Oracle loses court fight over software resale rules
A European court has ruled that it's permissible to resell software licenses even if the package has been downloaded directly from the Internet. It sided with a German firm in its legal battle with US giant Oracle.
The European Court of Justice on Tuesday ruled that used software licenses may generally be resold by individuals or companies. The Luxembourg-based court thus sided with the German firm UsedSoft in a protracted legal battle with US software giant Oracle. The ruling made it clear that trade in used software was permissible even if the software had not been shipped on a physical medium such as a CD or DVD, but had been digitally downloaded from the Internet. UsedSoft's business model hinges completely on reselling used packages or legally obtained license keys for them. By reselling the keys to clients, the latter are then able to download the latest version of a given program directly from a company's Internet site and obtain all new updates and patches in the process. Legal clarity Oracle had sued UsedSoft over its business model, trying to prevent buyers of used software licenses from downloading programs again. But the European court ruled that the so-called principle of exhaustion applied whenever software was originally sold to a customer for an unlimited time span, not giving the maker of the software the right to prevent the resale of that software. "The door for the trade in used software has been pushed wide open throughout the European Union," UsedSoft said in a statement, welcoming "perfect legal safety on the market." The court in Luxembourg emphasized, though, that whoever resold pieces of original software and their accompanying licenses must erase every copy on their own computers in advance and was not allowed to keep a copy after resale. hg/mz (AFP, dpa)
Oracle
Oracle_Corporation Oracle_Database Oracle Barbara_Gordon Oracle_machine ORACLE_(teletext) Oracle,_Arizona Pythia The_Oracle_(The_Matrix) Oracle_(comics) Oracle_(Kittie_album) Oracle_(Marvel_Comics) Oracle_(EP) ORACLE_(computer) Oracle_(Michael_Hedges_album) Oracle_Cloud
European court
European_Court_of_Justice European_Court_of_Human_Rights
Internet
Internet Internet_radio Streaming_television Internet_service_provider Internet_access World_Wide_Web Cable_Internet_access Internet_protocol_suite Internet_culture Internet_Party_(New_Zealand) Internet_pornography Internet_art Dot-com_company Top_Internet_Albums Webcomic Online_banking
German
US
United_States Billboard_200 Billboard_Hot_100 Recording_Industry_Association_of_America United_States_dollar Nielsen_SoundScan Billboard_charts Hot_Country_Songs Unincorporated_territories_of_the_United_States Billboard_(magazine) Dance_Club_Songs Federal_government_of_the_United_States American_English RIAA_Certification .us Us_(Peter_Gabriel_album)
Oracle
Oracle_Corporation Oracle_Database Oracle Barbara_Gordon Oracle_machine ORACLE_(teletext) Oracle,_Arizona Pythia The_Oracle_(The_Matrix) Oracle_(comics) Oracle_(Kittie_album) Oracle_(Marvel_Comics) Oracle_(EP) ORACLE_(computer) Oracle_(Michael_Hedges_album) Oracle_Cloud
European Court of Justice
European_Court_of_Justice Court_of_Justice_of_the_European_Union List_of_members_of_the_European_Court_of_Justice List_of_Presidents_of_the_European_Court_of_Justice
Tuesday
Luxembourg
Luxembourg Luxembourg_City Luxembourg_national_football_team Luxembourg_(Belgium) Same-sex_marriage_in_Luxembourg Luxembourg_(canton) House_of_Luxembourg Luxembourg_Football_Federation Luxembourg_national_under-21_football_team Luxembourg_District Luxembourg_railway_station Luxembourg_in_the_Eurovision_Song_Contest Luxembourg_Open Luxembourg_Fed_Cup_team Luxembourg_women's_national_football_team Luxembourg_Davis_Cup_team
German
firm
UsedSoft
UsedSoft
US
United_States Billboard_200 Billboard_Hot_100 Recording_Industry_Association_of_America United_States_dollar Nielsen_SoundScan Billboard_charts Hot_Country_Songs Unincorporated_territories_of_the_United_States Billboard_(magazine) Dance_Club_Songs Federal_government_of_the_United_States American_English RIAA_Certification .us Us_(Peter_Gabriel_album)
software giant
Oracle
Oracle_Corporation Oracle_Database Oracle Barbara_Gordon Oracle_machine ORACLE_(teletext) Oracle,_Arizona Pythia The_Oracle_(The_Matrix) Oracle_(comics) Oracle_(Kittie_album) Oracle_(Marvel_Comics) Oracle_(EP) ORACLE_(computer) Oracle_(Michael_Hedges_album) Oracle_Cloud
CD
Compact_disc Canadian_Forces_Decoration CD_single Compulsory_dance Compact_Disc_Digital_Audio Cadmium Candela CD-ROM Order_of_Distinction České_dráhy Democratic_Centre_(France) Democratic_Centre_(Italy) Constitutional_Democratic_Party_of_Japan Drag_coefficient Cd_(command) Cardinal_(train)
DVD
DVD Miscellaneous_right DVD-Video DVD_single DVD_player Miscellaneous_left Family_Values_Tour_'98_(DVD) Full_Moon_in_St._Petersburg Au_cœur_du_stade_(video) Oricon Music_video DVD-Audio Nature's_Best_DVD Pulse_(1995_film) Interactive_movie Stargate_SG-1_DVD
Internet
Internet Internet_radio Streaming_television Internet_service_provider Internet_access World_Wide_Web Cable_Internet_access Internet_protocol_suite Internet_culture Internet_Party_(New_Zealand) Internet_pornography Internet_art Dot-com_company Top_Internet_Albums Webcomic Online_banking
UsedSoft
UsedSoft
Internet
Internet Internet_radio Streaming_television Internet_service_provider Internet_access World_Wide_Web Cable_Internet_access Internet_protocol_suite Internet_culture Internet_Party_(New_Zealand) Internet_pornography Internet_art Dot-com_company Top_Internet_Albums Webcomic Online_banking
Oracle
Oracle_Corporation Oracle_Database Oracle Barbara_Gordon Oracle_machine ORACLE_(teletext) Oracle,_Arizona Pythia The_Oracle_(The_Matrix) Oracle_(comics) Oracle_(Kittie_album) Oracle_(Marvel_Comics) Oracle_(EP) ORACLE_(computer) Oracle_(Michael_Hedges_album) Oracle_Cloud
UsedSoft
UsedSoft
European court
European_Court_of_Justice European_Court_of_Human_Rights
European Union
European_Union European_Boxing_Union Member_state_of_the_European_Union European_Union_(resistance_group) Citizenship_of_the_European_Union Renewable_energy_in_the_European_Union European_Union_law Accession_of_Albania_to_the_European_Union Elections_to_the_European_Parliament Solar_energy_in_the_European_Union European_Union_Special_Representative European_Economic_Community Flag_of_Europe Pakistan–European_Union_relations LGBT_rights_in_the_European_Union History_of_the_European_Union
UsedSoft
UsedSoft
Luxembourg
Luxembourg Luxembourg_City Luxembourg_national_football_team Luxembourg_(Belgium) Same-sex_marriage_in_Luxembourg Luxembourg_(canton) House_of_Luxembourg Luxembourg_Football_Federation Luxembourg_national_under-21_football_team Luxembourg_District Luxembourg_railway_station Luxembourg_in_the_Eurovision_Song_Contest Luxembourg_Open Luxembourg_Fed_Cup_team Luxembourg_women's_national_football_team Luxembourg_Davis_Cup_team
hg/mz (AFP, dpa)
European Court of Justice
European_Court_of_Justice
iptc::02000000 slot::keyword topic::justice type::court type::entity type::organization
Oracle
Oracle_Corporation
iptc::20000170 sector::20000231 slot::keyword topic::business type::company type::entity type::organization
UsedSoft
UsedSoft
iptc::20000170 sector::20000231 slot::keyword topic::business type::company type::entity type::organization
European Union
European_Union
iptc::11000000 slot::in slot::keyword topic::politics type::entity type::igo type::organization type::so
Internet
Internet
iptc::13000000 topic::science type::entity type::misc type::technology
German
topic::none type::gpe0-x type::other
US
United_States
topic::none type::entity type::gpe type::gpe0 type::location
Tuesday
topic::none type::time type::value
Luxembourg
Luxembourg
topic::none type::entity type::gpe type::gpe0 type::location
firm
topic::none type::role type::value
software giant
topic::none type::role type::value
CD
Compact_disc
iptc::13000000 topic::science type::entity type::misc type::technology
DVD
DVD
iptc::13000000 topic::science type::entity type::misc type::technology
hg/mz (AFP, dpa)
topic::none type::footer type::other
Germany