 Gwathmey averaged 11.4 points, 5.4 rebounds and 1.3 blocks in four seasons at James Madison.She is a three-time Colonial Athletic Association Player of the Year and CAA Tournament Most Outstanding Player winning the awards in 2014, 2015 and 2016.Source

Gwathmey was drafted 14th overall in the second round by the Minnesota Lynx in the 2016 WNBA draft.