The cheese plate and the handle of the slicer are very nice. The blade was scuffed (the best word I can come up with). This tray was purchased to go with the Winterberry dinnerware set. This is not fine china, rather it is very nice stoneware that is sturdy yet appears very elegant because of the delicate decor. All pieces came intact and there were no flaws in any of the pieces, with the exception of this one blade. Every piece purchased was on sale, making it easier to buy extra pieces.