The theatrical editions are excelent, no doubt about it. But that's not what we're discussing here. The issue here is what the studio is doing with this release. There's no excuse for not delivering the theatrical and extended in one package. We want the extended. Is Peter Jackson considering adding more scenes for the Blu-Ray extended edition? And that's the reason of the delay? Come on. Give us the extended and then, on 2012, give us that version, whatever you wanna call it.Guys, do not buy this crap!