Women's World Cup gender tests 'ridiculous'
Female athletes are increasingly forced to pass gender verification tests. Medical ethicist Claudia Wiesemann says the tests are not just "ridiculous," but can have humiliating consequences.
DW: The German Women's National Soccer Team had to supply medical confirmation that all players were indeed women in order to be allowed to play in the Women's World Cup in Canada this summer. What does "gender verification" entail? Is it just a little peek down where the sun doesn't shine? Claudia Wiesemann: Well, at first it was, in the 50s and 60s. Back then, it was a purely phyiscal test. Later, it was examined whether the athletes had two X chromosomes. Men usually have an X and a Ychromosome. Then came more thorough physical tests, which included an exam of the organs in the abdomen. Today, hormone levels are tested in the blood - so how much testosterone a woman has in her blood. Is it complicated to measure that? Not really. It's pretty easy to examine testosterone levels. What's harder is interpreting the results. Why is that? There's no such thing as definite gender verification. Women can have very high levels of testosterone, but their bodies can be completely insensitive to the effects. Some people are more sensitive to testosterone, others less. Women can even have a Y chromosome and still have a female physique. Men and women are merely two extremes of a continuum, and, between these extremes, many different types are possible. How have attitudes developed within international sports associations? The International Olympic Committee (IOC,) for example, has introduced rules regarding testosterone levels. That was the IOC's way of reacting to massive criticism of previous tests, which were discriminating and didn't yield accurate results. But the testosterone examination is no different. In order for a woman to compete in a women's competition, the IOC demands she has lower testosterone levels than a man. But that's a purely arbitrary cut-off. There are women who undoubtedly grew up as females, but have higher-than-average testosterone levels. That makes them better athletes - just like a man who's taller than two meters (6'6'') is a better basketball player, because he's taller than average. Supporters of gender verification say that if women with heightened testosterone levels compete alongside other female athletes, it's unfair and distorts the competition. How do you respond to that? A physical advantage will always influence how the competition goes. That's also true for the basketball player who's taller than two meters, but we'd never entertain the idea of disqualifying him because of an unfair advantage. We have to provide a reason why a certain advantage is so unfair that it merits disqualification. Additionally, we have to think about the damage we'd be doing by excluding someone from the competition because of a purportedly wrong gender. What kind of detrimental effect could that have? There can be major damage. One female athlete from India [Santhi Soundarajan, eds. note] was publicly called a liar and a cheater when a gender verification exam showed she had a Y chromosome. She tried to kill herself because of the hostility and humiliation that ensued. How often do intersexual people whose gender cannot biologically be determined, face this issue? That's a big problem for them. The fact that intersex individuals exist is not widely known in society. Instead, most people think that it should be easy to tell the difference between man and woman. While that's true for 99.9 percent of cases, it's not the case for the remaining 0.1 percent. Going back to the German Women's National Team: According to media reports, the players had to present a kind of medical certificate from their gynecologists, confirming that they are indeed all women. What do you think about that? I find it disastrous that national associations are participating in this madness. They really are in a tough situation, though. They can't suddenly protest and say "Fine, then we're not coming" right before such an important competition. That's the perfidious aspect of the international associations' policy. They're simply passing the buck to the national associations. And they in turn pass that pressure on to the athletes, saying: "Either you participate in this pseudo-medical exam, or you can't compete." Claudia Wiesemann is a medical ethicist and director of the Institute for Ethics and History of Medicine at the University of Göttingen.
Women's World Cup
FIFA_Women's_World_Cup 1991_FIFA_Women's_World_Cup 2009_Women's_Cricket_World_Cup Women's_Cricket_World_Cup 2010_Women's_Hockey_World_Cup 2015_FIFA_Women's_World_Cup 2007_FIFA_Women's_World_Cup FIVB_Volleyball_Women's_World_Cup Table_Tennis_World_Cup 1995_FIFA_Women's_World_Cup 1999_FIFA_Women's_World_Cup 2010_Women's_Rugby_World_Cup 2011_UCI_Women's_Road_World_Cup 1990_Women's_Hockey_World_Cup 2002_Women's_Hockey_World_Cup FIBA_Women's_Basketball_World_Cup
Claudia Wiesemann
Claudia_Wiesemann
DW
Drum_Workshop Deutsche_Welle DW-TV Defender_(association_football) Dreamworld_(Australian_theme_park) Data_warehouse Delhi_Wizards D.W._Read DW Discworld
German Women's National Soccer Team
Women's World Cup
FIFA_Women's_World_Cup 1991_FIFA_Women's_World_Cup 2009_Women's_Cricket_World_Cup Women's_Cricket_World_Cup 2010_Women's_Hockey_World_Cup 2015_FIFA_Women's_World_Cup 2007_FIFA_Women's_World_Cup FIVB_Volleyball_Women's_World_Cup Table_Tennis_World_Cup 1995_FIFA_Women's_World_Cup 1999_FIFA_Women's_World_Cup 2010_Women's_Rugby_World_Cup 2011_UCI_Women's_Road_World_Cup 1990_Women's_Hockey_World_Cup 2002_Women's_Hockey_World_Cup FIBA_Women's_Basketball_World_Cup
Canada
Canada Canada_men's_national_ice_hockey_team Canada_men's_national_soccer_team Canada_national_rugby_union_team Canada_national_cricket_team Canada_men's_national_junior_ice_hockey_team Canadian_poetry Canada_women's_national_soccer_team Canadian_Open_(tennis) RPM_(magazine) Canadian_Soccer_Association Canada_(New_France) A1_Team_Canada Music_Canada Same-sex_marriage_in_Canada Canada_men's_national_basketball_team
Claudia Wiesemann
Claudia_Wiesemann
International Olympic Committee
International_Olympic_Committee List_of_members_of_the_International_Olympic_Committee President_of_the_International_Olympic_Committee
IOC
International_Olympic_Committee International_Ornithologists'_Union List_of_IOC_country_codes Indian_Oil_Corporation Birds_of_the_World:_Recommended_English_Names Intergovernmental_Oceanographic_Commission Inversion_of_control Initial_operating_capability Korukkupet Iron_Ore_Company_of_Canada
IOC
International_Olympic_Committee International_Ornithologists'_Union List_of_IOC_country_codes Indian_Oil_Corporation Birds_of_the_World:_Recommended_English_Names Intergovernmental_Oceanographic_Commission Inversion_of_control Initial_operating_capability Korukkupet Iron_Ore_Company_of_Canada
IOC
International_Olympic_Committee International_Ornithologists'_Union List_of_IOC_country_codes Indian_Oil_Corporation Birds_of_the_World:_Recommended_English_Names Intergovernmental_Oceanographic_Commission Inversion_of_control Initial_operating_capability Korukkupet Iron_Ore_Company_of_Canada
India
India India_national_cricket_team British_Raj India_national_football_team Presidencies_and_provinces_of_British_India India_women's_national_cricket_team Indian_poetry A1_Team_India Indian_subcontinent History_of_India India_men's_national_field_hockey_team Dominion_of_India Elections_in_India Cinema_of_India La_India India_Davis_Cup_team
Santhi Soundarajan
Santhi_Soundarajan
German Women's National Team
Germany_women's_national_volleyball_team Germany_women's_national_football_team Germany_women's_national_ice_hockey_team Germany_women's_national_handball_team
Claudia Wiesemann
Claudia_Wiesemann
Institute for Ethics and History of Medicine
University of Göttingen
University_of_Göttingen
German Women's National Soccer Team
Germany_women's_national_football_team
iptc::15000000 sport::20000827 topic::sport type::entity type::organization type::sport_team
Women's World Cup
FIFA_Women's_World_Cup
iptc::15000000 slot::keyword sport::20000827 sport_event::20001122 topic::sport type::competition type::entity type::event type::sport_competition
Claudia Wiesemann
Claudia_Wiesemann
gender::female meta::todo slot::keyword topic::none type::entity type::person
International Olympic Committee
International_Olympic_Committee
iptc::15000000 slot::keyword sport::unknown topic::sport type::entity type::organization type::sport_org
DW
Deutsche_Welle
topic::media type::entity type::media type::organization
Canada
Canada
slot::in topic::none type::entity type::gpe type::gpe0 type::location
India
India
topic::none type::entity type::gpe type::gpe0 type::location
Santhi Soundarajan
Santhi_Soundarajan
gender::female iptc::15000000 sport::20000827 topic::sport type::entity type::person type::sport_player
Institute for Ethics and History of Medicine
iptc::13000000 topic::science type::entity type::organization type::research_center
University of Göttingen
University_of_Göttingen
iptc::05000000 topic::education type::education_org type::entity type::organization
Germany