This is usually the type of cd a band releases early in their career, when they still have only a cult following. As their proficiency in their craft grows, then so does their following. APC takes a huge step backward with this release, which would indicate that it is nothing more than a lame vanity project. If your a fan of APC, and are quite impressed with the quality of music they have put forth so far, you better demo this cd first rather than just run out and buy it. I'm certain a lot of consumers are going to feel completely cheated with this purchase. The only good reviews are coming from die hard fans, and they would probably write great reviews if Keenan were to cover the Muppets Movie soundtrack. Most of the bad reviews are accurate.