These chimes are very attractive, are well made, and sound beautiful. I have several of the Woodstock Encore chimes (all but the very largest in the line) and they are completely harmonious together. Having the variety of lower and higher pitches makes for a very melodious sound without being overly loud when the wind blows.The only thing I don't like -- and the only reason I deducted a star -- is that after two seasons, even if I bring them in when the cold weather arrives, the wood platform starts to dry out and the strings that hold the tubes degrade and break or come lose from the platform. I try to bring them in when it rains in order to try to prolong their life, but I am not sure how much it helps.