 The series conducted an online poll where fans voted between a performance from Constantine and Phoebe, and one from Phoebe and Rick Forrester (then-Kyle Lowder).During the concert, Constantine is joined by Elliott Yamin, third runner up in season five of "American Idol", and singer-songwriter Jon McLaughlin.Each sing real-life singles; Yamin performs "Wait For You," McLaughlin performs "Beautiful Disaster" and Maroulis performs "Fading Into You".