I'am sick and tired of the controversy bewteen Pink FLoyd. All these people fighting over who did all the work on each album.I personaly LOVE this album, but I also love Piper at the gates of dawn. ahhh! Now theres Syd, the original main man, and heres Roger, our new main man. See how i like BOTH?!?Pink Floyd are a truly amazing band. Each one of there albums sound almost nothing like the one they did before that.....example----compare Wish you were here with Animals, or Meddle to Atom Heart mother. ALL OF THEM are insanely awsome. I dont make any controversy over...oh this is Roger...or ohh this is all Gilmour! PINK FLOYD IS PINK FLOYD!I hope you have seen my point.But then again...im only 14.