I first heard this album 12 or so years ago and loved it . Out of what I have heard [Sides, PP&P1&3,and a couple of others I can 't recall only Private Parts and Pieces #2 seems as good , if not better.It definetely requires a love of renaissancey english folk type stuff ,and makes you wish genesis had gone this way after Hackett left, or at least after Duke! Collins vocals are beautiful and stark - no megastar bluster or smoothness here.Rutherford seems to pkay the same sort of invisible support guitarist role as in pre 78 genesis -but here there are probably 10 guitar and co. tracks to the tune on some much more. All in all like a walk in Middle-Earth in the spring and fall well into the fourth age in Arnor.