This consists of a 2 disk set. Disk 1 is live and no new ground is broken here. Trent has the unfortunate tendancy to record the same stuff over and over again. It may be live, it may be well-recorded, but you've heard all this before. Disk 2 is simply nothing special. Generally quiet, generally piano driven and gnerally boring. Anyone who collects all of NIN will want this to complete their collection but I predict that most people will listen to the studio albums and leave this on the shelf.