I love & have loved Peter Gabriel for many years. He is a brilliant, intuitive, insighful artist. I saw him perform live last December 2002 from first row seats. He is a fabulous live performer. I was and still am terribly disappointed by "Up." It is muddy and overproduced. I remember unwrapping the CD in my car immediately after purchasing it in the store, feeling like a child on Christmas morning, only to open my packages to find dirt & mud & rocks. I don't recommend it. Buy all of his other albums.