I did not expect high quality stones due to the price, but I certainly didn't expect such horrible quality.Both stones and dull and extremely cloudy. They also have huge inclusions right on their surfaces. They are gray in color (not close to black as shown in the picture). One is darker than the other. Even though their color would hide most flaws, the quality is so obviously poor it would be embarrassing for anyone to wear them.I also would like to note that the white gold settings are not as shown in the picture. The stones are propped up on top of settings so the white gold cannot be seen on the perimeter when viewed directly from the front.I ordered them a couple of days ago but now when I view the item, it says "Item under review" due to customer feedback. I'm guessing other customers have complained about being sent two lumps of coal too!!Returning immediately. Not worth more than $10. You're better off buying something made of plastic from a bead store.