 After a 1–0 away defeat on 16 July, Cerro Porteño hosted the return leg at the Estadio Defensores del Chaco on 22 July.Caballero scored in the 4th minute of the match to level the scores 1–1 on aggregate, however, the match ultimately concluded in a 2–1 for Cerro Porteño, being 2–2 on aggregate.Barcelona went on to win via penalties, with Barcelona goal keeper José Cevallos saving Caballero's and two other of Cerro Porteño's penalties, eliminating Cerro Porteño from the competition.