I have been using Hope in a Jar for a few years now. I decided to order this online because it was a few dollars cheaper than Sephora. What I received is a watered down version of Hope in Jar. It's runny and has almost no scent at all. I happen to love the scent of HIAJ and the light consistency is what I love best. What I got is runny and greasy. I have used it a couple of times and thought I was losing my mind until I read a few other reviews and saw that I'm not the only one. Hopefully I will get a full refund. In the future I will spend the extra few bucks and buy it from Sephora.