Scottie's attention was fully focused on this toy as I unwrapped it. I took it outside where husband was sitting and said, "I give it less than 20 seconds", then tossed it over to Scottie. Within the allotted timeframe, the duck's hard quacking mechanism was broken and duck's tail was next on his list. Like another reviewer, it was fun to watch the sheer 20 seconds of joy but the toy does not stand up to my dog. As a caution, the toy is much smaller than I expected and could be swallowed and cause a choking hazard for any but the smallest of dogs.I've purchased other toys by this manufacturer and they have been winners. Unfortunately, this toy would do best with a small, gentle dog rather than a rough-and-tumble Scottish Terrier!