Our daughter outgrew her Britax Roundabout. We bought the Eddie Bauer seat as a replacement because it would saftely hold our tall child. The Britax seat is much higher quality in all aspects: the frabic, cushion, belt fastners, etc. We are just used to the extra niceties of our Britax seat and dislike the Eddie Bauer because it isn't as nice. I would definately spend the extra money on another Britax before buying an Eddie Bauer.