I prefer to form my own opinion, but the other reviewers are on target. The films are excellent as you might expect from Murnau and Borzage. The DVD's arrive loose in the box looking like they've been sandpapered. I haven't watched them all the way through to ascertain whether they are usable or not, but I'm betting that at least one will not play all the way through. The books (that cause all the damage to the discs) are little more than a collection of still photos. I would not buy this set again and certainly cannot recommend it to anyone who takes care of their things. I expected 20th Century Fox to have produced a more professional product.