This film was well-intentioned but ultimately unconvincing. I didn't mind the inclusion of the animation scenes. But their effect was to reduce the amount of time on the live-action parts. As a result, the character and plot development aspects seemed very rushed and unconvincing. The twists and turns came totally out of left field. The acting of Kieran Culkin and especially Emile Hirsch was very compelling, particularly the non-verbal aspects... though I didn't really buy into Jodie Foster's performance as a hard-nosed nun. This isn't a totally irredeemable movie, but the carelessly rushed character and plot development made for a disappointing end to what seemed like a promising film. I actually give this film 2 1/2 stars but that choice is not offered.