The earliest compelling evidence for human habitation of the Americas comes from the Clovis complex, between 11,050 and 10,800 C yr B.P. However, a series of human tracks were identified at White Sands National Park, New Mexico, which have been dated contentiously dated to between 23,000 and 21,000 years ago - during the Last Glacial Maximum. Alongside anatomically modern humans, the trackway shows impressions created by a Columbian mammoth and a giant ground sloth. The upper biostratigraphic limit for when the impressions were made could therefore be determined by consideration of the extinction dates of mammoths and ground sloths. More precise dates were able to be gained via radiocarbon dating of ditch grass (ruppia cirrhosa) embedded in the prints. These seeds produced a date of 23,000-21,000 years ago.
However, C dates are not infallible, and this remains a topic of debate. A recent counterproposal posits that the trackways were, in fact, created by the Clovis culture and the pre-existing proposed dates of first habitation should not be moved. False dates may have been produced as older strata containing the seeds could have been eroded and displaced onto the damp clay, before being impressed in by footsteps. Alternatively, aquatic plants like ditch grass reflect the C levels in their environment when living, if C was deficient in the habitat, this could imply a false date.