I ordered these and just received them last week. My dog won't eat them. There were some samples of some other products included in the box and she loved those, but she won't eat these. The reason for my bad review is this, I think, is the first thing I have ever found that she won't eat. It's a bummer. I am going to try crushing them and mixing them into her food. If I have any luck and see any results, I will leave another review.