Pros: This is a great toy. Our golden retriever could chase it forever. It's great in a lake, pond, beach (be careful of waves) or also in a field. It never had a problem floating. The rope allows you to throw it a good distance.Cons: Our dog chews through the rope if unsupervised. It doesn't last long if she gets to it and chews it. So...we put it away when we're not using it. Problem solved.Beat dog toy ever! This is her favorite toy by far!