I really enjoyed this book. If you read the first two books the errors and mistakes are still there. Example Matt Dillon a City Marshal. But please overlook that. The stories are still very exciting to read. And we all know the facts so sit back and enjoy the book. It's also good to see Doc back in the story. We all know Dodge wouldnt be Dodge without him. Festus is still very loyal to the Marshal and Kitty and Matt are still going strong and we continue to see that in this 3rd book.Plus I like the fact that all these stories are staying in and around Dodge. And this one has the winter theme to it and I like that because we didnt see alot of shows with the winter scene. Mr. West please continue entertaining us the these stories and I cant wait for May 2 2006 for your 4th book.