if it was you is a different sound for the girls from vancouver. this cd is quite different from previous offerings from tegan and sara. at first i was a little put off by the "rock" sound that blasted into my ears when i was expecting a folk acoustic soound. upon listening to this cd multiple times i have come to really appreciate it. the rock edge is done well and live these two really are absolutly brilliant. pick it up, listen to it a few times and you will find it just might be one of those cds that don't leave the player very often