Online betting firms say they discourage soccer match-fixing
As football authorities try to fight the worst scandal ever to hit the sport, gaming operators are coming under scrutiny. But as Deutsche Welle discovered, they could help prevent games from being thrown.
Prosecutors in the German city of Bochum certainly have enough to investigate - 200 manipulated matches in nine countries, the Champions League and possibly World Cup qualifiers. Players, referees and even hotel chefs are thought to be involved. The scandal is being called the biggest ever in football, and it comes just four years after German football was rocked by revelations that referee Robert Hoyzer had helped fix professional matches. Against this backdrop, some representatives of state gaming operators have criticized the dramatic growth of the online gambling industry, blaming it for persistent corruption in the sport. Not surprisingly, Internet betting firms disagree with that view. After the Hoyzer scandal, leading gaming operators banded together to form a watchdog, the European Sports Security Association, or ESSA. Industry representatives say the measures taken helped prevent abuses. When the German authorities started to investigate the Hoyzer scandal in 2005, they went to the largest operator at the time, bwin, and asked them how much money they lost," ESSA Secretary General Khalid Ali told Deutsche Welle. "Actually, bwin didn't lose anything. And the reason was that they were online so everything was fully traceable," he said, adding that the strict security procedures in place prevented people from coming online and placing large amounts of money on games - in particular on minor games in lower divisions. A spokesman for the large online betting platform Interwetten reaffirmed that assessment. "We have suffered in the past due to manipulated results, but we haven't been hurt at all by the current scandal," Interwetten Sponsoring and Public Relations Manager Michael Summer said. "That's because we have a risk management system that can block attempts at cheating at an early stages." Both Ali and Summer point out that online bookmakers are among those with the most to lose from match-fixing and, conversely, the biggest interest in uncovering instances of cheating. So can football's governing bodies and law-enforcement authorities actually learn from the Internet bookies? Transparency through technology For some people, online gambling is a marriage of something inherently dubious with something inherently seedy, but industry representatives say that impression is wrong. Both ESSA and individual Internet bookmakers monitor the flow of bets. If unusual amounts of money are wagered on a given result, the odds are immediately lowered. In extreme cases, bets are cancelled and football authorities notified about the irregularities. Computer technology increases the transparency. "All of our customers are identifiable and can't get away with using pseudonyms and false identities more than once or twice," Summer said. "That makes Internet gaming operators far more secure than traditional betting shops." Online bookmakers are particularly cautious with games in obscure leagues and lower divisions, where most, if not all, of the current match fixing seems to have taken place. "People think you can just go online and start betting a lot of money," Ali said. "That's not the case. It might be if you wanted to bet on the Champions League, the Premier League or the Bundesliga first division, but if you go down the leagues, the amount of money you can bet is very limited. In some cases you'd be lucky to be able to put even 50 euros on a match." The same, Ali says, is true of so-called provisional bets - for instance, who will pick up a game's first foul or corner kick. The industry asserts that the importance of such wagers, much criticized of late, has been blown out of proportion. "Provisional or in-play wagers aren't part of the problem at all," Summer said. "These are usually bets on 50-50 outcomes with very low odds and very low limits on the amounts that can be wagered." So if match fixers aren't making their ill-gotten gains from Internet bookmakers, how is the money being earned? The real bad guys "One of the first questions I'd be asking is: Where exactly have these bets been placed?" Ali said. "Once UEFA had released the names of the teams involved in the Champions League and Europe League games, we went to our members and did a retroactive search on this. And none of our members found anything suspicious. That's not to say the matches weren't fixed, but it shows that the criminals who were behind this are not putting their bets with the responsible online operators." Instead, say industry representatives, the trail leads to Asia and Eastern Europe, where gambling is usually illegal and controlled by the local mafia. That assertion is backed up by research done by British journalist Declan Hill, whose 2008 book "The Fix" predicted that the football world was on the verge of a major scandal. "In Asia, the gambling market is enormous - bigger than Las Vegas and the European bookmakers combined," Hill told The New York Times in a recent interview. "It's huge and most of it is illegal. It's easier to hide a fraud inside a covert, criminal industry." Online gaming operators do say more attention needs to be paid to betting exchanges, in which individual gamblers conclude bets with one another. And they say more effective use needs to be made of the information they provide to law-enforcement authorities and football governing bodies. "Abuses need to be pursued more vigorously," Summer said. "For example, after the Hoyzer affair, we passed on data we had collected to the German Football League, the DFL. But for whatever reason, some of the people behind that match-fixing scandal are the same ones involved in the latest affair. There was a lack of follow-up." Most observers are confident that investigators in Bochum are doing a good job trying to shed light on the current scandal. But improved cooperation between law enforcers, football organizations and legitimate bookmakers would help them in their attempt to eradicate match-fixing. Author: Jefferson Chase Editor: Kyle James
Deutsche Welle
Deutsche_Welle Deutsche_Welle_GmbH DW-TV
German
Bochum
Bochum VfL_Bochum Bochum_Hauptbahnhof Ruhr_University_Bochum Senwabarwana Ruhrstadion Schauspielhaus_Bochum Bochum-Westenfeld
Champions League
UEFA_Champions_League UEFA_Women's_Champions_League 2012–13_UEFA_Champions_League 2013–14_UEFA_Champions_League 2009–10_UEFA_Champions_League 2014–15_UEFA_Champions_League 2010–11_UEFA_Champions_League Women's_EHF_Champions_League 2011–12_UEFA_Champions_League 2008–09_UEFA_Champions_League 2015–16_UEFA_Champions_League 2016–17_UEFA_Champions_League 2006–07_UEFA_Champions_League 2017–18_UEFA_Champions_League 2007–08_UEFA_Champions_League Basketball_Champions_League
World Cup
FIFA_World_Cup World_Cup_(men's_golf) FIS_Alpine_Ski_World_Cup FIS_Ski_Jumping_World_Cup Biathlon_World_Cup Rugby_League_World_Cup FIS_Freestyle_Ski_World_Cup ISU_Speed_Skating_World_Cup 2006_IAAF_World_Cup Cricket_World_Cup FIS_Cross-Country_World_Cup 1989_IAAF_World_Cup 2006_FIFA_World_Cup 2010_FIFA_World_Cup 2017–18_ISU_Speed_Skating_World_Cup Rugby_World_Cup
German
referee
Robert Hoyzer
Bundesliga_scandal_(2005)
Internet
Internet Internet_radio Streaming_television Internet_service_provider Internet_access World_Wide_Web Cable_Internet_access Internet_protocol_suite Internet_culture Internet_Party_(New_Zealand) Internet_pornography Internet_art Dot-com_company Top_Internet_Albums Webcomic Online_banking
Hoyzer
European Sports Security Association
ESSA
Essa,_Ontario Environmental_Science_Services_Administration Yungun Muhammad_Essa European_Social_Simulation_Association
German
Hoyzer
2005
bwin
Bwin Bwin.Party_Digital_Entertainment GVC_Holdings
ESSA
Essa,_Ontario Environmental_Science_Services_Administration Yungun Muhammad_Essa European_Social_Simulation_Association
Secretary General
Khalid Ali
Khalid_Ali
Deutsche Welle
Deutsche_Welle Deutsche_Welle_GmbH DW-TV
bwin
Bwin Bwin.Party_Digital_Entertainment GVC_Holdings
online betting platform
Interwetten
Interwetten Interwetten_Racing
Interwetten
Interwetten Interwetten_Racing
Sponsoring and Public Relations Manager
Michael Summer
Ali
Ali Ali_(actor) Ali_(film) Ali_(South_Korean_singer) Aliʻi Ali_(American_rapper) Ali_(name) Alianza_Lima Muhammad_Ali Alianza_F.C. Alianza_F.C._(Panama) Ali_of_Hejaz Ali_Hewson ALi_Corporation Alì Onela
Summer
Summer Summer_(Calvin_Harris_song) Summer_Olympic_Games Transfer_window Summer_Paralympic_Games Summer_Hoyland Summer_(2008_film) Summer_solstice Summer_Swann Summer_(War_song) The_Four_Seasons_(ballet) Summer_XO Leto_(film) Summer_Roberts Summer_(Mogwai_composition) Summer_(Jon_Foreman_EP)
ESSA
Essa,_Ontario Environmental_Science_Services_Administration Yungun Muhammad_Essa European_Social_Simulation_Association
Internet
Internet Internet_radio Streaming_television Internet_service_provider Internet_access World_Wide_Web Cable_Internet_access Internet_protocol_suite Internet_culture Internet_Party_(New_Zealand) Internet_pornography Internet_art Dot-com_company Top_Internet_Albums Webcomic Online_banking
Summer
Summer Summer_(Calvin_Harris_song) Summer_Olympic_Games Transfer_window Summer_Paralympic_Games Summer_Hoyland Summer_(2008_film) Summer_solstice Summer_Swann Summer_(War_song) The_Four_Seasons_(ballet) Summer_XO Leto_(film) Summer_Roberts Summer_(Mogwai_composition) Summer_(Jon_Foreman_EP)
Internet
Internet Internet_radio Streaming_television Internet_service_provider Internet_access World_Wide_Web Cable_Internet_access Internet_protocol_suite Internet_culture Internet_Party_(New_Zealand) Internet_pornography Internet_art Dot-com_company Top_Internet_Albums Webcomic Online_banking
Ali
Ali Ali_(actor) Ali_(film) Ali_(South_Korean_singer) Aliʻi Ali_(American_rapper) Ali_(name) Alianza_Lima Muhammad_Ali Alianza_F.C. Alianza_F.C._(Panama) Ali_of_Hejaz Ali_Hewson ALi_Corporation Alì Onela
Champions League
UEFA_Champions_League UEFA_Women's_Champions_League 2012–13_UEFA_Champions_League 2013–14_UEFA_Champions_League 2009–10_UEFA_Champions_League 2014–15_UEFA_Champions_League 2010–11_UEFA_Champions_League Women's_EHF_Champions_League 2011–12_UEFA_Champions_League 2008–09_UEFA_Champions_League 2015–16_UEFA_Champions_League 2016–17_UEFA_Champions_League 2006–07_UEFA_Champions_League 2017–18_UEFA_Champions_League 2007–08_UEFA_Champions_League Basketball_Champions_League
Premier League
Premier_League Scottish_Premier_League Premier_League_(speedway) Russian_Premier_League Azerbaijan_Premier_League Ukrainian_Premier_League 2011–12_Premier_League Kenyan_Premier_League 2012–13_Premier_League 2013–14_Premier_League Premier_League_of_Bosnia_and_Herzegovina Israeli_Premier_League 2008–09_Premier_League 2009–10_Premier_League 2014–15_Premier_League Kazakhstan_Premier_League
Bundesliga
Bundesliga Frauen-Bundesliga Basketball_Bundesliga Austrian_Football_Bundesliga 2016–17_Bundesliga 2013–14_Bundesliga Handball-Bundesliga 2007–08_Bundesliga Bundesliga_(baseball) 2012–13_Bundesliga 2014–15_Bundesliga 2011–12_Bundesliga Handball-Bundesliga_(women) 2008–09_Bundesliga 2009–10_Bundesliga 2015–16_Bundesliga
50 euros
Ali
Ali Ali_(actor) Ali_(film) Ali_(South_Korean_singer) Aliʻi Ali_(American_rapper) Ali_(name) Alianza_Lima Muhammad_Ali Alianza_F.C. Alianza_F.C._(Panama) Ali_of_Hejaz Ali_Hewson ALi_Corporation Alì Onela
Summer
Summer Summer_(Calvin_Harris_song) Summer_Olympic_Games Transfer_window Summer_Paralympic_Games Summer_Hoyland Summer_(2008_film) Summer_solstice Summer_Swann Summer_(War_song) The_Four_Seasons_(ballet) Summer_XO Leto_(film) Summer_Roberts Summer_(Mogwai_composition) Summer_(Jon_Foreman_EP)
Internet
Internet Internet_radio Streaming_television Internet_service_provider Internet_access World_Wide_Web Cable_Internet_access Internet_protocol_suite Internet_culture Internet_Party_(New_Zealand) Internet_pornography Internet_art Dot-com_company Top_Internet_Albums Webcomic Online_banking
Ali
Ali Ali_(actor) Ali_(film) Ali_(South_Korean_singer) Aliʻi Ali_(American_rapper) Ali_(name) Alianza_Lima Muhammad_Ali Alianza_F.C. Alianza_F.C._(Panama) Ali_of_Hejaz Ali_Hewson ALi_Corporation Alì Onela
UEFA
UEFA UEFA_Europa_League 2019_FIFA_Women's_World_Cup_qualification_(UEFA) UEFA_Women's_Champions_League UEFA_Champions_League 2010_FIFA_World_Cup_qualification_(UEFA) UEFA_coefficient UEFA_Euro_1996 1962_FIFA_World_Cup_qualification_(UEFA) 2011–12_UEFA_Europa_League 2005–06_UEFA_Cup 2018_FIFA_World_Cup_qualification_(UEFA) 2007–08_UEFA_Cup 2008–09_UEFA_Cup 2014_FIFA_World_Cup_qualification_(UEFA) 2006_FIFA_World_Cup_qualification_(UEFA)
Champions League
UEFA_Champions_League UEFA_Women's_Champions_League 2012–13_UEFA_Champions_League 2013–14_UEFA_Champions_League 2009–10_UEFA_Champions_League 2014–15_UEFA_Champions_League 2010–11_UEFA_Champions_League Women's_EHF_Champions_League 2011–12_UEFA_Champions_League 2008–09_UEFA_Champions_League 2015–16_UEFA_Champions_League 2016–17_UEFA_Champions_League 2006–07_UEFA_Champions_League 2017–18_UEFA_Champions_League 2007–08_UEFA_Champions_League Basketball_Champions_League
Europe League
UEFA_Europa_League 2004–05_FIBA_Europe_League 2003–04_FIBA_Europe_League Europe_Cup_(badminton) NFL_Europe FIBA_EuroChallenge 2012–13_UEFA_Europa_League 2011–12_UEFA_Europa_League
Asia
Asia Asian_Football_Confederation Asia_(band) Asia_(Roman_province) AFC_Champions_League United_Nations_geoscheme_for_Asia Asian_Cricket_Council Asian_Athletics_Association Asia_(Asia_album) Languages_of_Asia Asia_Rugby Anatolia Asia_(mythology) .asia Asian_Squash_Federation Kawaguchi,_Saitama
Eastern Europe
Eastern_Europe Charouz_Racing_System Eastern_Bloc Novocherkassk_culture Eastern_European_Group Red_Bull_BC_One_Eastern_European_Finals Eastern_European_cuisine Category:Eastern_European_music History_of_Europe List_of_World_Heritage_sites_in_Eastern_Europe Ashkenazi_Jews Eastern_Front_(World_War_II) Movies_24 The_Rough_Guide_to_the_Music_of_Eastern_Europe Human_trafficking_in_Europe Ochipok
British
journalist
Declan Hill
Declan_Hill
2008
book
The Fix
The_Fix_(musical) The_Fix_(album) The_Fix_(Heroes) The_Fix_(1997_film) The_Fix_(2019_TV_series) The_Fix_(song) The_Fix_(band) The_Fix_(2008_TV_series) Chris_Cillizza The_Fix_(House) Jordan_Knight Nine.com.au The_Fix_(Person_of_Interest) American_Broadcasting_Company
Asia
Asia Asian_Football_Confederation Asia_(band) Asia_(Roman_province) AFC_Champions_League United_Nations_geoscheme_for_Asia Asian_Cricket_Council Asian_Athletics_Association Asia_(Asia_album) Languages_of_Asia Asia_Rugby Anatolia Asia_(mythology) .asia Asian_Squash_Federation Kawaguchi,_Saitama
Las Vegas
Las_Vegas Las_Vegas_Valley Las_Vegas_(TV_series) Las_Vegas_Strip Las_Vegas,_New_Mexico Las_Vegas_Motor_Speedway Las_Vegas_Wranglers Alan_King_Tennis_Classic McCarran_International_Airport 2018_Las_Vegas_Aces_season Las_Vegas_51s Las_Vegas_(Modern_Family) Paradise,_Nevada MGM_Grand_Garden_Arena Thomas_&_Mack_Center Las_Vegas_Locomotives
European
Hill
Hill Hill_County,_Texas Rich_Hill_(pitcher) Hill_County,_Montana George_Hill_(basketball) Embassy_Hill Gordon_Hill_(footballer) Hill,_New_Hampshire Shawn_Hill Clint_Hill_(footballer) Ken_Hill_(baseball) Jordan_Hill_(basketball) Hill_Zaini Jimmy_Hill_(Scottish_footballer) Jimmy_Hill_(footballer,_born_1935) Danny_Hill_(rugby_league)
The New York Times
The_New_York_Times The_New_York_Times_Best_Seller_list List_of_The_New_York_Times_Manga_Best_Sellers The_New_York_Times_Magazine The_New_York_Times_International_Edition The_New_York_Times_Company Newspaper The_New_York_Times_crossword_puzzle Nytimes.com
Summer
Summer Summer_(Calvin_Harris_song) Summer_Olympic_Games Transfer_window Summer_Paralympic_Games Summer_Hoyland Summer_(2008_film) Summer_solstice Summer_Swann Summer_(War_song) The_Four_Seasons_(ballet) Summer_XO Leto_(film) Summer_Roberts Summer_(Mogwai_composition) Summer_(Jon_Foreman_EP)
Hoyzer
German Football League
German_Football_League Deutsche_Fußball_Liga German_football_league_system Bundesliga
DFL
Minnesota_Democratic–Farmer–Labor_Party Deutsche_Fußball_Liga Double_Flower_FA Cosworth_DFL Cosworth_DFV Cinelli–Down_Under DFL_(disambiguation) Dead_Fucking_Last
Bochum
Bochum VfL_Bochum Bochum_Hauptbahnhof Ruhr_University_Bochum Senwabarwana Ruhrstadion Schauspielhaus_Bochum Bochum-Westenfeld
Author: Jefferson Chase Editor: Kyle James
European Sports Security Association
wikidata:Q3734921
iptc::15000000 slot::keyword sport::unknown topic::sport type::entity type::organization type::sport_org
Robert Hoyzer
wikidata:Q84318
gender::male iptc::15000000 slot::keyword topic::sport type::entity type::person type::sport_referee
UEFA
UEFA
iptc::15000000 slot::keyword sport::20001065 topic::sport type::entity type::organization type::sport_org
Khalid Ali
Khalid_Ali
gender::male iptc::15000000 topic::sport type::entity type::person type::sport_head
Michael Summer
gender::male iptc::20000170 topic::business type::entity type::manager type::person
Declan Hill
Declan_Hill
gender::male iptc::01000000 iptc::20000013 topic::culture topic::media type::artist type::entity type::journalist type::person type::writer
German Football League
German_Football_League
iptc::15000000 sport::20001065 topic::sport type::entity type::organization type::sport_org
Deutsche Welle
Deutsche_Welle
topic::media type::entity type::media type::organization
German
topic::none type::gpe0-x type::other
Bochum
Bochum
topic::none type::entity type::gpe type::gpe2 type::location
Champions League
UEFA_Champions_League
iptc::15000000 sport::20001065 sport_event::20001110 topic::sport type::competition type::entity type::event type::sport_competition
World Cup
FIFA_World_Cup
iptc::15000000 sport::20001065 sport_event::20001122 topic::sport type::competition type::entity type::event type::sport_competition
referee
topic::none type::role type::value
Internet
Internet
iptc::13000000 topic::science type::entity type::misc type::technology
2005
topic::none type::time type::value
bwin
Bwin
iptc::20000170 sector::20000332 topic::business type::company type::entity type::organization
Secretary General
topic::none type::role type::value
online betting platform
topic::none type::role type::value
Interwetten
Interwetten
iptc::20000170 sector::20000332 topic::business type::company type::entity type::organization
Sponsoring and Public Relations Manager
topic::none type::role type::value
Premier League
Premier_League
iptc::15000000 sport::20001065 sport_event::20001115 topic::sport type::competition type::entity type::event type::sport_competition
Bundesliga
Bundesliga
iptc::15000000 sport::20001065 sport_event::20001115 topic::sport type::competition type::entity type::event type::sport_competition
50 euros
topic::none type::money type::value
Europe League
UEFA_Europa_League
iptc::15000000 sport::20001065 sport_event::20001110 topic::sport type::competition type::entity type::event type::sport_competition
Asia
Asia
topic::none type::entity type::location type::regio
Eastern Europe
Eastern_Europe
topic::none type::entity type::location type::regio
British
topic::none type::gpe0-x type::other
journalist
topic::none type::role type::value
2008
topic::none type::time type::value
book
topic::none type::role type::value
The Fix
iptc::01000000 iptc::20000013 topic::culture type::book_title type::entity type::misc type::work_of_art
Las Vegas
Las_Vegas
topic::none type::entity type::gpe type::gpe2 type::location
European
topic::none type::loc-x type::other
The New York Times
The_New_York_Times
topic::media type::entity type::media type::organization
Author: Jefferson Chase Editor: Kyle James
topic::none type::footer type::other
Germany
United_Kingdom
United_States