I'm a big Picoult fan, but I have to say this book is quite a disappointment. There were too many main characters and they were not fully developed. I thought the one chapter thrown in from Elise's point of view was out of place. The chapters describing Andrew's time in jail added nothing to the story line. I find it hard to believe that Eric would just walk away from Delia and Sophie and not be the least bit angry about what went on with Delia and Fitz. I also find it hard to believe that someone would simply stand by and watch a friend jump off a cliff. There were too many elements of this story that weren't believable. But even though the story was a disappointment, Picoult tells it in such a way that makes the reader want to find out what's next. I always have a hard time putting her books down which is why I will continue to read her novels.