I'm not sure how long the other reviewer had his before he wrote it or what kind of work he did but I've had this for 3 months and it's falling apart already. The pivot bolts that hold the wheel side have literally sheared off. The platic wing nuts that are all over this thing are breaking. I can't say which stand would be better because I haven't tried another yet but I can say for sure that unless you are a once in a while user, you had better not waste your money on this one.