i absolutely LOVED this BOOK. The movie, on the other hand seemed to lack so much story from the book(it condenses about 2-5yrs into 10mo. not to mention a severe lack of war). I understand teh time constraints on the movie, but i believe that Will going to WWII was a very important part in his character developement, as well as changing his standing in Whitney(becoming a war hero and all).i thought both actors did an alright job, but not great, and i couldn't really feel the chemistry in them like i felt between the characters in the book.i also didnt like how the roles of Elly's children in bringing them together(inadvertantly, of course) were played down.OKAY movie, but i would recommend you buy the book, it's much more fulfilling.