It's comfortable and I'm able to get my player in and out of it with no problem. I'm also able to use the controls on my player thru the clear vinyl front with ease. I gave this 4 out of 5 stars only because I think the band is just a little wide. While it doesn't hinder anything, it just take a little getting used to when I've used thinner bands in the past, but I do like the look at feel of this one. The top is completely open but there's no fear of the player coming out as it fits snuggly against my arm. I'd definately recommend the product.