I usually buy my Charms lollipops at BJ's, but they only sell the assorted box. That is why I was willing to pay more for this product. When I received the package the box looked old. Like it had been setting around a warehouse for some time. I decided to try one and regretted it. The lollipops are way past their "freshness" date. They are nasty. Don't waste your money purchasing from this seller. I wish I would have read the reviews before I spent my money. I requested a refund. I think I'll stick to buying them at BJ's where the lollipops look and taste fresh.