I had the pleasure of meeting the author this week at North Dakota State University. As a former young-earth creationist, I can safely say that Dr. Scott has an excellent understanding of creationism. She is passionate, but she does not let her passion degrade into ad hominem or strawman attacks on creationists and their claims. Seriously, if you want an author who truly understands both sides of this non-debate, seek out Dr. Scott's work! She will rake garbage "scholarship" over the coals, but it is never undeserved, immature, or irrational. Wish I could say the same for Richard Dawkins!