If, after a dozen years or so, this is all that Paul Simon has to say then it would have been best if he had waited another decade before attempting a new album. If he's all done then so be it. He's made remarkable music all of his life, the kind of soul catching music I grew up on both simple and complex-always memorable, engaging songs with which I can mark my own life. Unfortunately this new album is a once great fighter, dressed up like an indian chief, sadly dancing circles in the ring - not pretty, not memomorable and not worth the price of admission.