My baby liked these cookies alright and she is the appropriate age for them, HOWEVER, they are TOO SMALL FOR BABIES! The cookies are just small enough that she can easily stuff the whole thing in her mouth. The first time she did this and began to choke I thought it was just a fluke. I had to fish the cookie out of her mouth. The next time I gave her one of the cookies, she did the same thing so I immediately threw the rest of the package away. We have since gone back to buying Earth's Best teething biscuits which are much safer.I wouldn't recommend these to anyone!