"Without Waters" that is. I doubt that Roger could have done much to help this mess of a CD, since his contemporary CD "Radio KAOS" is barely any better. This CD has one good song, the catchy "Learning to Fly", and even it starts to lose its pizazz after 20 or so listens. Most of the hardcore Pink Floyd fans I know tend to be of the "Worship Our Philosophical Musician Gods" mindset. They seem to find deep philosophical meaning in laughable lyrics, worship the singers as near-deities, and rationalize themselves into thinking that awful songs are splendid masterpieces. Being of a more objective mind, I find almost nothing to like about this CD other than the aforementioned Learning To Fly. It's inoffensive enough to serve as background music. Can't say much more for it than that.