Almost the same experience as Anjela Bugher, but not quite as bad. One disc was extremely dirty and scratched all over. Many others had faint to moderate scratches only where they were inserted into the cardboard. I don't know if any of them are unplayable yet though. And I think Season 1 disc two is from the wrong set. All of the other discs say copyright 2006 on the bottom. But this one disc has a different label than the others and says copyright 2001.The show itself is great, but buyer beware on the packaging in this set.