 Carrier argues that no one "who quotes this text is quoting what Hitler actually said".In the new foreword to the "Table Talk", Gerhard Weinberg commented that "Carrier has shown the English text of the table-talk that originally appeared in 1953 and is reprinted here derives from Genoud's French edition and not from one of the German texts".Citing Carrier's paper Diethelm Prowe remarked that Trevor-Roper's "Table Talk" "has been proven to be wholly unreliable as a source almost a decade ago".