In my opinion, a lot of the music just doesn't fit with the plot of the movie. Had this been American Pie or American Pie 2, your Good Charlotte's, Avril Lavigne's, and other pop-punk that seems to be dominating the airwaves would have fit perfectly, maybe, but honestly, some of the songs really were just thrown in and really didn't fit with the scenes. The people behind advertising were greatly going for sales. I thought that American Pie 2 had great music in the background. Full of a mixture of known and not-so known artists, but the music was quality for what it was. I think the greatest music is the more adult music. Your Joseph Arthur, Wallflowers , Matt Nathanson cover, Norah Jones, etc. fits perfectly with the whole growing, marriage vibe that's demonstrated in the beginning and end of the movie. This is not worth the $14-$15 I would probably pay for this. If you like the pop-punk stuff, get this. It's probably for you, otherwise, don't bother.