Roaster does a great job, looks nice too if you're worried about that. Cleans up well. Would be great if it were constructed out of a bit heavier gauged steel but for the price what should one expect. I originally wanted a Calphalon (big fan of their pans) but this was more budget friendly. I'd buy it again. As far as size, we have a 12 lb turkey at Thanksgiving and this was about as big as I'd go in this roaster, so if you routinely have large gathering at the Holidays and roast larger turkeys you might want to consider a larger model.