arabia_national_under-20_football_team Saudi_Arabia_national_handball_team LGBT_rights_in_Saudi_Arabia Flag_of_Saudi_Arabia Saudi_Arabia_at_the_Olympics
Tunisian
paper
Al Fair
Islamist
Algerian
paper
Al Joumhouria
Al_Joumhouria
Jew
Muslim
anti-Semitic
Germany
Germany Germany_national_football_team Nazi_Germany German_Empire Germany_women's_national_football_team Weimar_Republic German_Football_Association ISU_Junior_Grand_Prix_in_Germany GfK_Entertainment_Charts Germany_national_youth_football_team A1_Team_Germany Germany_national_rugby_union_team Kingdom_of_Germany German_literature Germany_men's_national_ice_hockey_team Same-sex_marriage_in_Germany
Nazis
Nazism Nazi_Party Nazi_Germany Neo-Nazism Nazi_plunder Nazi_architecture Occupation_of_Poland_(1939–1945) Netherlands_in_World_War_II The_Holocaust_in_Poland Religious_aspects_of_Nazism Germans Louis_and_the_Nazis Austria_under_National_Socialism National_Alliance_(United_States) Austrian_National_Socialism Government_of_Nazi_Germany
Algerian
Jews
newspaper
Al Arabi al-Jadeed
London
London London,_Ontario London_GAA London_Cricket_Club Greater_London London_Records London_Stadium London_(European_Parliament_constituency) County_of_London City_of_London University_of_London West_End_theatre London,_Kentucky Bishop_of_London London_(electoral_district) London,_Ohio
Commentator
Azmi Bishara
Azmi_Bishara
Twitter
Twitter Twitter_usage Use_of_Twitter_by_public_figures Censorship_of_Twitter Twitter_diplomacy
Charlie Hebdo
Charlie_Hebdo Charlie_Hebdo_shooting
Muslims
Muslim Islam Muslims_(ethnicity) Islam_in_India Muslims_cricket_team Islam_in_Lebanon Bosniaks Islam_in_China Sri_Lankan_Moors Böszörmény Islam_in_Sri_Lanka Islam_in_the_Philippines Islam_in_Ethiopia Al-Andalus Umayyad_Caliphate Islam_in_Nigeria
leader
Muhammad
Muhammad Muhammad_in_Islam Muhammad_(name) Muhammad_of_Ghazni Shabazz_Muhammad Muhammad_ibn_Ja'far Muhammad:_The_Messenger_of_God_(film) Muhammad_ibn_Ahmad_al-Shaybani Muhammad_ibn_Marwan Muhammad_(book) Muhammad_(surah) Muhammad_II_ibn_Mahmud Muhammad_ibn_al-Qasim Muhammad_(Bavandid_ruler) Muhammad_ibn_Abu_Bakr Muhammad_of_Negeri_Sembilan
East Asia
East_Asia East_Asian_Football_Federation East_Asian_cultural_sphere History_of_East_Asia Music_of_Asia East_Asian_Buddhism East_Asian_cinema East_Asia_(album) East_Asian_cuisine Northern_Asia-Pacific_Division_of_Seventh-day_Adventists Haplogroup_D-M174 Southeast_Asia Bahá'í_Faith_in_Asia East Far_East East_Asian_studies
Al Jazeera
Al_Jazeera Al-Jazeera_Club_(Jordan) Al_Jazeera_English Al-Jazeera_SC_(Syria) Al_Jazeera_SC Al_Jazeera_Media_Network Aljazeera_SC Upper_Mesopotamia Al-Jazira_Province Al_Jazeera_America BeIN_Sports_(Middle_East_TV_network) Aljazeera_Publishing
Charlie Hebdo
Charlie_Hebdo Charlie_Hebdo_shooting
Islam
Islam Islam_in_the_Philippines Islam_in_Australia Islam_in_Indonesia Islam_in_Ethiopia Sunni_Islam Islam_in_Albania Islam_in_Malaysia Islam_in_the_Republic_of_Macedonia Islam_in_Lebanon Islam_in_India Islam_in_China Islam_in_Sri_Lanka Islam_in_the_United_Kingdom Islam_in_the_United_States Islam_in_Norway
Muslim
Muslims
Muslim Islam Muslims_(ethnicity) Islam_in_India Muslims_cricket_team Islam_in_Lebanon Bosniaks Islam_in_China Sri_Lankan_Moors Böszörmény Islam_in_Sri_Lanka Islam_in_the_Philippines Islam_in_Ethiopia Al-Andalus Umayyad_Caliphate Islam_in_Nigeria
Egyptian
Dar al-Iftaa
Egyptian
Charlie Hebdo
Charlie_Hebdo Charlie_Hebdo_shooting
Muslims
Muslim Islam Muslims_(ethnicity) Islam_in_India Muslims_cricket_team Islam_in_Lebanon Bosniaks Islam_in_China Sri_Lankan_Moors Böszörmény Islam_in_Sri_Lanka Islam_in_the_Philippines Islam_in_Ethiopia Al-Andalus Umayyad_Caliphate Islam_in_Nigeria
Dar al-Iftaa
Charlie Hebdo
Charlie_Hebdo Charlie_Hebdo_shooting
French
Muslim
Muslims
Muslim Islam Muslims_(ethnicity) Islam_in_India Muslims_cricket_team Islam_in_Lebanon Bosniaks Islam_in_China Sri_Lankan_Moors Böszörmény Islam_in_Sri_Lanka Islam_in_the_Philippines Islam_in_Ethiopia Al-Andalus Umayyad_Caliphate Islam_in_Nigeria
Dar al-Iftaa
Paris
Paris Paris_Masters Paris_(mythology) University_of_Paris Paris,_Texas Paris,_Ontario Paris,_Tennessee Paris_(rapper) Open_GDF_Suez Paris_FC Paris,_Kentucky Meeting_de_Paris Stade_Roland_Garros Paris_(The_Chainsmokers_song) AccorHotels_Arena Paris,_Illinois
Muslims
Muslim Islam Muslims_(ethnicity) Islam_in_India Muslims_cricket_team Islam_in_Lebanon Bosniaks Islam_in_China Sri_Lankan_Moors Böszörmény Islam_in_Sri_Lanka Islam_in_the_Philippines Islam_in_Ethiopia Al-Andalus Umayyad_Caliphate Islam_in_Nigeria
Muslims
Muslim Islam Muslims_(ethnicity) Islam_in_India Muslims_cricket_team Islam_in_Lebanon Bosniaks Islam_in_China Sri_Lankan_Moors Böszörmény Islam_in_Sri_Lanka Islam_in_the_Philippines Islam_in_Ethiopia Al-Andalus Umayyad_Caliphate Islam_in_Nigeria
Jews
Jews
iptc::12000000 topic::none topic::religion type::other type::religion-x
Muslims
Islam
iptc::12000000 topic::none topic::religion type::entity type::misc type::other type::religion type::religion-x
Charlie Hebdo
Charlie_Hebdo
slot::keyword topic::media type::entity type::media type::organization
Muslim
iptc::12000000 slot::keyword topic::none topic::religion type::other type::religion-x
Muhammad
Muhammad
gender::male iptc::12000000 topic::religion type::deity type::entity type::person
Arab
Arabs
topic::none type::entity type::ethnicity
French
topic::none type::gpe0-x type::other
magazine
topic::none type::role type::value
Paris
Paris
topic::none type::entity type::gpe type::gpe2 type::location
Algeria
Algeria
topic::none type::entity type::gpe type::gpe0 type::location
Egypt
Egypt
topic::none type::entity type::gpe type::gpe0 type::location
Saudi Arabia
Saudi_Arabia
topic::none type::entity type::gpe type::gpe0 type::location
Tunisian
topic::none type::gpe0-x type::other
paper
topic::none type::role type::value
Al Fair
topic::media type::entity type::media type::organization
Islamist
iptc::12000000 topic::none topic::religion type::other type::religion-x
Algerian
topic::none type::gpe0-x type::other
Al Joumhouria
Al_Joumhouria
topic::media type::entity type::media type::organization
anti-Semitic
Antisemitism
meta::todo
Germany
Germany
topic::none type::entity type::gpe type::gpe0 type::location
Nazis
Nazism
iptc::11000000 topic::politics type::entity type::organization type::party
newspaper
topic::none type::role type::value
Al Arabi al-Jadeed
The_New_Arab
topic::media type::entity type::media type::organization
London
London
topic::none type::entity type::gpe type::gpe2 type::location
Commentator
topic::none type::role type::value
Azmi Bishara
Azmi_Bishara
gender::male topic::media type::entity type::journalist type::person
Twitter
Twitter
topic::media type::entity type::media type::organization
leader
topic::none type::role type::value
East Asia
East_Asia
topic::none type::entity type::location type::regio
Al Jazeera
Al_Jazeera
topic::media type::entity type::media type::organization
Egyptian
topic::none type::gpe0-x type::other
Dar al-Iftaa
Dar_al-Ifta_al-Misriyyah
iptc::11000000 topic::politics type::agency type::entity type::governmental_organisation type::organization
Islamism
Tunisia
France
United_Kingdom