We were very disappointed based on what we thought we were ordering. The title is misleading. "Dog Whisperer" and "Beginning" dog training fall a bit short of my expected content."Whisperer" should involve emulating how the animal interacts in the wild. The horse Whisper takes control of the horse by emulating the lead stallion in the herd. A dog whisperer should be able to control a dog by emulating the alpha dog in the pack. This DVD illustrates basic treat reward dog training and has nothing do do with dog whispering per my expectation."Beginning" training should include how to house train (not even mentioned in this DVD) and how to get the puppy to stop mouthing/biting when playing (a common behavior that needs fixing). If the DVD touches on this it is very subtle. We have a new puppy (3 months old) and need to solve these 2 problems. This was THE reason for purchasing this DVD but it fell way short. We returned it.