First of all there is a bag of BUCKWHEAT inside this product! If you look on the list of toxic substances for animals buckwheat is on the list!! What kind of a company would put a toxic substance in a dog toy? Soo stupid!! Yes, it was good for keeping him company as a two month old puppy. But as soon as he was ready to chew on it It was harmful to him. I took the bag out and my dog loves playing the the toy case. But im sure a piece of cloth would have been just as good.