It's very hard to clam up ur feeling here;however, u have to realize that this is waters not floyd! please stop the comparisons! i personally think it's a great remake,well put! different!change is good! the instrumental solos r marvelously played with an extra touch! with the short time waters had to set it up! i think it's one of the best shows i have ever seen!with a nice finale! again it's waters so don't expect floyd! some people think waters is pink! in a way he is!the driving force!now he's solo! so accept him for what he is! as a pointer to all who have not seen him on stage, u don't know what ur missing! would really make u ponder who pink is?he's touring again so check him out!waters writing's definately unique unlike any other, where u'd see loads of effort put into his work!just right! as jeff beck said "waters' is a great director and song- writer" and u'll see that in berlin- the wall! check "amused to death"as well!