I've never seen monty roberts in person, never watched another person try his methods, nor do I have anything to say about the people who don't like his methods, but take it from someone who trains, it works. I'ver been using this method of training for 2 years now, and let me tell you, it's a godsend. My horses trust me, are more responsive, handle new situations easily, and work well with all people, not just their trainer. If you have a problem with his methods, you're doing somthing wrong. I've trained over 40 horses in this manor and never have I once had a problem. Maybe the book in itself is a lie, who knows, I personally don't care. If someone is so obsessed with wether it's true or not, you need to get a life. If you get anything out of reading it, it should be that gentlness and trust are what make an equine relationship. As for buying it, rent a copy and save yourself some money.