On this song, only about 6 of the contestants shown actually sing. Only 1 of those is one of the female singers (no Carmen Rasmussen, apparently.) The way they sing together sounds terrible. Song is boring. Second track puts even fewer singers. Overall, a boring, worthless cd. I only bought it to get autographed at the American Idol 2 mall tour. I suppose it's good if you want something cheap that has a picture of the top 10 contestants, however small those pictures may be.