I really liked this one. I think that it ended prematurely though. I feel like she developed the characters of Miri and Simon and their relationship really well and although I figured out who the Silver Rose was, the writing was very good as in the other two. But the ending was way too short like Carroll had to meet a deadline or something and rushed in writing the end. I really wanted to read Ariane and Gabrielle's reactions and inevitable acceptance of Simon into their family. Plus the first interaction with Simon and Renard would have been interesting. That is why it gets four stars because there was room for improvement.