I love high-end beauty products and this one is no exception. It has its pros and cons just like any product, but it's the best mascara I've tried so far. I have half-decent lashes to start with, but this mascara really does get them long, lush and dramatic the way I like them! It can be a bit clumpy if you're not careful, but that's nothing a careful application and an eyelash comb can't fix. With that said, this product probably isn't for the casual makeup wearer. It comes off completely and easily with water and your usual face wash, but that also means you have to be careful if you cry. The first dramatic mascara I tried was Benefit's BagGal Lash, but I found that it didn't get my lashes as thick as DiorShow, and it dried out very quickly, within a month (and no, I do not pump the wand!) DiorShow wins! I am now a repeat customer. I give it about a 4 1/2 out of 5.