Below is the list of tables from the database along with their columns and datatype. Need to generate an accurate SQL query for the question.
Only use the columns present in the respective table. Only use the columns which are required to generate the SQL query. Only use table joins if required and not otherwise.

### Tables ###
TABLE: CREATE TABLE table_24108789_4 ( before VARCHAR, player VARCHAR )

### Question ###
List all before numbers when Geoff Ogilvy was playing.

### Accurate SQL ###

SELECT before FROM table_24108789_4 WHERE player = "Geoff Ogilvy"