I have been a Weezer fan for a long time, and I can't believe that this is what they give us after 5 years. This album is just plain weak--the first album had great well crafted songs, and Pinkerton was great because it was raw and emotional---but this album is derivative, and the songs sound like they should be on a soundtrack. "Hash Pipe" and "Island in the Sun" are the only ones that standout and sound different. I am very happy that Weezer is back, but I am upset with this album...let's hope Weezer works to their potential on their next album.