this Buckaroo toy would have the big goose egg for a rating. I laughed when I saw the "stinkaroo" comment in another review, because I was thinking the same thing when it was such a huge disappointment in our house. Everyone is right: the saddle doesn't stay on, and we put every piece of the toy together it still doesn't buck. This toy is a major drag. I was really bummed when I ran across the receipt tonight and realized it was almost $20. It's a total waste of cash.