Maybe I shouldn't write a review so quickly, but my 5 year old daughter has only had this toy for 3 hours and I hate it already. She seems to like it, but I agree with the reviewer that says it requires constant adult supervision. The sand is VERY fine and gets everywhere! I've vacuumed twice tonight and finally took away the bottle and sand and told her she had to play with just the dolls. Maybe an older child would get more out of it. I disagree that it would teach a child responsibility for cleaning up after a real cat. You can't control when a real cat pees, and real cat pee has a smell. Perhaps if the sand was stinky, then it would be the MOST obnoxious toy on the market right now.The doll is nice though. I like that she's not as "busty" as Barbie, and so is easier to dress.