The first Chronicles of Thomas Covenant were unique and breathtaking. The second Chronicles were not nearly as satisfying but at least Donaldson's ability to create fantasical creatures and situations made the books worth reading. Unfortunately, this seventh novel appears to simply recycle old ideas and characters that have been fully explored -- often using plot devices that defy even an indulgent reader from suspending disbelief. Indeed, with the exception of Donaldson's unusual style of writing prose, this novel seems to be what an avid fan of limited imagination would write if allowed to author a book in Donaldon's place. In short, Donaldson has returned to the land one time too many times given his ability to realize new characters and plot devices.