In Rwanda, stability trumps democracy as nation goes to polls
Rwandans voted Monday in presidential elections, but the outcome is already all but certain. Critics of the government say the country may be stable but has moved far away from being a real democracy.
Rwandans went to the ballot box on Monday to vote for a new president, although no one was biting their nails over the outcome - the country's sitting president, Paul Kagame, was expected to win with some 90 percent of the vote. Critics say despite its democratic appearance, the election represents just another seven-year extension of Kagame's iron-fisted rule during which Rwanda's economy has flourished, but any political opposition has been ruthlessly suppressed, turning the East African nation into what amounts to a one-party state. "After the genocide there was the appearance to a certain extent of a liberal system, but for many years one can clearly see that it's a de facto one-party state," Denis Tull, an Africa expert at the German Institute for International and Security Affairs, told Deutsche Welle. "There are a few political parties allowed, but those represented in parliament can't be considered a real opposition," he said. Monday's vote is the second presidential election since the country was rocked with genocidal violence in 1994 that killed some 800,000. While the country has not seen a repeat of that horror, this election run-up has been marked by a spate of arrests, mysterious killings and restrictions on the free-speech rights of critical opposition figures that could well affect the nation's long-term stability, and reopen the wounds left over from the genocide. Growth and stability Kagame's supporters, including many in the West, can point to a string of accomplishments during his 16 years at the top - 10 as president - beginning in those dark days in 1994, when he helped end the wave of killing that had wracked the country. After the genocide, the country was in ruins, today Rwanda is the safest, cleanest country in Africa, with no slums and almost no begging or street crime. Its economy is expected to grow 6 percent this year and tax revenues to increase by 12 percent. Kagame has positioned himself as a foe of corruption which has attracted donors and private investors, including big names like Starbucks and the Gulf investment firm Dubai World. Berlin-based corruption watchdog Transparency International ranks Rwanda as the least corrupt country in East Africa. The World Bank puts the country among the top five most attractive African nations to do business. Kagame's popularity with foreign donors has meant the country's food stocks are swelling, the Chinese have built a basic road network and South Korea is laying a fiber-optic system across the country. His ruling Rwandan Patriotic Front party has overseen a trebling of household incomes and today citizens have access to universal health insurance and the country's parliament has a higher percentage of female members than anywhere else in the world - 56 percent. "I will continue to work as hard as I can till the day we can speak of a Rwanda that has achieved the kind of prosperity that leaves no one behind and everyone proud of who they are," Kagame wrote in a letter to supporters posted on his website Friday. The other side of the coin But there is a dark side to Kagame's rule, critics say, charging that all the stability has came at a high price - human rights. Over the last few months, a string of attacks on Rwandans with whom the president has fallen out has raised eyebrows and suspicions. Opposition politicians and independent journalists have been harassed, arrested, or worse. Police have arrested two aspiring presidential candidates and opposition supporters have been detained for holding an illegal rally. Victoire Ingabire, a Hutu politician who had hoped to stand against Kagame, must face charges of "denying the genocide" while in exile. General Faustin Kayumba Nyamwasa, a critic Kagame, fled his homeland in February and was shot in the stomach in June in South Africa. The deputy editor of a critical newspaper was recently shot and killed outside his home in the capital Kigali. Andre Kagwa Rwisereka, the deputy leader of the opposition Democratic Green Party of Rwanda, was found nearly decapitated in the south of the country. "We have stability here and you can see economic improvement. But we don't think it's sustainable, because we say stability and democracy must go hand and hand," Frank Habineza, president of Rwanda's Green Party, told Deutsche Welle by telephone from Kigali. He said he himself was threatened by unnamed men in February who he suspects of being government security operatives. "We know Kagame's party is going to win this election, because the president is very prepared and he has no competition at all," he added. "This election is an election where there is no opposition." Kagame won a 2003 presidential election with 95 percent of the vote. This time around, he faces three opponents who backed him seven years ago. Western support Despite the recent events, all of which the government denies having any role in, Rwanda still enjoys a good deal of enthusiastic Western support since the country is seen as something of a model for the continent. Kagame's list of advisors includes Tony Blair, Bill Clinton, high-profile US evangelist Rick Warren and the CEOs of Google and Starbucks. It also helps that Kagame, 52, is an elegant, charismatic figure, who speaks well and knows how to court international players. Over the past few weeks, Kagame has responded to allegations about democratic deficits by saying democracy in Rwanda takes time to establish, stability is the priority, especially given the convulsion of 1994. "Your model of democracy, why should it be suitable for me," he told Britain's Guardian newspaper. Foreign governments and advisors have been mostly quiet about the rights situation, despite the fact that Rwanda is ranked 183 out of 195 countries for freedom of the press. According to analyst Tull, that is partly due to the fact that Kagame, the rebel army leader who stopped the genocide, has successfully played on Western guilt about its non-intervention during the killing. "The government is saying, we have other goals, like stability and development, and we won't be told by others how to lead our country, especially by an international community which didn't intervene to stop the genocide," he said. "That is the message and it's getting across fairly well because we haven't seen that much criticism from outside." Author: Kyle James Editor: Rob Mudge
Rwanda
Rwanda Rwanda_national_football_team Kingdom_of_Rwanda Rwandese_Association_Football_Federation Rwandan_genocide International_Criminal_Tribunal_for_Rwanda United_Nations_Assistance_Mission_for_Rwanda Rwanda_national_basketball_team Rwandan_Defence_Forces Province_of_the_Anglican_Church_of_Rwanda Elections_in_Rwanda Rwanda_national_cricket_team LGBT_rights_in_Rwanda Football_in_Rwanda Rwanda_national_rugby_union_team Water_supply_and_sanitation_in_Rwanda
Rwandans
Monday
Rwandans
Monday
president
Paul Kagame
Paul_Kagame
Kagame
Paul_Kagame
Rwanda
Rwanda Rwanda_national_football_team Kingdom_of_Rwanda Rwandese_Association_Football_Federation Rwandan_genocide International_Criminal_Tribunal_for_Rwanda United_Nations_Assistance_Mission_for_Rwanda Rwanda_national_basketball_team Rwandan_Defence_Forces Province_of_the_Anglican_Church_of_Rwanda Elections_in_Rwanda Rwanda_national_cricket_team LGBT_rights_in_Rwanda Football_in_Rwanda Rwanda_national_rugby_union_team Water_supply_and_sanitation_in_Rwanda
East African
Denis Tull
Africa
Africa Africa_(Roman_province) Africa_(Toto_song) Poverty_in_Africa Confederation_of_African_Football Confederation_of_African_Athletics African_Cricket_Association Africa_(TV_series) United_Nations_geoscheme_for_Africa Africa_(Petrarch) Africa_(Karl_Wolf_song) Praetorian_prefecture_of_Africa Languages_of_Africa Squash_Federation_of_Africa Music_of_Africa Exarchate_of_Africa
German Institute for International and Security Affairs
German_Institute_for_International_and_Security_Affairs
Deutsche Welle
Deutsche_Welle Deutsche_Welle_GmbH DW-TV
Monday
1994
Kagame
Paul_Kagame
West
Western_United_States Western_world West Western_Conference_(WNBA) West_Africa Western_Ukraine West_Province_(Western_Australia) West_(cigarette) West_Germany American_League_West Longitude Scottish_Junior_Football_Association,_West_Region Enoch_West Senior_League_World_Series_(West_Region) Western_European_Summer_Time David_West_(basketball)
1994
Rwanda
Rwanda Rwanda_national_football_team Kingdom_of_Rwanda Rwandese_Association_Football_Federation Rwandan_genocide International_Criminal_Tribunal_for_Rwanda United_Nations_Assistance_Mission_for_Rwanda Rwanda_national_basketball_team Rwandan_Defence_Forces Province_of_the_Anglican_Church_of_Rwanda Elections_in_Rwanda Rwanda_national_cricket_team LGBT_rights_in_Rwanda Football_in_Rwanda Rwanda_national_rugby_union_team Water_supply_and_sanitation_in_Rwanda
Africa
Africa Africa_(Roman_province) Africa_(Toto_song) Poverty_in_Africa Confederation_of_African_Football Confederation_of_African_Athletics African_Cricket_Association Africa_(TV_series) United_Nations_geoscheme_for_Africa Africa_(Petrarch) Africa_(Karl_Wolf_song) Praetorian_prefecture_of_Africa Languages_of_Africa Squash_Federation_of_Africa Music_of_Africa Exarchate_of_Africa
Kagame
Paul_Kagame
Starbucks
Starbucks Starbuck_(whaling_family) G.F._Milnes_&_Co. Starbucks_(song) Starbucks_(mixtape) Starbucks_Israel Hear_Music Kara_Thrace
Gulf
Gulf_Oil Gulf_of_Mexico Persian_Gulf Gulf_County,_Florida National_Register_of_Historic_Places_listings_in_Gulf_County,_Florida Gulf_Province Arab_states_of_the_Persian_Gulf Headlands_and_bays Bay Gulf_Coast_of_the_United_States Gulf Gulf_(novella) Gulf_Arabic Gulf_War Gulf,_North_Carolina Gulf_languages
investment firm
Dubai World
Dubai_World The_World_(archipelago)
Berlin
Berlin Humboldt_University_of_Berlin Berlin_(band) German_Open_(WTA) Berlin,_New_Hampshire Berlin_Hauptbahnhof Olympiastadion_(Berlin) Berlin,_Connecticut Berlin_International_Film_Festival Berlin,_Maryland Berlin_(Lou_Reed_album) Berlin,_New_Jersey Berlin,_Massachusetts Berlin,_Wisconsin East_Berlin Battle_of_Berlin
corruption watchdog
Transparency International
Transparency_International
Rwanda
Rwanda Rwanda_national_football_team Kingdom_of_Rwanda Rwandese_Association_Football_Federation Rwandan_genocide International_Criminal_Tribunal_for_Rwanda United_Nations_Assistance_Mission_for_Rwanda Rwanda_national_basketball_team Rwandan_Defence_Forces Province_of_the_Anglican_Church_of_Rwanda Elections_in_Rwanda Rwanda_national_cricket_team LGBT_rights_in_Rwanda Football_in_Rwanda Rwanda_national_rugby_union_team Water_supply_and_sanitation_in_Rwanda
East Africa
East_Africa East_Africa_cricket_team East_Africa_rugby_union_team East_African_Campaign_(World_War_I) East_African_Campaign_(World_War_II) German_East_Africa East_Africa_Protectorate Italian_East_Africa Africa History_of_East_Africa East_African_Community CECAFA Northeast_Bantu_languages East_African_mangroves East_African_Railways_and_Harbours_Corporation Kenya
World Bank
World_Bank World_Bank_Group International_Bank_for_Reconstruction_and_Development Office_of_the_World_Bank,_London Bank_for_International_Settlements
African
Kagame
Paul_Kagame
Chinese
South Korea
South_Korea South_Korea_national_football_team South_Korea_national_baseball_team South_Korea_women's_national_football_team Korea_Football_Association Cinema_of_South_Korea South_Korea_national_under-23_football_team South_Korea_national_under-20_football_team List_of_years_in_South_Korea South_Korea_national_basketball_team South_Korea_Fed_Cup_team South_Korea_national_rugby_union_team South_Korea_men's_national_under-18_ice_hockey_team South_Korea_Davis_Cup_team South_Korea_men's_national_volleyball_team South_Korea_at_the_2012_Summer_Olympics
Rwandan Patriotic Front
Rwandan_Patriotic_Front
Rwanda
Rwanda Rwanda_national_football_team Kingdom_of_Rwanda Rwandese_Association_Football_Federation Rwandan_genocide International_Criminal_Tribunal_for_Rwanda United_Nations_Assistance_Mission_for_Rwanda Rwanda_national_basketball_team Rwandan_Defence_Forces Province_of_the_Anglican_Church_of_Rwanda Elections_in_Rwanda Rwanda_national_cricket_team LGBT_rights_in_Rwanda Football_in_Rwanda Rwanda_national_rugby_union_team Water_supply_and_sanitation_in_Rwanda
Kagame
Paul_Kagame
Friday
Kagame
Paul_Kagame
Rwandans
Victoire Ingabire
Victoire_Ingabire_Umuhoza
Hutu
Hutu Ascarina_lucida
Kagame
Paul_Kagame
General
Faustin Kayumba Nyamwasa
Kayumba_Nyamwasa
Kagame
Paul_Kagame
February
June
South Africa
South_Africa South_Africa_national_cricket_team South_Africa_national_rugby_union_team South_Africa_national_football_team Union_of_South_Africa South_African_Rugby_Union A1_Team_South_Africa South_Africa_women's_national_cricket_team Same-sex_marriage_in_South_Africa South_Africa_national_rugby_league_team South_Africa_women's_national_football_team South_African_Football_Association South_Africa_national_rugby_sevens_team South_African_wine South_Africa_Fed_Cup_team South_Africa_national_baseball_team
capital
Kigali
Kigali Kigali_International_Airport Roman_Catholic_Archdiocese_of_Kigali Tarlac_City Kigali_Genocide_Memorial_Centre A.S._Kigali
Andre Kagwa Rwisereka
André_Kagwa_Rwisereka
opposition
Democratic Green Party of Rwanda
Democratic_Green_Party_of_Rwanda
Frank Habineza
Frank_Habineza
Rwanda
Rwanda Rwanda_national_football_team Kingdom_of_Rwanda Rwandese_Association_Football_Federation Rwandan_genocide International_Criminal_Tribunal_for_Rwanda United_Nations_Assistance_Mission_for_Rwanda Rwanda_national_basketball_team Rwandan_Defence_Forces Province_of_the_Anglican_Church_of_Rwanda Elections_in_Rwanda Rwanda_national_cricket_team LGBT_rights_in_Rwanda Football_in_Rwanda Rwanda_national_rugby_union_team Water_supply_and_sanitation_in_Rwanda
Green Party
Green_Party_of_Switzerland Green_Party_of_England_and_Wales Green_Party_of_the_United_States Green_Party_(Ireland) Green_Party_(Sweden) Green_Party_of_Aotearoa_New_Zealand Alliance_90/The_Greens Green_Party_(Czech_Republic) Green_party Green_Party_of_Canada Green_Party_(UK) Green_Party_(Brazil) Green_Party_(Norway) The_Greens_–_The_Green_Alternative Green_Party_of_British_Columbia Green_Party_in_Northern_Ireland
Deutsche Welle
Deutsche_Welle Deutsche_Welle_GmbH DW-TV
Kigali
Kigali Kigali_International_Airport Roman_Catholic_Archdiocese_of_Kigali Tarlac_City Kigali_Genocide_Memorial_Centre A.S._Kigali
February
Kagame
Paul_Kagame
Kagame
Paul_Kagame
2003
Western
Western_(genre) Western_world Western_culture Western_United_States Western_Province,_Sri_Lanka Western_Province_(Victoria) Western_film Western_Europe Western_comics Western_fiction Western_Conference_(NBA) Western_music_(North_America) Western_Mustangs Western_Province_(Papua_New_Guinea) American_frontier Western_Province_(Kenya)
Rwanda
Rwanda Rwanda_national_football_team Kingdom_of_Rwanda Rwandese_Association_Football_Federation Rwandan_genocide International_Criminal_Tribunal_for_Rwanda United_Nations_Assistance_Mission_for_Rwanda Rwanda_national_basketball_team Rwandan_Defence_Forces Province_of_the_Anglican_Church_of_Rwanda Elections_in_Rwanda Rwanda_national_cricket_team LGBT_rights_in_Rwanda Football_in_Rwanda Rwanda_national_rugby_union_team Water_supply_and_sanitation_in_Rwanda
Western
Western_(genre) Western_world Western_culture Western_United_States Western_Province,_Sri_Lanka Western_Province_(Victoria) Western_film Western_Europe Western_comics Western_fiction Western_Conference_(NBA) Western_music_(North_America) Western_Mustangs Western_Province_(Papua_New_Guinea) American_frontier Western_Province_(Kenya)
Kagame
Paul_Kagame
Tony Blair
Tony_Blair Shadow_Cabinet_of_Tony_Blair Tony_Blair_(song) Prime_Minister_of_the_United_Kingdom Blair_ministry Shadow_Cabinet_of_John_Smith Premiership_of_Tony_Blair
Bill Clinton
Bill_Clinton Presidency_of_Bill_Clinton Impeachment_of_Bill_Clinton Democratic_Party_(United_States) Bill_Clinton_sexual_misconduct_allegations List_of_federal_judges_appointed_by_Bill_Clinton Bill_Clinton_presidential_campaign,_1992
US
United_States Billboard_200 Billboard_Hot_100 Recording_Industry_Association_of_America United_States_dollar Nielsen_SoundScan Billboard_charts Hot_Country_Songs Unincorporated_territories_of_the_United_States Billboard_(magazine) Dance_Club_Songs Federal_government_of_the_United_States American_English RIAA_Certification .us Us_(Peter_Gabriel_album)
evangelist
Rick Warren
Rick_Warren
Google
Google Google_Search Google_(verb) Google_Translate Google_Nexus Alphabet_Inc. Google_Books Google_Chrome Google_Play Google_Search_Appliance Privacy_concerns_regarding_Google Google_Cloud_Platform Google_Maps Google_tax Google_Ad_Grants Google_plus
Starbucks
Starbucks Starbuck_(whaling_family) G.F._Milnes_&_Co. Starbucks_(song) Starbucks_(mixtape) Starbucks_Israel Hear_Music Kara_Thrace
Kagame
Paul_Kagame
Kagame
Paul_Kagame
Rwanda
Rwanda Rwanda_national_football_team Kingdom_of_Rwanda Rwandese_Association_Football_Federation Rwandan_genocide International_Criminal_Tribunal_for_Rwanda United_Nations_Assistance_Mission_for_Rwanda Rwanda_national_basketball_team Rwandan_Defence_Forces Province_of_the_Anglican_Church_of_Rwanda Elections_in_Rwanda Rwanda_national_cricket_team LGBT_rights_in_Rwanda Football_in_Rwanda Rwanda_national_rugby_union_team Water_supply_and_sanitation_in_Rwanda
1994
Britain
Guardian
The_Guardian Legal_guardian Guardian_(DC_Comics) TheGuardian.com Guardian_(band) Custos_(Franciscans) Guardian_(Bahá'í_Faith) GuardiaN Guardian_(Marvel_Comics) Guardian_(song) The_Guardian_(Nigeria) Guardians_of_the_Universe Guardian_(web_series) Guardian_temperament Guardian_(fireboat) Trinidad_and_Tobago_Guardian
Rwanda
Rwanda Rwanda_national_football_team Kingdom_of_Rwanda Rwandese_Association_Football_Federation Rwandan_genocide International_Criminal_Tribunal_for_Rwanda United_Nations_Assistance_Mission_for_Rwanda Rwanda_national_basketball_team Rwandan_Defence_Forces Province_of_the_Anglican_Church_of_Rwanda Elections_in_Rwanda Rwanda_national_cricket_team LGBT_rights_in_Rwanda Football_in_Rwanda Rwanda_national_rugby_union_team Water_supply_and_sanitation_in_Rwanda
analyst
Tull
Tull,_Arkansas Tull_Considine Jethro_Tull_(agriculturist) Fisher_Tull
Kagame
Paul_Kagame
Western
Western_(genre) Western_world Western_culture Western_United_States Western_Province,_Sri_Lanka Western_Province_(Victoria) Western_film Western_Europe Western_comics Western_fiction Western_Conference_(NBA) Western_music_(North_America) Western_Mustangs Western_Province_(Papua_New_Guinea) American_frontier Western_Province_(Kenya)
Author: Kyle James Editor: Rob Mudge
Democratic Green Party of Rwanda
Democratic_Green_Party_of_Rwanda
iptc::11000000 topic::politics type::entity type::organization type::party
Western
Western_world
topic::none type::entity type::loc-x type::location type::other type::regio
Rwanda
Rwanda
slot::in slot::keyword topic::none type::entity type::gpe type::gpe0 type::location
Paul Kagame
Paul_Kagame
gender::male iptc::11000000 slot::keyword topic::politics type::entity type::head_of_state type::person type::politician
Denis Tull
gender::male iptc::11000000 topic::politics type::entity type::person type::politics_per
Rwandans
topic::none type::gpe0-x type::other
Monday
topic::none type::time type::value
president
topic::none type::role type::value
East African
topic::none type::loc-x type::other
Africa
Africa
topic::none type::entity type::location type::regio
German Institute for International and Security Affairs
German_Institute_for_International_and_Security_Affairs
iptc::11000000 topic::politics type::entity type::organization type::policy_institute
Deutsche Welle
Deutsche_Welle
topic::media type::entity type::media type::organization
1994
topic::none type::time type::value
Starbucks
Starbucks
iptc::20000170 topic::business type::company type::entity type::organization
Gulf
Persian_Gulf
topic::none type::entity type::location type::regio
investment firm
topic::none type::role type::value
Dubai World
Dubai_World
iptc::20000170 sector::20000280 topic::business type::company type::entity type::organization
Berlin
Berlin
topic::none type::entity type::gpe type::gpe2 type::location
corruption watchdog
topic::none type::role type::value
Transparency International
Transparency_International
iptc::11000000 topic::politics type::entity type::ngo type::organization
East Africa
East_Africa
topic::none type::entity type::location type::regio
World Bank
World_Bank
iptc::11000000 topic::politics type::entity type::igo type::organization
African
topic::none type::loc-x type::other
Chinese
topic::none type::gpe0-x type::other
South Korea
South_Korea
topic::none type::entity type::gpe type::gpe0 type::location
Rwandan Patriotic Front
Rwandan_Patriotic_Front
iptc::11000000 topic::politics type::entity type::organization type::party
Friday
topic::none type::time type::value
Victoire Ingabire
Victoire_Ingabire_Umuhoza
gender::female iptc::11000000 topic::politics type::entity type::person type::politician
Hutu
Hutu
topic::none type::entity type::ethnicity
General
topic::none type::role type::value
Faustin Kayumba Nyamwasa
Kayumba_Nyamwasa
gender::male iptc::16000000 topic::conflict type::entity type::military_personnel type::person
February
topic::none type::time type::value
June
topic::none type::time type::value
South Africa
South_Africa
topic::none type::entity type::gpe type::gpe0 type::location
capital
topic::none type::role type::value
Kigali
Kigali
topic::none type::entity type::gpe type::gpe2 type::location
Andre Kagwa Rwisereka
André_Kagwa_Rwisereka
gender::male iptc::11000000 topic::politics type::entity type::person type::politician
opposition
topic::none type::role type::value
Frank Habineza
Frank_Habineza
gender::male iptc::11000000 topic::politics type::entity type::person type::politician
2003
topic::none type::time type::value
Tony Blair
Tony_Blair
gender::male iptc::11000000 topic::politics type::entity type::head_of_gov type::person type::politician
Bill Clinton
Bill_Clinton
gender::male iptc::11000000 topic::politics type::entity type::head_of_state type::person type::politician
US
United_States
topic::none type::entity type::gpe type::gpe0 type::location
evangelist
topic::none type::role type::value
Rick Warren
Rick_Warren
gender::male iptc::12000000 topic::religion type::clergy type::entity type::person
Google
Google
iptc::20000170 sector::20000225 topic::business type::company type::entity type::organization
Britain
topic::none type::gpe0-x type::other
Guardian
The_Guardian
topic::media type::entity type::media type::organization
analyst
topic::none type::role type::value
Author: Kyle James Editor: Rob Mudge
topic::none type::footer type::other
China
Germany
United_Kingdom