I have read all the reviews and Idon't agree with it all everyone has different opions and every child is different i have a 13 month baby he love my cell he plays with it for along time it makes no noises and i have a 3 year old that plays with fake cells and likes it I think it all depends on the child not what the adults say noises isn't everything I think if the child likes it thats all that counts so what if it isn't noisey not everything is.