Live in Brooklyn has all of the jamming and spontaneity of Live04 Drum Logos, and all of the passion of Hampton Comes Alive. For phans, that's not a ringing endorsement....There are some bright spots (an awesome, rollicking Suzy Greenberg!), some are downright lame (Dinner and a Movie is a waste of a song, and that's the worst Divided Sky I've ever heard), but most are just...average. Phish's average is better than most bands really good, but we have higher standards.