 O'Neill reconfigured his team by moving McNamara back to fill the gap in defence caused by Baldé's dismissal.The first half of extra time arrived without a change in the score, so the silver goal rule did not apply.In the second half of extra time Celtic were unable to hold out for penalties, as Derlei reacted quickest to a Douglas block in the 115th minute and rounded McNamara to make it 3–2.