I had been waiting to see this movie. I loved the Original London Cast, seen it performed in L.A. live 4 times. But this is really terrible. Butler might do well acting the part but his singing has less to do with the POTO that has become a favorite with theater goers and has more in common with Rock version sung by Steve Harley. Though Harley sings the title song better. His breathy voice leaves much to be desired. Is this suppose to be he Angel of Music???Emmy Rossum voice is sweet and lovely but nothing impressionable. I've heard many Christine's (yes even better than Ms. Sarah Brightman) and many real opera sopranos. The vocal roles are so unique it defies the norm of musical theater. It is really such a shame that this production didn't take the time and effort to find real vocal talent, instead of finding the right face.I'll still go and watch the film, but stay clear away from this recording.