When we started cloth diapering, getting flushable liners was a must for us. We first used Grovia liners. I tried switching to these as they were a little cheaper. Sometimes you get what you pay for. These bunched up and did not do a good job of catching all of the waste. They are much thinner and flimsier than the Grovia liners. We didn't even use them all up before we ended up buying some more Grovia liners. We are pretty much done with diapering, so I have not done anymore research to find an alternative. I would definitely not recommend these, though.