 They were champions in 1971 and runners-up in 1972 and 1975.Hellenic reached the final of the Cup competition then widely known as "Castle Cup" in 1976, losing 2–0 to Cape Town City.In 1994 Hellenic lost the final of the NSL/PSL League Cup, then known as "Coca-Cola Cup", losing to QwaQwa Stars 2-3 after extra time.